Whoops, doesn't look like my reply made it to the mailing list. Forwarding
there for posterity

---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Adrian Vovk <adrianvovk@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, Feb 1, 2023, 15:15
Subject: Re: [PATCH] find-debuginfo: Stop depending on RPM_* environment
variables
To: Mark Wielaard <mark@klomp.org>


Hi Mark,

I've been using this [1] in my distro's build system since I first posted
the patch, but I honestly don't recall what testing I did. I definitely
didn't set up any kinds of test cases; I would have tested it by hand.

In my distro, I used to just set the RPM env vars [2], and then I just
ported it over to my positional arguments when I created the patch [3], and
it works the same IIRC.

Thanks,
Adrian

[1]:
https://gitlab.com/carbonOS/build-meta/-/blob/main/include/config/strip.yml#L9
[2]:
https://gitlab.com/carbonOS/build-meta/-/blob/6a633eabc156f7a577e6d56ff0976d58482743da/include/config/strip.yml#L10-12
[3]:
https://gitlab.com/carbonOS/build-meta/-/commit/5151753e19149db8a177c1147eeb45c53b246c2f

On Wed, Feb 1, 2023, 13:34 Mark Wielaard <mark@klomp.org> wrote:

> Hi Adrian,
>
> On Wed, 2023-02-01 at 12:16 -0500, Adrian Vovk wrote:
> > I'm bumping this again to make sure it's not lost. Is there anything I
> > need to do to get this merged?
>
> O, so sorry, yes, this got "lost". I started looking at it. Then got a
> little scared because I realized we don't have any testcases for find-
> debuginfo. And then I kind of forgot to review it. Thanks for the
> reminder.
>
> So one question is: how did you test this?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Mark
>
> > On Sat, Jun 11, 2022 at 5:22 PM Adrian Vovk <adrianvovk@gmail.com>
> wrote:
> > >
> > > This should fix https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=27637
> > >
> > > I've implemented this in such a way that it should remain
> backwards-compatible.
> > > In other words, it should just continue working in the RPM build
> environment as
> > > before with no changes, though I haven't tested this.
> > >
> > > After RPM transitions to the new way of invoking the script, the
> backwards
> > > compatibility should be simple to strip out
> > >
> > > Signed-off-by: Adrian Vovk <adrianvovk@gmail.com>
> > > ---
> > >  scripts/find-debuginfo.in | 154
> +++++++++++++++++++++++++-------------
> > >  1 file changed, 102 insertions(+), 52 deletions(-)
> > >
> > > diff --git a/scripts/find-debuginfo.in b/scripts/find-debuginfo.in
> > > index b07a52f..9bc6232 100755
> > > --- a/scripts/find-debuginfo.in
> > > +++ b/scripts/find-debuginfo.in
> > > @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@
> > >  help()
> > >  {
> > >    cat <<'EOF'
> > > -Usage: find-debuginfo [OPTION]... [builddir]
> > > +Usage: find-debuginfo [OPTION]... builddir destdir nevra
> > >  automagically generates debug info and file lists
> > >
> > >  Options:
> > > @@ -39,7 +39,6 @@ Options:
> > >  [--unique-debug-suffix SUFFIX]
> > >  [--unique-debug-src-base BASE]
> > >  [[-l filelist]... [-p 'pattern'] -o debuginfo.list]
> > > -[builddir]
> > >
> > >  The -g flag says to use strip -g instead of full strip on DSOs or
> EXEs.
> > >  The --g-libs flag says to use strip -g instead of full strip ONLY on
> > > @@ -87,14 +86,22 @@ are unique between versions and releases of the
> same package.
> > >  If --unique-debug-suffix SUFFIX is given then the debug files created
> > >  for <FILE> will be named <FILE>-<SUFFIX>.debug.  This makes sure
> .debug
> > >  are unique between package version, release and architecture.
> > > -(Use --unique-debug-suffix "-%{VERSION}-%{RELEASE}.%{_arch}".)
