* Re: Suggested IRIX6 patch
@ 1998-03-26 21:54 Doug Semler
1998-03-30 16:18 ` Jeremiah W. James
0 siblings, 1 reply; 4+ messages in thread
From: Doug Semler @ 1998-03-26 21:54 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: egcs
-----Original Message-----
From: Jeremiah W. James <jerry@cs.ucsb.edu>
To: egcs@cygnus.com <egcs@cygnus.com>
Date: Thursday, March 26, 1998 11:20 AM
Subject: Suggested IRIX6 patch
>
>One philosophy of gcc/egcs seems to be "don't assume more processor than
>absolutely necessary, unless the user tells you so." That rule seems to
>be followed fairly well. One place where it is not followed is causing
>me problems.
>
>Irix 6 has three ABIs, 32 (= Irix 5 ABI, not currently supported for
>Irix 6), n32, and 64. When generating MIPS III or MIPS IV code, one of
>the latter two ABIs must be used. Everything is fine, in general,
>except that egcs currently does this: if -mabi=64 is specified, then it
>defaults to generating MIPS IV code! This is a problem, since MIPS III
>machines can also use the 64-bit ABI. When multilib is invoked, it gets
>the following arguments:
>
> -mabi=n32, which generates MIPS III code; and
> -mabi=64, which generates MIPS IV code!
>
>Frankly, that isn't right for anybody. Those, like me, with MIPS III
>machines cannot use the 64-bit ABI, since programs get linked with MIPS
>IV libraries, resulting in an unusable MIPS IV binary. Those with MIPS
>IV machines miss out on the advanced MIPS IV floating point instructions
>in the n32 libraries.
>
I think it's all hunky dory, but the default ISA used by the native compiler
is
mips3 for n32, and mips4 for 64. Changing the default in egcs would, IMHO
be a bad thing (ie unexpected for people moving from native to egcs.)
My $0.02
---
Doug Semler | doug@seaspace.com
SeaSpace Corporation | Garbage In -- Gospel Out
Least Senior Software Developer; | Minister of things to do Next Quarter
Low Man on the Totem Pole | (but will Never Be Done) DNRC O-
A closed mind is a terrible thing | Bus Error (passengers dumped)
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
* Re: Suggested IRIX6 patch
1998-03-26 21:54 Suggested IRIX6 patch Doug Semler
@ 1998-03-30 16:18 ` Jeremiah W. James
0 siblings, 0 replies; 4+ messages in thread
From: Jeremiah W. James @ 1998-03-30 16:18 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: egcs
Doug Semler <doug@seaspace.com> wrote:
> I think it's all hunky dory, but the default ISA used by the native compiler
> is
> mips3 for n32, and mips4 for 64. Changing the default in egcs would, IMHO
> be a bad thing (ie unexpected for people moving from native to egcs.)
>
>
> My $0.02
I have SGI's compiler version 7.1 on a MIPS III machine (Challenge
server). When I compile with -64 and no -mips option, I get MIPS III
code. Hence, the default for -64 appears to depend on the type of
machine on which you compile.
While I wouldn't want to confuse those using MIPS IV machines, do note
that -64 is completely unusable for those of us with MIPS III machines
as egcs currently stands. Perhaps it would be a good idea to either
autodetect the machine type (easily done with a small snippet of MIPS IV
code), or to create a configure option to choose between MIPS III and
MIPS IV defaults for -64.
--
Jerry James
Email: jerry@cs.ucsb.edu
WWW: http://www.cs.ucsb.edu/~jerry/
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
* Re: Suggested IRIX6 patch
1998-03-25 17:22 Jeremiah W. James
@ 1998-03-27 15:18 ` Jeremiah W. James
0 siblings, 0 replies; 4+ messages in thread
From: Jeremiah W. James @ 1998-03-27 15:18 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: egcs
And, naturally, after posting that patch I found there was a typo in
it. Two typos, in fact. I left out two critical % characters in the
link spec. Here's the corrected patch. And I checked the rest of it
for typos, too. Really.
Thu Mar 26 09:37:15 PST 1998 Jerry James (jerry@cs.ucsb.edu)
* gcc/config/mips/iris6.h: Pass appropriate ABI and instruction set
options to the linker when the user doesn't set both.
* gcc/config/mips/mips.c (override_options): default to MIPS III
instead of MIPS IV when -mabi=64
* gcc/config/mips/mips.h: Pass appropriate ABI and instruction set
options to the assembler and cc1 when the user doesn't set both.
* gcc/invoke.texi: Add documentation for new MIPS ABI and instruction
set options. Add ABI defaults to description of -mips options.
diff -u gcc/config/mips/iris6.h.ORIG gcc/config/mips/iris6.h
--- gcc/config/mips/iris6.h.ORIG Fri Jan 2 15:38:15 1998
+++ gcc/config/mips/iris6.h Thu Mar 26 09:36:47 1998
@@ -531,11 +531,11 @@
%{!mabi*:%{mips4:/usr/lib32/mips4/crtn.o%s}\
%{!mips4:/usr/lib32/mips3/crtn.o%s}}}"
-/* ??? If no mabi=X option give, but a mipsX option is, then should depend
- on the mipsX option. */
#undef LINK_SPEC
#define LINK_SPEC "\
-%{G*} %{EB} %{EL} %{mips1} %{mips2} %{mips3} %{mips4} \
+%{G*} %{EB} %{EL} \
+%{mips1:%{!mabi*:-32} -mips1} %{mips2:%{!mabi*:-32} -mips2} \
+%{mips3:%{!mabi*:-n32} -mips3} %{mips4:%{!mabi*:-64} -mips4} \
%{bestGnum} %{shared} %{non_shared} \
%{call_shared} %{no_archive} %{exact_version} %{w} \
%{static: -non_shared} \
@@ -543,4 +543,4 @@
%{!shared: %{!non_shared: %{!call_shared: -call_shared -no_unresolved}}}} \
%{rpath} -init __do_global_ctors -fini __do_global_dtors \
%{shared:-hidden_symbol __do_global_ctors,__do_global_dtors,__EH_FRAME_BEGIN__,__frame_dummy} \
--_SYSTYPE_SVR4 %{mabi=32: -32}%{mabi=n32: -n32}%{mabi=64: -64} %{!mabi*: -n32}"
+-_SYSTYPE_SVR4 %{mabi=32: -32}%{mabi=n32: -n32 %{!mips*:-mips3}}%{mabi=64: -64 %{!mips*:-mips3}} %{!mabi*: -n32 %{!mips*:-mips3}}"
diff -pu gcc/config/mips/mips.c.ORIG gcc/config/mips/mips.c
--- gcc/config/mips/mips.c.ORIG Wed Dec 24 14:06:51 1997
+++ gcc/config/mips/mips.c Wed Mar 25 10:16:24 1998
@@ -3462,10 +3462,8 @@ override_options ()
{
if (mips_abi == ABI_32)
mips_isa = 1;
- else if (mips_abi == ABI_N32)
- mips_isa = 3;
else
- mips_isa = 4;
+ mips_isa = 3;
}
/* If both ABI and ISA were specified, check for conflicts. */
else if (mips_isa_string && mips_abi_string)
diff -u gcc/config/mips/mips.h.ORIG gcc/config/mips/mips.h
--- gcc/config/mips/mips.h.ORIG Wed Dec 24 14:06:54 1997
+++ gcc/config/mips/mips.h Wed Mar 25 10:22:55 1998
@@ -717,7 +717,8 @@
%(subtarget_asm_optimizing_spec) \
%(subtarget_asm_debugging_spec) \
%{membedded-pic} \
-%{mabi=32:-32}%{mabi=o32:-32}%{mabi=n32:-n32}%{mabi=64:-64}%{mabi=n64:-64} \
+%{mabi=32:-32}%{mabi=o32:-32}%{mabi=n32:-n32 %{!mips*:-mips3}} \
+%{mabi=64:-64 %{!mips*:-mips3}}%{mabi=n64:-64 %{!mips*:-mips3}} \
%(target_asm_spec) \
%(subtarget_asm_spec)"
@@ -784,9 +785,12 @@
#ifndef CC1_SPEC
#define CC1_SPEC "\
