c++/8099: Friend classes and template specializations

[bangerth@ticam.utexas.edu]

>Number:         8099
>Category:       c++
>Synopsis:       Friend classes and template specializations
>Confidential:   no
>Severity:       serious
>Priority:       medium
>Responsible:    unassigned
>State:          open
>Class:          sw-bug
>Submitter-Id:   net
>Arrival-Date:   Mon Sep 30 10:16:13 PDT 2002
>Closed-Date:
>Last-Modified:
>Originator:     Wolfgang Bangerth
>Release:        unknown-1.0
>Organization:
>Environment:
all gcc versions up to gcc3.2
>Description:
[Note that there are already a number of related bug reports,
at least c++/8056 comes to my mind, but there may be more.]

Maybe this is just some point where the standard is unclear:
in 14.5.3.1, the following example is given of a friend
declaration:
  template <typename T> class X {
    friend class X<int>;
  };
One would presume that this syntax also holds if a class
Y would name a particular (fully specialized) instance of
X as a friend. That would be irrespective of whether this
instance is derived from the general template for X, or
from a partial or full explicit specialization of X. Then
the following example should compile (as it does with
Compaq's cxx and Intel's icc):
--------------------------------
template <int N, typename T> class X;
template <typename T>        class X<1,T>;

template <typename P> class Y {
    static int i;
    template <int N, typename T> friend class X;
    friend class X<1,P>;
};

template <typename T> class X<1,T> {
    X () { Y<T>::i; };     // access private field
};
-------------------------------------

gcc rejects the second friend declaration, apparently
refering to 14.7.3.17, which states that "An  explicit 
specialization declaration shall not be a friend 
declaration".

So I admit I am confused, both about the standard and
the behavior of different compilers. Since gcc behavior
restricts the use of the language (IMHO) unduly, I would
opt for it to follow the other compiler's interpretation.

Regards
  Wolfgang

>How-To-Repeat:

>Fix:

>Release-Note:
>Audit-Trail:
>Unformatted: