From: Wilco Dijkstra <Wilco.Dijkstra@arm.com>
To: 'GNU C Library' <libc-alpha@sourceware.org>
Subject: [PATCH 4/5] Remove slow paths from atan2
Date: Mon, 4 Jan 2021 12:21:53 +0000 [thread overview]
Message-ID: <VE1PR08MB55995DAFEA510C9BACAF0A5283D20@VE1PR08MB5599.eurprd08.prod.outlook.com> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <VE1PR08MB559960408B9E0ECB8BC925CE83D20@VE1PR08MB5599.eurprd08.prod.outlook.com>
Remove slow paths from atan2. Add ULP annotations.
Passes GLIBC testsuite.
---
diff --git a/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/atnat2.h b/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/atnat2.h
index de4300c5fc559f391e0b20a818452640dabb0e41..9cb8a1fbeae6ff2845151f23d49797c1218c0062 100644
--- a/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/atnat2.h
+++ b/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/atnat2.h
@@ -34,7 +34,7 @@
#define MM 5
#ifdef BIG_ENDI
- static const number
+ static const mynumber
/* polynomial I */
/**/ d3 = {{0xbfd55555, 0x55555555} }, /* -0.333... */
/**/ d5 = {{0x3fc99999, 0x999997fd} }, /* 0.199... */
@@ -96,7 +96,7 @@
#else
#ifdef LITTLE_ENDI
- static const number
+ static const mynumber
/* polynomial I */
/**/ d3 = {{0x55555555, 0xbfd55555} }, /* -0.333... */
/**/ d5 = {{0x999997fd, 0x3fc99999} }, /* 0.199... */
diff --git a/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/e_atan2.c b/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/e_atan2.c
index 7af2a4f495d39f6450699de1d0d9d2f7a33fdcf7..5af12d37c3c89cac951d293339e811fd96d0daf3 100644
--- a/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/e_atan2.c
+++ b/sysdeps/ieee754/dbl-64/e_atan2.c
@@ -20,25 +20,14 @@
/* MODULE_NAME: atnat2.c */
/* */
/* FUNCTIONS: uatan2 */
-/* atan2Mp */
/* signArctan2 */
-/* normalized */
/* */
-/* FILES NEEDED: dla.h endian.h mpa.h mydefs.h atnat2.h */
-/* mpatan.c mpatan2.c mpsqrt.c */
+/* FILES NEEDED: dla.h endian.h mydefs.h atnat2.h */
/* uatan.tbl */
/* */
-/* An ultimate atan2() routine. Given two IEEE double machine numbers y,*/
-/* x it computes the correctly rounded (to nearest) value of atan2(y,x).*/
-/* */
-/* Assumption: Machine arithmetic operations are performed in */
-/* round to nearest mode of IEEE 754 standard. */
-/* */
/************************************************************************/
#include <dla.h>
-#include "mpa.h"
-#include "MathLib.h"
#include "mydefs.h"
#include "uatan.tbl"
#include "atnat2.h"
@@ -48,20 +37,21 @@
#include <math-barriers.h>
#include <math_private.h>
#include <fenv_private.h>
-#include <stap-probe.h>
#include <libm-alias-finite.h>
#ifndef SECTION
# define SECTION
#endif
+#define TWO52 0x1.0p52
+#define TWOM1022 0x1.0p-1022
+
/************************************************************************/
/* An ultimate atan2 routine. Given two IEEE double machine numbers y,x */
/* it computes the correctly rounded (to nearest) value of atan2(y,x). */
/* Assumption: Machine arithmetic operations are performed in */
/* round to nearest mode of IEEE 754 standard. */
/************************************************************************/
-static double atan2Mp (double, double, const int[]);
/* Fix the sign and return after stage 1 or stage 2 */
static double
signArctan2 (double y, double z)
@@ -69,18 +59,14 @@ signArctan2 (double y, double z)
return copysign (z, y);
}
-static double normalized (double, double, double, double);
-void __mpatan2 (mp_no *, mp_no *, mp_no *, int);
-
double
SECTION
__ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
{
int i, de, ux, dx, uy, dy;
- static const int pr[MM] = { 6, 8, 10, 20, 32 };
- double ax, ay, u, du, u9, ua, v, vv, dv, t1, t2, t3,
- z, zz, cor, s1, ss1, s2, ss2;
- number num;
+ double ax, ay, u, du, v, vv, dv, t1, t2, t3,
+ z, zz, cor;
+ mynumber num;
static const int ep = 59768832, /* 57*16**5 */
em = -59768832; /* -57*16**5 */
@@ -208,10 +194,8 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
if (x > 0)
{
double ret;
- if ((z = ay / ax) < TWOM1022)
- ret = normalized (ax, ay, y, z);
- else
- ret = signArctan2 (y, z);
+ z = ay / ax;
+ ret = signArctan2 (y, z);
if (fabs (ret) < DBL_MIN)
{
double vret = ret ? ret : DBL_MIN;
@@ -270,30 +254,12 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * (d11.d
+ v * d13.d)))));
- if ((z = u + (zz - u1.d * u)) == u + (zz + u1.d * u))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- MUL2 (u, du, u, du, v, vv, t1, t2);
- s1 = v * (f11.d + v * (f13.d
- + v * (f15.d + v * (f17.d + v * f19.d))));
- ADD2 (f9.d, ff9.d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f7.d, ff7.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f5.d, ff5.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f3.d, ff3.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (u, du, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (u, du, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s1 + (ss1 - u5.d * s1)) == s1 + (ss1 + u5.d * s1))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = u + zz;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.504. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
- i = (TWO52 + TWO8 * u) - TWO52;
+ i = (TWO52 + 256 * u) - TWO52;
i -= 16;
t3 = u - cij[i][0].d;
EADD (t3, du, v, dv);
@@ -304,43 +270,9 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * (cij[i][4].d
+ v * (cij[i][5].d
+ v * cij[i][6].d))));
- if (i < 112)
- {
- if (i < 48)
- u9 = u91.d; /* u < 1/4 */
- else
- u9 = u92.d;
- } /* 1/4 <= u < 1/2 */
- else
- {
- if (i < 176)
- u9 = u93.d; /* 1/2 <= u < 3/4 */
- else
- u9 = u94.d;
- } /* 3/4 <= u <= 1 */
- if ((z = t1 + (zz - u9 * t1)) == t1 + (zz + u9 * t1))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- t1 = u - hij[i][0].d;
- EADD (t1, du, v, vv);
- s1 = v * (hij[i][11].d
- + v * (hij[i][12].d
- + v * (hij[i][13].d
- + v * (hij[i][14].d
- + v * hij[i][15].d))));
- ADD2 (hij[i][9].d, hij[i][10].d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][7].d, hij[i][8].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][5].d, hij[i][6].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][3].d, hij[i][4].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][1].d, hij[i][2].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s2 + (ss2 - ub.d * s2)) == s2 + (ss2 + ub.d * s2))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = t1 + zz;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.56. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
/* (ii) x>0, abs(x)<=abs(y): pi/2-atan(ax/ay) */
@@ -355,31 +287,12 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * d13.d)))));
ESUB (hpi.d, u, t2, cor);
t3 = ((hpi1.d + cor) - du) - zz;
- if ((z = t2 + (t3 - u2.d)) == t2 + (t3 + u2.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- MUL2 (u, du, u, du, v, vv, t1, t2);
- s1 = v * (f11.d
- + v * (f13.d
- + v * (f15.d + v * (f17.d + v * f19.d))));
- ADD2 (f9.d, ff9.d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f7.d, ff7.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f5.d, ff5.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f3.d, ff3.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (u, du, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (u, du, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- SUB2 (hpi.d, hpi1.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s2 + (ss2 - u6.d)) == s2 + (ss2 + u6.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = t2 + t3;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.501. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
- i = (TWO52 + TWO8 * u) - TWO52;
+ i = (TWO52 + 256 * u) - TWO52;
i -= 16;
v = (u - cij[i][0].d) + du;
@@ -389,36 +302,9 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * (cij[i][5].d
+ v * cij[i][6].d))));
t1 = hpi.d - cij[i][1].d;
- if (i < 112)
- ua = ua1.d; /* w < 1/2 */
- else
- ua = ua2.d; /* w >= 1/2 */
- if ((z = t1 + (zz - ua)) == t1 + (zz + ua))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- t1 = u - hij[i][0].d;
- EADD (t1, du, v, vv);
-
- s1 = v * (hij[i][11].d
- + v * (hij[i][12].d
- + v * (hij[i][13].d
- + v * (hij[i][14].d
- + v * hij[i][15].d))));
-
- ADD2 (hij[i][9].d, hij[i][10].d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][7].d, hij[i][8].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][5].d, hij[i][6].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][3].d, hij[i][4].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][1].d, hij[i][2].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- SUB2 (hpi.d, hpi1.d, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s1 + (ss1 - uc.d)) == s1 + (ss1 + uc.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = t1 + zz;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.503. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
/* (iii) x<0, abs(x)< abs(y): pi/2+atan(ax/ay) */
@@ -434,30 +320,12 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * (d11.d + v * d13.d)))));
EADD (hpi.d, u, t2, cor);
t3 = ((hpi1.d + cor) + du) + zz;
- if ((z = t2 + (t3 - u3.d)) == t2 + (t3 + u3.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- MUL2 (u, du, u, du, v, vv, t1, t2);
- s1 = v * (f11.d
- + v * (f13.d + v * (f15.d + v * (f17.d + v * f19.d))));
- ADD2 (f9.d, ff9.d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f7.d, ff7.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f5.d, ff5.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f3.d, ff3.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (u, du, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (u, du, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hpi.d, hpi1.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s2 + (ss2 - u7.d)) == s2 + (ss2 + u7.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = t2 + t3;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.501. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
- i = (TWO52 + TWO8 * u) - TWO52;
+ i = (TWO52 + 256 * u) - TWO52;
i -= 16;
v = (u - cij[i][0].d) + du;
zz = hpi1.d + v * (cij[i][2].d
@@ -466,34 +334,9 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * (cij[i][5].d
+ v * cij[i][6].d))));
t1 = hpi.d + cij[i][1].d;
- if (i < 112)
- ua = ua1.d; /* w < 1/2 */
- else
- ua = ua2.d; /* w >= 1/2 */
- if ((z = t1 + (zz - ua)) == t1 + (zz + ua))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- t1 = u - hij[i][0].d;
- EADD (t1, du, v, vv);
- s1 = v * (hij[i][11].d
- + v * (hij[i][12].d
- + v * (hij[i][13].d
- + v * (hij[i][14].d
- + v * hij[i][15].d))));
- ADD2 (hij[i][9].d, hij[i][10].d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][7].d, hij[i][8].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][5].d, hij[i][6].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][3].d, hij[i][4].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][1].d, hij[i][2].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hpi.d, hpi1.d, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s1 + (ss1 - uc.d)) == s1 + (ss1 + uc.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = t1 + zz;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.503. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
/* (iv) x<0, abs(y)<=abs(x): pi-atan(ax/ay) */
@@ -506,29 +349,12 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * (d9.d + v * (d11.d + v * d13.d)))));
ESUB (opi.d, u, t2, cor);
t3 = ((opi1.d + cor) - du) - zz;
- if ((z = t2 + (t3 - u4.d)) == t2 + (t3 + u4.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- MUL2 (u, du, u, du, v, vv, t1, t2);
- s1 = v * (f11.d + v * (f13.d + v * (f15.d + v * (f17.d + v * f19.d))));
- ADD2 (f9.d, ff9.d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f7.d, ff7.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f5.d, ff5.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (f3.d, ff3.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (u, du, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (u, du, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- SUB2 (opi.d, opi1.d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s2 + (ss2 - u8.d)) == s2 + (ss2 + u8.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = t2 + t3;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.501. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
- i = (TWO52 + TWO8 * u) - TWO52;
+ i = (TWO52 + 256 * u) - TWO52;
i -= 16;
v = (u - cij[i][0].d) + du;
zz = opi1.d - v * (cij[i][2].d
@@ -536,86 +362,11 @@ __ieee754_atan2 (double y, double x)
+ v * (cij[i][4].d
+ v * (cij[i][5].d + v * cij[i][6].d))));
t1 = opi.d - cij[i][1].d;
- if (i < 112)
- ua = ua1.d; /* w < 1/2 */
- else
- ua = ua2.d; /* w >= 1/2 */
- if ((z = t1 + (zz - ua)) == t1 + (zz + ua))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-
- t1 = u - hij[i][0].d;
-
- EADD (t1, du, v, vv);
-
- s1 = v * (hij[i][11].d
- + v * (hij[i][12].d
- + v * (hij[i][13].d
- + v * (hij[i][14].d + v * hij[i][15].d))));
-
- ADD2 (hij[i][9].d, hij[i][10].d, s1, 0, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][7].d, hij[i][8].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][5].d, hij[i][6].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][3].d, hij[i][4].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- MUL2 (v, vv, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
- ADD2 (hij[i][1].d, hij[i][2].d, s1, ss1, s2, ss2, t1, t2);
- SUB2 (opi.d, opi1.d, s2, ss2, s1, ss1, t1, t2);
-
- if ((z = s1 + (ss1 - uc.d)) == s1 + (ss1 + uc.d))
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
- return atan2Mp (x, y, pr);
+ z = t1 + zz;
+ /* Max ULP is 0.502. */
+ return signArctan2 (y, z);
}
#ifndef __ieee754_atan2
libm_alias_finite (__ieee754_atan2, __atan2)
#endif
-
-/* Treat the Denormalized case */
-static double
-SECTION
-normalized (double ax, double ay, double y, double z)
-{
- int p;
- mp_no mpx, mpy, mpz, mperr, mpz2, mpt1;
- p = 6;
- __dbl_mp (ax, &mpx, p);
- __dbl_mp (ay, &mpy, p);
- __dvd (&mpy, &mpx, &mpz, p);
- __dbl_mp (ue.d, &mpt1, p);
- __mul (&mpz, &mpt1, &mperr, p);
- __sub (&mpz, &mperr, &mpz2, p);
- __mp_dbl (&mpz2, &z, p);
- return signArctan2 (y, z);
-}
-
-/* Stage 3: Perform a multi-Precision computation */
-static double
-SECTION
-atan2Mp (double x, double y, const int pr[])
-{
- double z1, z2;
- int i, p;
- mp_no mpx, mpy, mpz, mpz1, mpz2, mperr, mpt1;
- for (i = 0; i < MM; i++)
- {
- p = pr[i];
- __dbl_mp (x, &mpx, p);
- __dbl_mp (y, &mpy, p);
- __mpatan2 (&mpy, &mpx, &mpz, p);
- __dbl_mp (ud[i].d, &mpt1, p);
- __mul (&mpz, &mpt1, &mperr, p);
- __add (&mpz, &mperr, &mpz1, p);
- __sub (&mpz, &mperr, &mpz2, p);
- __mp_dbl (&mpz1, &z1, p);
- __mp_dbl (&mpz2, &z2, p);
- if (z1 == z2)
- {
- LIBC_PROBE (slowatan2, 4, &p, &x, &y, &z1);
- return z1;
- }
- }
- LIBC_PROBE (slowatan2_inexact, 4, &p, &x, &y, &z1);
- return z1; /*if impossible to do exact computing */
-}
next prev parent reply other threads:[~2021-01-04 12:22 UTC|newest]
Thread overview: 19+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top
2021-01-04 12:11 [PATCH 0/5] Remove remaining slow paths from math functions Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 12:15 ` [PATCH 1/5] Remove slow paths from asin Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 16:25 ` Paul Zimmermann
2021-01-04 17:06 ` Szabolcs Nagy
2021-01-04 17:41 ` Paul Zimmermann
2021-01-07 19:36 ` Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-08 10:29 ` Paul Zimmermann
2021-01-07 19:23 ` [PATCH v2 1/5] Remove remaining slow paths from asin and acos Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 12:17 ` [PATCH 2/5] Remove slow paths in tan Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 16:36 ` Paul Zimmermann
2021-01-07 19:25 ` [PATCH v2 " Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 12:19 ` [PATCH 3/5] Remove slow paths from atan Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 16:43 ` Paul Zimmermann
2021-01-07 19:26 ` [PATCH v2 " Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 12:21 ` Wilco Dijkstra [this message]
2021-01-04 16:49 ` [PATCH 4/5] Remove slow paths from atan2 Paul Zimmermann
2021-01-07 19:28 ` [PATCH v2 " Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-04 12:25 ` [PATCH 5/5] Remove mpa files Wilco Dijkstra
2021-01-07 20:12 ` [PATCH v2 " Wilco Dijkstra
Reply instructions:
You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:
* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
and reply-to-all from there: mbox
Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style
* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
switches of git-send-email(1):
git send-email \
--in-reply-to=VE1PR08MB55995DAFEA510C9BACAF0A5283D20@VE1PR08MB5599.eurprd08.prod.outlook.com \
--to=wilco.dijkstra@arm.com \
--cc=libc-alpha@sourceware.org \
/path/to/YOUR_REPLY
https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html
* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line
before the message body.
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for read-only IMAP folder(s) and NNTP newsgroup(s).