> > > +(Use --unique-debug-suffix "-%{VERSION}-%{RELEASE}.%{_arch}")
> > >
> > > -If --unique-debug-src-base BASE is given then the source directory
> > > -will be called /usr/debug/src/<BASE>.  This makes sure the debug
> source
> > > -dirs are unique between package version, release and achitecture (Use
> > > ---unique-debug-src-base "%{name}-%{VERSION}-%{RELEASE}.%{_arch}")
> > > +If --unique-debug-src-base BASE is given, then the source directory
> > > +will be called /usr/src/debug/<BASE>.  This makes sure the debug
> source
> > > +dirs are unique between package version, release and achitecture.
> This
> > > +option defaults to the nevra, unless RPM_BUILD_DIR is set, in which
> case
> > > +it defaults to legacy RPM-specific behavior to maintain compatibility.
> > >
> > > -All file names in switches are relative to builddir ('.' if not
> given).
> > > +All file names in switches are relative to builddir.
> > > +(if unsure, use ".")
> > > +
> > > +All output files are placed into destdir.
> > > +(Use $RPM_BUILD_ROOT or equivalent)
> > > +
> > > +The nevra should uniquely identify the current package and version.
> > > +(Use %{name}-%{VERSION}-%{RELEASE}.%{_arch} or equivalent)
> > >  EOF
> > >  }
> > >
> > > @@ -138,6 +145,7 @@ build_id_seed=
> > >  unique_debug_suffix=
> > >
> > >  # Base given by --unique-debug-src-base
> > > +unique_debug_src_base_legacy=undecided
> > >  unique_debug_src_base=
> > >
> > >  # Number of parallel jobs to spawn
> > > @@ -146,7 +154,9 @@ n_jobs=1
> > >  # exit early on --version or --help
> > >  done=false
> > >
> > > -BUILDDIR=.
> > > +BUILDDIR=
> > > +DESTDIR=
> > > +NEVRA=
> > >  out=debugfiles.list
> > >  srcout=
> > >  nout=0
> > > @@ -179,6 +189,7 @@ while [ $# -gt 0 ]; do
> > >      ;;
> > >    --unique-debug-src-base)
> > >      unique_debug_src_base=$2
> > > +    unique_debug_src_base_legacy=no
> > >      shift
> > >      ;;
> > >    --g-libs)
> > > @@ -249,6 +260,8 @@ while [ $# -gt 0 ]; do
> > >      ;;
> > >    *)
> > >      BUILDDIR=$1
> > > +    DESTDIR=$2
> > > +    NEVRA=$3
> > >      shift
> > >      break
> > >      ;;
> > > @@ -259,17 +272,52 @@ done
> > >  # version or help given
> > >  if [ "$done" = "true" ]; then exit 0; fi
> > >
> > > -# Currently this scripts depends on some RPM environment variables
> > > -# being set.  RPM_BUILD_ROOT as the installation root directory.
> > > -# RPM_BUILD_DIR as the top build dir (usually one above BUILDDIR).
> > > -# And RPM_PACKAGE_NAME, RPM_PACKAGE_VERSION, RPM_PACKAGE_RELEASE,
> > > -# RPM_ARCH to create an unique (dir) name. Warn if they aren't set.
> > > -for n in RPM_BUILD_ROOT RPM_BUILD_DIR RPM_PACKAGE_NAME; do
> > > -  if eval test -z \"\${$n-}\"; then
> > > -    echo >&2 "$n is not set"
> > > +# Ensure that BUILDDIR, DESTDIR, and NEVRA are set, with fallbacks
> > > +# into the legacy RPM_* environment variables
> > > +if test -z "$BUILDDIR"; then
> > > +  echo >&2 "ERROR: builddir was not provided"
> > > +  exit 1
> > > +fi
> > > +if test -z "$DESTDIR"; then
> > > +  # Check for legacy RPM_BUILD_ROOT env var
> > > +  if test -n "$RPM_BUILD_ROOT"; then
> > > +    DESTDIR="$RPM_BUILD_ROOT"
> > > +    echo >&2 "WARNING: Using legacy RPM_BUILD_ROOT env var. Please
> pass destdir directly"
> > > +  else
> > > +    echo >&2 "ERROR: destdir was not provided"
> > >      exit 1
> > >    fi
> > > -done
> > > +fi
> > > +if test -z "$NEVRA"; then
> > > +  # Check for legacy nevra env vars
> > > +  using_rpm=true
> > > +  for var in RPM_PACKAGE_NAME RPM_PACKAGE_VERSION RPM_PACKAGE_RELEASE
> RPM_ARCH; do
> > > +    if test -z "${!var}"; then
> > > +      using_rpm=false
> > > +    fi
> > > +  done
> > > +  if [ "$using_rpm" = "true" ]; then
> > > +
> NEVRA="${RPM_PACKAGE_NAME}-${RPM_PACKAGE_VERSION}-${RPM_PACKAGE_RELEASE}.${RPM_ARCH}"
> > > +    echo >&2 "WARNING: Using legacy RPM nevra env vars. Please pass
> nevra directly"
> > > +  else
> > > +    echo >&2 "ERROR: nevra was not provided"
> > > +    exit 1
> > > +  fi
> > > +fi
> > > +
> > > +# Fall back to unique_debug_src_base's legacy behavior if
> RPM_BUILD_DIR is set
> > > +if [ "$unique_debug_src_base_legacy" = "undecided" ]; then
> > > +  if test -z "$RPM_BUILD_DIR"; then
> > > +    unique_debug_src_base_legacy=no
> > > +  else
> > > +    unique_debug_src_base_legacy=yes
> > > +  fi
> > > +fi
> > > +
> > > +# Handle unique_debug_src_base's default
> > > +if test -z "$unique_debug_src_base"; then
> > > +  unique_debug_src_base="$NEVRA"
> > > +fi
> > >
> > >  if test -n "$build_id_seed" -a "$no_recompute_build_id" = "true"; then
> > >    echo >&2 "*** ERROR: --build-id-seed (unique build-ids) and -n (do
> not recompute build-id) cannot be used together"
> > > @@ -302,7 +350,7 @@ ELFBINSFILE="$BUILDDIR/elfbins.list"
> > >  > "$LINKSFILE"
> > >  > "$ELFBINSFILE"
> > >
> > > -debugdir="${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug"
> > > +debugdir="${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug"
> > >
> > >  strip_to_debug()
> > >  {
> > > @@ -390,12 +438,12 @@ debug_link()
> > >    local l="/usr/lib/debug$2"
> > >    local t="$1"
> > >    echo >> "$LINKSFILE" "$l $t"
> > > -  link_relative "$t" "$l" "$RPM_BUILD_ROOT"
> > > +  link_relative "$t" "$l" "$DESTDIR"
> > >  }
> > >
> > >  get_debugfn()
> > >  {
> > > -  dn=$(dirname "${1#$RPM_BUILD_ROOT}")
> > > +  dn=$(dirname "${1#$DESTDIR}")
> > >    bn=$(basename "$1" .debug)${unique_debug_suffix}.debug
> > >    debugdn=${debugdir}${dn}
> > >    debugfn=${debugdn}/${bn}
> > > @@ -411,7 +459,7 @@ trap 'rm -rf "$temp"' EXIT
> > >
> > >  # Build a list of unstripped ELF files and their hardlinks
> > >  touch "$temp/primary"
> > > -find "$RPM_BUILD_ROOT" ! -path "${debugdir}/*.debug" -type f \
> > > +find "$DESTDIR" ! -path "${debugdir}/*.debug" -type f \
> > >                      \( -perm -0100 -or -perm -0010 -or -perm -0001 \)
> \
> > >                      -print | LC_ALL=C sort |
> > >  file -N -f - | sed -n -e 's/^\(.*\):[  ]*.*ELF.*, not
> stripped.*/\1/p' |
> > > @@ -439,9 +487,10 @@ do_file()
> > >
> > >    echo "extracting debug info from $f"
> > >    # See also cpio SOURCEFILE copy. Directories must match up.
> > > -  debug_base_name="$RPM_BUILD_DIR"
> > > -  debug_dest_name="/usr/src/debug"
> > > -  if [ ! -z "$unique_debug_src_base" ]; then
> > > +  if [ "$unique_debug_src_base_legacy" = "yes" ]; then
> > > +    debug_base_name="$RPM_BUILD_DIR"
> > > +    debug_dest_name="/usr/src/debug"
> > > +  else
> > >      debug_base_name="$BUILDDIR"
> > >      debug_dest_name="/usr/src/debug/${unique_debug_src_base}"
> > >    fi
> > > @@ -505,7 +554,7 @@ do_file()
> > >      $skip_mini || add_minidebug "${debugfn}" "$f"
> > >    fi
> > >
> > > -  echo "./${f#$RPM_BUILD_ROOT}" >> "$ELFBINSFILE"
> > > +  echo "./${f#$DESTDIR}" >> "$ELFBINSFILE"
> > >
> > >    # If this file has multiple links, make the corresponding .debug
> files
> > >    # all links to one file too.
> > > @@ -573,14 +622,14 @@ fi
> > >
> > >  # Invoke the DWARF Compressor utility.
> > >  if $run_dwz \
> > > -   && [ -d "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug" ]; then
> > > -  readarray dwz_files < <(cd "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug"; find
> -type f -name \*.debug | LC_ALL=C sort)
> > > +   && [ -d "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug" ]; then
> > > +  readarray dwz_files < <(cd "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug"; find -type f
> -name \*.debug | LC_ALL=C sort)
> > >    if [ ${#dwz_files[@]} -gt 0 ]; then
> > > -    size_before=$(du -sk ${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug | cut -f1)
> > > -
> dwz_multifile_name="${RPM_PACKAGE_NAME}-${RPM_PACKAGE_VERSION}-${RPM_PACKAGE_RELEASE}.${RPM_ARCH}"
> > > +    size_before=$(du -sk ${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug | cut -f1)
> > > +    dwz_multifile_name="$NEVRA"
> > >      dwz_multifile_suffix=
> > >      dwz_multifile_idx=0
> > > -    while [ -f
> "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug/.dwz/${dwz_multifile_name}${dwz_multifile_suffix}"
> ]; do
> > > +    while [ -f
> "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug/.dwz/${dwz_multifile_name}${dwz_multifile_suffix}"
> ]; do
> > >        let ++dwz_multifile_idx
> > >        dwz_multifile_suffix=".${dwz_multifile_idx}"
> > >      done
> > > @@ -588,37 +637,37 @@ if $run_dwz \
> > >      dwz_opts="-h -q -r"
> > >      [ ${#dwz_files[@]} -gt 1 ] && [ "$dwz_single_file_mode" = "false"
> ] \
> > >        && dwz_opts="${dwz_opts} -m .dwz/${dwz_multifile_name}"
> > > -    mkdir -p "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug/.dwz"
> > > +    mkdir -p "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug/.dwz"
> > >      [ -n "${dwz_low_mem_die_limit}" ] \
> > >        && dwz_opts="${dwz_opts} -l ${dwz_low_mem_die_limit}"
> > >      [ -n "${dwz_max_die_limit}" ] \
> > >        && dwz_opts="${dwz_opts} -L ${dwz_max_die_limit}"
> > >      if type dwz >/dev/null 2>&1; then
> > > -      ( cd "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug" && dwz $dwz_opts
> ${dwz_files[@]} )
> > > +      ( cd "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug" && dwz $dwz_opts
> ${dwz_files[@]} )
> > >      else
> > >        echo >&2 "*** ERROR: DWARF compression requested, but no dwz
> installed"
> > >        exit 2
> > >      fi
> > > -    size_after=$(du -sk ${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug | cut -f1)
> > > +    size_after=$(du -sk ${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug | cut -f1)
> > >      echo "original debug info size: ${size_before}kB, size after
> compression: ${size_after}kB"
> > >      # Remove .dwz directory if empty
> > > -    rmdir "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib/debug/.dwz" 2>/dev/null
> > > +    rmdir "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib/debug/.dwz" 2>/dev/null
> > >
> > >      # dwz invalidates .gnu_debuglink CRC32 in the main files.
> > >      cat "$ELFBINSFILE" |
> > > -    (cd "$RPM_BUILD_ROOT"; \
> > > +    (cd "$DESTDIR"; \
> > >       tr '\n' '\0' | xargs -0 ${install_dir}/sepdebugcrcfix
> usr/lib/debug)
> > >    fi
> > >  fi
> > >
> > >  # For each symlink whose target has a .debug file,
> > >  # make a .debug symlink to that file.
> > > -find "$RPM_BUILD_ROOT" ! -path "${debugdir}/*" -type l -print |
> > > +find "$DESTDIR" ! -path "${debugdir}/*" -type l -print |
> > >  while read f
> > >  do
> > >    t=$(readlink -m "$f").debug
> > > -  f=${f#$RPM_BUILD_ROOT}
> > > -  t=${t#$RPM_BUILD_ROOT}
> > > +  f=${f#$DESTDIR}
> > > +  t=${t#$DESTDIR}
> > >    if [ -f "$debugdir$t" ]; then
> > >      echo "symlinked /usr/lib/debug$t to /usr/lib/debug${f}.debug"
> > >      debug_link "/usr/lib/debug$t" "${f}.debug"
> > > @@ -627,33 +676,34 @@ done
> > >
> > >  if [ -s "$SOURCEFILE" ]; then
> > >    # See also debugedit invocation. Directories must match up.
> > > -  debug_base_name="$RPM_BUILD_DIR"
> > > -  debug_dest_name="/usr/src/debug"
> > > -  if [ ! -z "$unique_debug_src_base" ]; then
> > > +  if [ "$unique_debug_src_base_legacy" = "yes" ]; then
> > > +    debug_base_name="$RPM_BUILD_DIR"
> > > +    debug_dest_name="/usr/src/debug"
> > > +  else
> > >      debug_base_name="$BUILDDIR"
> > >      debug_dest_name="/usr/src/debug/${unique_debug_src_base}"
> > >    fi
> > >
> > > -  mkdir -p "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}${debug_dest_name}"
> > > +  mkdir -p "${DESTDIR}${debug_dest_name}"
> > >    # Filter out anything compiler generated which isn't a source file.
> > >    # e.g. <internal>, <built-in>, <__thread_local_inner macros>.
> > >    # Some compilers generate them as if they are part of the working
> > >    # directory (which is why we match against ^ or /).
> > >    LC_ALL=C sort -z -u "$SOURCEFILE" | grep -E -v -z '(^|/)<[a-z
> _-]+>$' |
> > > -  (cd "${debug_base_name}"; cpio -pd0mL
> "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}${debug_dest_name}")
> > > +  (cd "${debug_base_name}"; cpio -pd0mL
> "${DESTDIR}${debug_dest_name}")
> > >    # stupid cpio creates new directories in mode 0700,
> > >    # and non-standard modes may be inherented from original
> directories, fixup
> > > -  find "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}${debug_dest_name}" -type d -print0 |
> > > +  find "${DESTDIR}${debug_dest_name}" -type d -print0 |
> > >    xargs --no-run-if-empty -0 chmod 0755
> > >  fi
> > >
> > > -if [ -d "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib" ] || [ -d
> "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/src" ]; then
> > > +if [ -d "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib" ] || [ -d "${DESTDIR}/usr/src" ]; then
> > >    ((nout > 0)) ||
> > > -  test ! -d "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib" ||
> > > -  (cd "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/lib"; find debug -type d) |
> > > +  test ! -d "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib" ||
> > > +  (cd "${DESTDIR}/usr/lib"; find debug -type d) |
> > >    sed 's,^,%dir /usr/lib/,' >> "$LISTFILE"
> > >
> > > -  (cd "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr"
> > > +  (cd "${DESTDIR}/usr"
> > >     test ! -d lib/debug || find lib/debug ! -type d
> > >     test ! -d src/debug -o -n "$srcout" || find src/debug -mindepth 1
> -maxdepth 1
> > >    ) | sed 's,^,/usr/,' >> "$LISTFILE"
> > > @@ -662,8 +712,8 @@ fi
> > >  if [ -n "$srcout" ]; then
> > >    srcout="$BUILDDIR/$srcout"
> > >    > "$srcout"
> > > -  if [ -d "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr/src/debug" ]; then
> > > -    (cd "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}/usr"
> > > +  if [ -d "${DESTDIR}/usr/src/debug" ]; then
> > > +    (cd "${DESTDIR}/usr"
> > >       find src/debug -mindepth 1 -maxdepth 1
> > >      ) | sed 's,^,/usr/,' >> "$srcout"
> > >    fi
> > > @@ -735,7 +785,7 @@ if ((nout > 0)); then
> > >      done | \
> > >      sort -u | \
> > >      while read -r line; do
> > > -      test -d "${RPM_BUILD_ROOT}$line" && printf '%%dir %s\n' "$line"
> > > +      test -d "${DESTDIR}$line" && printf '%%dir %s\n' "$line"
> > >      done
> > >    }
> > >    i=0
> > > --
> > > 2.36.1
> > >
>
>