Re: X11Forward and xauth problems

[Jon TURNEY <jon.turney@dronecode.org.uk>]

On 26/03/2015 22:06, Andrew DeFaria wrote:
> On 3/26/2015 12:12 PM, Jon TURNEY wrote:
>> On 25/03/2015 17:40, Andrew DeFaria wrote:
>>> Prediction: This problem probably will end up having something to do
>>> with the permissions and file system that ~/.Xauthority resides on,
>>> which is, I believe, a NetApp. This file system is the file system for
>>> the Linux Home directories (Windows "home" directories are somewhere
>>> else). In an attempt to have a transparently workable environment I set
>>> my Cygwin home directory to access the same directory my Linux servers
>>> use for the home directory - this NetApp. If you need more information
>>> about that then let me know and perhaps tell me how I can get that.
>>
>> This seems very plausible.
>>
>> If I am understanding you correctly, ~/.Xauthority is the same file on
>> the NetApp at both ends.  I think perhaps that is somehow the cause of
>> the problem.
>
> Yes.
>>
>> The sequence of actions is something like:
>>
>> - startx(|win) generates a random cookie and stores it in
>> ~/.serverauth.<pid> and uses that file as the server -auth option
>> - it also uses 'xauth add' to put that cookie into ~/.Xauthority for the
>> display (e.g. :0)
>
> I'm not using startx - I just do C:\Cygwin\bin\XWin.exe -multiwindow
> -listen tcp

Sorry, I don't think you had mentioned that before.

It's even simpler then:

- ssh looks for a cookie for $DISPLAY (e.g. :0) in ~/.Xauthority using 
'xauth list',  discovers there isn't one so makes one up and sends it to 
the far end (this what "Warning: No xauth data; using fake 
authentication data for X11 forwarding." is telling you)
- sshd tries to store that cookie using xauth for the proxy display (e.g 
:10)

>> Reading the source of xauth [1], it does try to lock the ~/.Xauthority
>> file for up to 20 seconds before giving up, which perhaps corresponds to
>> the delay you see?
>
> Sounds plausible. Is that configurable?

Unfortunately, no.

Possibly you could set XAuthLocation in ssh(|d)_config to a wrapper 
script which uses 'xauth -i' to ignore locks.

Does 20 seconds actually match the length of the delay you see?

>> However, the "unable to link authority file .Xauthority, use
>> .Xauthority-n" message indicates that the working file .Xauthority-n
>> cannot renamed as .Xauthority (xauth tries both to hard-link it as
>> .Xauthority, and to rename it)
>
> After I ssh -X to this system I do see ~/.Xauthority and
> ~/.Xauthority-n. They are the same size but differ binarily. I can do mv
> ~/.Xauthority-n ~/.Xauthority without issue. Why can't sshd do that?
>
> Once I rename the file X clients work! From that machine...

> So the plot thickens... Why was mv denied permission when I can easily
> do it once I get a prompt?

It kind of looks like perhaps there is some kind of delay in releasing 
the file lock?

You might like to try running something like 'xauth -f ~/foo add :99 . 
`mcookie`' at both ends in rapid succession and see if that works or 
fails in the same way?

> Any idea why setting ForwardX11 yes and ForwardX11Trusted don't seem to
> work? I thought it was that setting ForwardX11 yes is equivalent to
> specifying -X and setting ForwardX11Trusted yes is equivalent to
> specifying -Y but they are not behaving that way!
>
> Adefaria-lt:echo "ForwardX11 yes" > ~/.ssh/config
> Adefaria-lt:ssh cm-db-ldev01 "echo DISPLAY = \'\$DISPLAY\'"
> Warning: untrusted X11 forwarding setup failed: xauth key data not
> generated
> Warning: No xauth data; using fake authentication data for X11 forwarding.
> X11 forwarding request failed on channel 0

This seems to be a separate question, but the first thing I would check 
is if is X11Forwarding permitted by the sshd_config on cm-db-ldev01?

> I find all of this behavior erratic and unreliable.

Indeed.  But I think that the erratic and unreliable thing is the 
networked file system, not ssh.

-- 
Jon TURNEY
Volunteer Cygwin/X X Server maintainer

--
Problem reports:       http://cygwin.com/problems.html
FAQ:                   http://cygwin.com/faq/
Documentation:         http://cygwin.com/docs.html
Unsubscribe info:      http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple