[PATCH] Indicate minimum in-tree MPFR version handled

[PATCH] Indicate minimum in-tree MPFR version handled

[Maciej W. Rozycki]

Hi,

 Commit 235763 removed support for versions of MPFR below 3.1.0 which have 
a flat directory structure, however it did not introduce any safety check 
for such an unhandled library version present in the tree.  Consequently 
the system-installed version is silently chosen, which if too old, causes 
a confusing configuration failure in mpc/ stating a misleading version 
requirement:

checking for MPFR... yes
checking for recent GMP... yes
checking for recent MPFR... no
configure: error: MPFR version >= 2.4.2 required
make[1]: *** [configure-mpc] Error 1

 I propose the check below to make people's life just a little bit easier 
and indicate right away that an incorrect version of MPFR has been found 
in the source tree.  This is especially helpful when you just sync your 
build tree from upstream and may easily miss the updated requirement.  I 
carefully chose to use "handled" rather than "supported" in the message as 
the commit referred clearly indicates you are on your own with versions of 
the libraries different from those stated in `download_prerequisites'.

2016-08-12  Maciej W. Rozycki  <macro@imgtec.com>

	* configure.ac: Check for the minimum in-tree MPFR version 
	handled.
	* configure: Regenerate.

 OK to apply?

  Maciej

gcc-mpfr-version.diff
Index: gcc/configure
===================================================================
--- gcc.orig/configure	2016-08-11 23:23:44.104635061 +0100
+++ gcc/configure	2016-08-11 23:24:02.933019031 +0100
@@ -5566,6 +5566,10 @@ if test "x$with_mpfr_lib" != x; then
   gmplibs="-L$with_mpfr_lib $gmplibs"
 fi
 if test "x$with_mpfr$with_mpfr_include$with_mpfr_lib" = x && test -d ${srcdir}/mpfr; then
+  # MPFR v3.1.0 moved the sources into a src sub-directory.
+  if ! test -d ${srcdir}/mpfr/src; then
+    as_fn_error "Building GCC with MPFR in the source tree is only handled for MPFR 3.1.0+." "$LINENO" 5
+  fi
   gmplibs='-L$$r/$(HOST_SUBDIR)/mpfr/src/'"$lt_cv_objdir $gmplibs"
   gmpinc='-I$$r/$(HOST_SUBDIR)/mpfr/src -I$$s/mpfr/src '"$gmpinc"
   extra_mpc_mpfr_configure_flags='--with-mpfr-include=$$s/mpfr/src --with-mpfr-lib=$$r/$(HOST_SUBDIR)/mpfr/src/'"$lt_cv_objdir"
Index: gcc/configure.ac
===================================================================
--- gcc.orig/configure.ac	2016-08-11 23:23:44.117834819 +0100
+++ gcc/configure.ac	2016-08-11 23:24:00.198745307 +0100
@@ -1546,6 +1546,11 @@ if test "x$with_mpfr_lib" != x; then
   gmplibs="-L$with_mpfr_lib $gmplibs"
 fi
 if test "x$with_mpfr$with_mpfr_include$with_mpfr_lib" = x && test -d ${srcdir}/mpfr; then
+  # MPFR v3.1.0 moved the sources into a src sub-directory.
+  if ! test -d ${srcdir}/mpfr/src; then
+    AC_MSG_ERROR([dnl
+Building GCC with MPFR in the source tree is only handled for MPFR 3.1.0+.])
+  fi
   gmplibs='-L$$r/$(HOST_SUBDIR)/mpfr/src/'"$lt_cv_objdir $gmplibs"
   gmpinc='-I$$r/$(HOST_SUBDIR)/mpfr/src -I$$s/mpfr/src '"$gmpinc"
   extra_mpc_mpfr_configure_flags='--with-mpfr-include=$$s/mpfr/src --with-mpfr-lib=$$r/$(HOST_SUBDIR)/mpfr/src/'"$lt_cv_objdir"

Re: [PATCH] Indicate minimum in-tree MPFR version handled

[Bernd Edlinger]

On 08/12/16, Maciej W. Rozycki wrote:
> Hi,
> 
>  Commit 235763 removed support for versions of MPFR below 3.1.0 which have
> a flat directory structure, however it did not introduce any safety check
> for such an unhandled library version present in the tree.  Consequently
> the system-installed version is silently chosen, which if too old, causes
> a confusing configuration failure in mpc/ stating a misleading version
> requirement:
> 
> checking for MPFR... yes
> checking for recent GMP... yes
> checking for recent MPFR... no
> configure: error: MPFR version >= 2.4.2 required
> make[1]: *** [configure-mpc] Error 1
> 
>  I propose the check below to make people's life just a little bit easier
> and indicate right away that an incorrect version of MPFR has been found
> in the source tree.  This is especially helpful when you just sync your
> build tree from upstream and may easily miss the updated requirement.  I
> carefully chose to use "handled" rather than "supported" in the message as
> the commit referred clearly indicates you are on your own with versions of
> the libraries different from those stated in `download_prerequisites'.
> 
> +  # MPFR v3.1.0 moved the sources into a src sub-directory.
> +  if ! test -d ${srcdir}/mpfr/src; then
> +    as_fn_error "Building GCC with MPFR in the source tree is only handled for MPFR 3.1.0+." "$LINENO" 5
> +  fi

I think it is a good idea to detect this situation, but you should advise the user
that he has to use exactly the same version(s) that contrib/download_prerequisites
installs.


Bernd.

Re: [PATCH] Indicate minimum in-tree MPFR version handled

[Maciej W. Rozycki]

On Fri, 12 Aug 2016, Bernd Edlinger wrote:

> > +  # MPFR v3.1.0 moved the sources into a src sub-directory.
> > +  if ! test -d ${srcdir}/mpfr/src; then
> > +    as_fn_error "Building GCC with MPFR in the source tree is only handled for MPFR 3.1.0+." "$LINENO" 5
> > +  fi
> 
> I think it is a good idea to detect this situation, but you should advise the user
> that he has to use exactly the same version(s) that contrib/download_prerequisites
> installs.

 We're not doing an exhaustive check for the GMP/MPFR/MPC dependencies 
here, so I think it's enough to point out the outright incompatibility.  
It might make sense though to have an additional check in the component 
requiring these libraries and issue a warning if a mismatch is detected 
with in-tree versions.

  Maciej

Re: [PATCH] Indicate minimum in-tree MPFR version handled

[Jeff Law]

On 08/11/2016 05:20 PM, Maciej W. Rozycki wrote:
> Hi,
>
>  Commit 235763 removed support for versions of MPFR below 3.1.0 which have
> a flat directory structure, however it did not introduce any safety check
> for such an unhandled library version present in the tree.  Consequently
> the system-installed version is silently chosen, which if too old, causes
> a confusing configuration failure in mpc/ stating a misleading version
> requirement:
>
> checking for MPFR... yes
> checking for recent GMP... yes
> checking for recent MPFR... no
> configure: error: MPFR version >= 2.4.2 required
> make[1]: *** [configure-mpc] Error 1
>
>  I propose the check below to make people's life just a little bit easier
> and indicate right away that an incorrect version of MPFR has been found
> in the source tree.  This is especially helpful when you just sync your
> build tree from upstream and may easily miss the updated requirement.  I
> carefully chose to use "handled" rather than "supported" in the message as
> the commit referred clearly indicates you are on your own with versions of
> the libraries different from those stated in `download_prerequisites'.
>
> 2016-08-12  Maciej W. Rozycki  <macro@imgtec.com>
>
> 	* configure.ac: Check for the minimum in-tree MPFR version
> 	handled.
> 	* configure: Regenerate.
>
>  OK to apply?
OK.
jeff

Re: [PATCH] Indicate minimum in-tree MPFR version handled

[Maciej W. Rozycki]

On Tue, 16 Aug 2016, Jeff Law wrote:

> > 2016-08-12  Maciej W. Rozycki  <macro@imgtec.com>
> > 
> > 	* configure.ac: Check for the minimum in-tree MPFR version
> > 	handled.
> > 	* configure: Regenerate.
> > 
> >  OK to apply?
> OK.

 Applied now, thanks for your review and apologies for the delay.

  Maciej