calm and cygport not in sync

calm and cygport not in sync

[Marco Atzeri]

It seems calm is now rejecting what cygport is still producing


homepage: https://pypi.org/project/sh
category: Python
requires: python36
sdesc: "Python subprocess replacement"
ldesc: "full-fledged subprocess replacement for Python,
PyPy and PyPy3 that allows you to call any program
as if it were a function. sh is not a collection
of system commands implemented in Python."
obsoletes: python3-sh
external-source: python-sh

-------- Forwarded Message --------
Subject: calm: cygwin package upload report for Marco Atzeri
Date: Sun, 23 Jan 2022 22:08:29 -0000
From: cygwin-apps@cygwin.com
To: marco.atzeri@gmail.com

ERROR: package 'python36-sh' version '1.14.2-1' obsoletes: 'python3-sh', 
but nothing satisfies that
ERROR: package 'python36-straight.plugin' version '1.5.0-1' obsoletes: 
'python3-straight.plugin', but nothing satisfies that
ERROR: error while validating merged x86 packages for Marco Atzeri
ERROR: package 'python36-sh' version '1.14.2-1' obsoletes: 'python3-sh', 
but nothing satisfies that
ERROR: package 'python36-straight.plugin' version '1.5.0-1' obsoletes: 
'python3-straight.plugin', but nothing satisfies that
ERROR: error while validating merged x86_64 packages for Marco Atzeri
SUMMARY: 6 ERROR(s)
-------------------------------------------

temporary solved by hand

Marco

Re: calm and cygport not in sync

[Jon Turney]

On 24/01/2022 04:42, Marco Atzeri wrote:
> It seems calm is now rejecting what cygport is still producing
> 
[..]
> 
> ERROR: package 'python36-sh' version '1.14.2-1' obsoletes: 'python3-sh', 
> but nothing satisfies that
> ERROR: package 'python36-straight.plugin' version '1.5.0-1' obsoletes: 
> 'python3-straight.plugin', but nothing satisfies that
> ERROR: error while validating merged x86 packages for Marco Atzeri
> ERROR: package 'python36-sh' version '1.14.2-1' obsoletes: 'python3-sh', 
> but nothing satisfies that
> ERROR: package 'python36-straight.plugin' version '1.5.0-1' obsoletes: 
> 'python3-straight.plugin', but nothing satisfies that
> ERROR: error while validating merged x86_64 packages for Marco Atzeri
> SUMMARY: 6 ERROR(s)
> -------------------------------------------
> 
> temporary solved by hand
> 

Yes, there's a disconnect here.

cygport assumes that if we are making a 'python36-' package, a 
'python3-' version of the package exists which it should obsolete.

For a new package that assumption isn't correct, which calm considers an 
error.

I'll try to adjust calm so this isn't so annoying.

But I'm not sure this is how 'python3-' packages should be handled, 
which probably needs a bit of discussion.

I think I'd like it it if 'python3-' names were retained (so then 'setup 
-q -P python-foo' gets you a working 'python3 -c 'import foo''), but not 
sure how those names should work (as a forwarding package, as a 
provides?), or how those names should work in setup (e.g. it probably 
doesn't allow obsoletes/provides names to be searched for or specified 
with -P at the moment).