[Bug translator/19500] New: .callee test failures

public inbox for systemtap@sourceware.org
 help / color / mirror / Atom feed

* [Bug translator/19500] New: .callee test failures
@ 2016-01-20 17:44 dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-19 19:44 ` [Bug translator/19500] " dsmith at redhat dot com
                   ` (3 more replies)
  0 siblings, 4 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: dsmith at redhat dot com @ 2016-01-20 17:44 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: systemtap

https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=19500

            Bug ID: 19500
           Summary: .callee test failures
           Product: systemtap
           Version: unspecified
            Status: NEW
          Severity: normal
          Priority: P2
         Component: translator
          Assignee: systemtap at sourceware dot org
          Reporter: dsmith at redhat dot com
  Target Milestone: ---

On RHEL7 s390x (3.10.0-327.el7.s390x), the callee.exp testcase gets the
following failures:

====
Running ../../src/testsuite/systemtap.base/callee.exp ...
FAIL: callee (inlined - probing .callee(foo).call)
FAIL: callee (reloc - listing shlib foo .callees)

                === systemtap Summary ===

# of expected passes            31
# of unexpected failures        2
====

But, in addition .callee causes lots of failures in the listing_mode.exp
testcase:

====
Running ../../src/testsuite/systemtap.base/listing_mode.exp ...
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar") 
-c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar") 
-c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar") 
-c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar")
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").call
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callee("libbar").return
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees 
-c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees 
-c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees 
-c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(1)
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(1)
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(1)
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(1) )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(1) )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(1) )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(1)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("./liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(2)
 -c listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(2)
 -c ./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode (process.library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(2)
 -c EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(2) )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(2) )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("SOFULLPATH").function("libfoo").callees(2) )
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
./listing_mode)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process.library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)  -c
EXEFULLPATH)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("./listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("EXEFULLPATH").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)
FAIL: listing_mode
(process("*listing_mode").library("*liblisting_mode.so").function("libfoo").callees(2)
)

                === systemtap Summary ===

# of expected passes            1236
# of unexpected failures        168
# of known failures             62
...
# grep ^FAIL systemtap.sum | fgrep -v callee
#
====

All 168 unexpected failures are related to callee probes.


A similar situation is seen on RHEL7 ppc64 (3.10.0-327.el7.ppc64):

====
Running ../../src/testsuite/systemtap.base/callee.exp ...
FAIL: callee (inlined - probing .callee(foo).call)
FAIL: callee (extern - probing main .callees)
FAIL: callee (reloc - probing shlib foo .callees)

                === systemtap Summary ===

# of expected passes            30
# of unexpected failures        3
====

On ppc64, listing_mode.exp doesn't show the failures that s390x shows.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread

* [Bug translator/19500] .callee test failures
  2016-01-20 17:44 [Bug translator/19500] New: .callee test failures dsmith at redhat dot com
@ 2016-02-19 19:44 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-25 22:37 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
                   ` (2 subsequent siblings)
  3 siblings, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: dsmith at redhat dot com @ 2016-02-19 19:44 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: systemtap

https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=19500

--- Comment #1 from David Smith <dsmith at redhat dot com> ---
This appears to be the result of s390x's odd debuginfo. On x86_64, you'll see
something like this (from 'eu-readelf --debug-dump libreloc.so'):

====
...
 [    2d]    subprogram
             external             (flag_present) Yes
             name                 (string) "bar"
...
 [    79]    subprogram
             external             (flag_present) Yes
             name                 (string) "foo"
...
             GNU_all_call_sites   (flag_present) Yes
...
 [    bb]      GNU_call_site
               low_pc               (addr) +0x00000000000006e2 <foo+0x12>
               abstract_origin      (ref4) [    2d]
...
====

This means that foo() has one callee, bar(), which we can see since foo() has 1
GNU_call_site attribute, whose abstract_origin is 2d (which maps to bar()).

On s390x, we see the following (from 'eu-readelf --debug-dump libreloc.so'):

====
...
 [    2d]    subprogram
             external             (flag_present) Yes
             name                 (string) "bar"
...
 [    7b]    subprogram
             external             (flag_present) Yes
             name                 (string) "foo"
...
             GNU_all_call_sites   (flag_present) Yes
 [    bd]      GNU_call_site
               low_pc               (addr) +0x000000000000073a <foo+0x22>
...
====

On s390x, we've got a GNU_call_site attribute, but it doesn't have an
abstract_origin attribute to tell us which function was called.

I've sent an email to a gcc developer and we'll see if he can shine any light
on this.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread

* [Bug translator/19500] .callee test failures
  2016-01-20 17:44 [Bug translator/19500] New: .callee test failures dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-19 19:44 ` [Bug translator/19500] " dsmith at redhat dot com
@ 2016-02-25 22:37 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-26 19:40 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-26 21:11 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
  3 siblings, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: dsmith at redhat dot com @ 2016-02-25 22:37 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: systemtap

https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=19500

--- Comment #2 from David Smith <dsmith at redhat dot com> ---
On ppc64, the debuginfo looks reasonable. In the 'reloc - probing shlib foo
.callees' case, what happens is that _caller_match() gets called in the probe
handler, returns false, so the handler exits early. With STAP_CALLEE_MATCHALL
defined in a couple of places, the test completely passes.

When the test fails in the 'reloc - probing shlib foo .callees' case, here's
what _caller_match() sees:

====
# stap -DDEBUG_SYMBOLS=1 -e 'probe
process("./reloc").library("libreloc.so").function("foo").callees {
printf("caller %s callee %s\n", usymname(ustack(1)),  ppfunc()) }' -c "./reloc
; true"
_stp_do_relocation:73: found kernel _stext load address: 0xc000000000000000
_stp_kmodule_update_address:1052: module
stap_694ab5dbd3f37227c1a6bd579439c70_21670 special section .note.gnu.build-id
address 0xd00000000cbe9af4
_stp_kmodule_update_address:1065: module
stap_694ab5dbd3f37227c1a6bd579439c70_21670 section .symtab address
0xd00000000cc20000
_stp_kmodule_update_address:1065: module
stap_694ab5dbd3f37227c1a6bd579439c70_21670 section .text address
0xd00000000cbd0000
_stp_usermodule_check:833: build-id validation [21675
/root/rhel7.2/testsuite/libreloc.so] address=0x3fffb03d0000
build_id_offset=0x1a0
_stp_umod_lookup:153: found module /root/rhel7.2/testsuite/libreloc.so at 0x0
_stp_umodule_relocate:78: [21675] /root/rhel7.2/testsuite/libreloc.so, 968
_stp_umodule_relocate:95: address=3fffb03d0968
function___global__caller_match:545: addr 0x968, stack 0x3fffb03d0964, reloc
0x3fffb03d0968
#
====

(note that the code for the last debug print isn't checked in)

Since the stack address (0x3fffb03d0964) doesn't *exactly* match the relocated
address (0x3fffb03d0968), _caller_match() returns 0. But, as you can see in
this case, the 2 addresses are only off by 4 bytes. Perhaps our math isn't
quite right somewhere.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread

* [Bug translator/19500] .callee test failures
  2016-01-20 17:44 [Bug translator/19500] New: .callee test failures dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-19 19:44 ` [Bug translator/19500] " dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-25 22:37 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
@ 2016-02-26 19:40 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
  2016-02-26 21:11 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
  3 siblings, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: dsmith at redhat dot com @ 2016-02-26 19:40 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: systemtap

https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=19500

--- Comment #3 from David Smith <dsmith at redhat dot com> ---
Commit 83b2752 added multiarch testing to callee.exp. With this commit, I'm
seeing the following error on an x86_64 fedora rawhide system:

FAIL: callee (simple - probing .callee(foo).return - 32-bit)

On a RHEL7 ppc64 machine, I'm seeing the following:

FAIL: callee (simple - probing .callees(3) - 64-bit)
FAIL: callee (extern - probing main .callees - 64-bit)
FAIL: callee (reloc - probing shlib foo .callees - 64-bit)
FAIL: callee (simple - probing .callees(2) - 32-bit)
FAIL: callee (multicalls - probing main .callees(2) - 32-bit)

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread

* [Bug translator/19500] .callee test failures
  2016-01-20 17:44 [Bug translator/19500] New: .callee test failures dsmith at redhat dot com
                   ` (2 preceding siblings ...)
  2016-02-26 19:40 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
@ 2016-02-26 21:11 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
  3 siblings, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: dsmith at redhat dot com @ 2016-02-26 21:11 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: systemtap

https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=19500

--- Comment #4 from David Smith <dsmith at redhat dot com> ---
On rawhide x86_64 (4.5.0-0.rc5.git0.1.fc24.x86_64), the "callee (simple -
probing .callee(foo).return - 32-bit)" failure is the equivalent of doing the
following:

====
# gcc ../../src/testsuite/systemtap.base/callee.simple.c -m32 -O -g -lm -o
callee
# stap -e 'probe process("./callee").function("main").callee("level1").return {
printf("caller %s callee %s\n", usymname(ustack(0)), ppfunc()) }' -c ./callee
WARNING: Child process exited with signal 11 (Segmentation fault)
WARNING: /usr/local/bin/staprun exited with status: 1
Pass 5: run failed.  [man error::pass5]
====

Without stap, callee runs without getting a SIGSEGV. This appears to be a
kernel problem, since I get the same SIGSEV without systemtap by just using
perf:

====
# gcc ../../src/testsuite/systemtap.base/callee.simple.c -m32 -O -g -lm -o
callee
# perf probe -x ./callee 'cmr=main%return'
Added new event:
  probe_callee:cmr     (on main%return in
/discer.farm/es/scratch/dsmith/systemtap/rawhide-64-2/testsuite/callee)

You can now use it in all perf tools, such as:

        perf record -e probe_callee:cmr -aR sleep 1

# perf record -e probe_callee:cmr -aR ./callee
[ perf record: Woken up 1 times to write data ]
[ perf record: Captured and wrote 0.148 MB perf.data (1 samples) ]
Segmentation fault
====

On RHEL7 x86_64 (3.10.0-347.el7.x86_64), I get the same "callee (simple -
probing .callee(foo).return - 32-bit)" failure when running the new callee.exp.
The output looks similar to the rawhide system:

====
# gcc ../../src/testsuite/systemtap.base/callee.simple.c -m32 -O -g -lm -o
callee
# stap -e 'probe process("./callee").function("main").callee("level1").return {
printf("caller %s callee %s\n", usymname(ustack(0)), ppfunc()) }' -c ./callee
WARNING: Child process exited with signal 11 (Segmentation fault)
WARNING: /usr/local/bin/staprun exited with status: 1
Pass 5: run failed.  [man error::pass5]
====

However, when run with perf, the target doesn't get a SIGSEGV:

====
# perf probe -x ./callee 'callee32=main%return'
Added new event:
  probe_callee:callee32 (on main%return in
/discer.farm/es/scratch/dsmith/systemtap/rhel7-64/testsuite/callee)

You can now use it in all perf tools, such as:

        perf record -e probe_callee:callee32 -aR sleep 1

# perf record -e probe_callee:callee32 -aR ./callee
[ perf record: Woken up 1 times to write data ]
[ perf record: Captured and wrote 0.145 MB perf.data (1 samples) ]
====

So, the RHEL7 failure appears to be a systemtap problem, since it doesn't
happen with perf.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread

end of thread, other threads:[~2016-02-26 21:11 UTC | newest]

Thread overview: 5+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
2016-01-20 17:44 [Bug translator/19500] New: .callee test failures dsmith at redhat dot com
2016-02-19 19:44 ` [Bug translator/19500] " dsmith at redhat dot com
2016-02-25 22:37 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
2016-02-26 19:40 ` dsmith at redhat dot com
2016-02-26 21:11 ` dsmith at redhat dot com

This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for read-only IMAP folder(s) and NNTP newsgroup(s).