%{gline:%{!g:%{!g0:%{!g1:%{!g2: -g1}}}}} \
-%{mips1:-mfp32 -mgp32} %{mips2:-mfp32 -mgp32}\
-%{mips3:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64} \
-%{mips4:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64} \
+%{mabi=n32:%{!mips*:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 -mips3}} \
+%{mabi=64:%{!mips*:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 -mips3}} \
+%{mips1:-mfp32 -mgp32 %{!mabi*:-mabi=32}} \
+%{mips2:-mfp32 -mgp32 %{!mabi*:-mabi=32}} \
+%{mips3:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 %{!mabi*:-mabi=n32}} \
+%{mips4:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 %{!mabi*:-mabi=64}} \
%{mfp64:%{msingle-float:%emay not use both -mfp64 and -msingle-float}} \
%{mfp64:%{m4650:%emay not use both -mfp64 and -m4650}} \
%{m4650:-mcpu=r4650} \
diff -u gcc/invoke.texi.ORIG gcc/invoke.texi
--- gcc/invoke.texi.ORIG Tue Dec 2 22:02:05 1997
+++ gcc/invoke.texi Wed Mar 25 11:06:31 1998
@@ -4254,28 +4254,45 @@
These @samp{-m} options are defined for the MIPS family of computers:
@table @code
+@item -mabi=@var{abi type}
+For Irix 6, choose the ABI to target. The choices for @var{abi type} are
+@samp{32}, @samp{n32}, and @samp{64}. With @samp{32}, the default
+instruction level is @samp{-mips1}. With @samp{n32} and @samp{64}, the
+default instruction level is @samp{-mips3}.
+
@item -mcpu=@var{cpu type}
Assume the defaults for the machine type @var{cpu type} when scheduling
instructions. The choices for @var{cpu type} are @samp{r2000}, @samp{r3000},
-@samp{r4000}, @samp{r4400}, @samp{r4600}, and @samp{r6000}. While picking a
-specific @var{cpu type} will schedule things appropriately for that
-particular chip, the compiler will not generate any code that does not
-meet level 1 of the MIPS ISA (instruction set architecture) without
-the @samp{-mips2} or @samp{-mips3} switches being used.
+@samp{r4000}, @samp{r4100}, @samp{r4300}, @samp{r4400}, @samp{r4600},
+@samp{r4650}, @samp{r5000}, @samp{r6000}, and @samp{r8000}. Additionally,
+the @samp{r2000}, @samp{r3000}, @samp{r4000}, @samp{r5000}, and
+@samp{r6000} can be abbreviated as @samp{r2k} (or @samp{r2K}),
+@samp{r3k}, etc. Finally, @samp{orion} is equivalent to @samp{r4600}.
+While picking a specific @var{cpu type} will schedule things appropriately
+for that articular chip, the compiler will not generate any code that does
+not meet level 1 of the MIPS ISA (instruction set architecture) without the
+@samp{-mips2}, @samp{-mips3}, @samp{-mips4}, @samp{-mabi=n32}, or
+@samp{-mabi=64} switches being used.
@item -mips1
Issue instructions from level 1 of the MIPS ISA. This is the default.
-@samp{r3000} is the default @var{cpu type} at this ISA level.
+At this ISA level, @samp{r3000} is the default @var{cpu type} and @samp{32}
+is the default @var{abi type}.
@item -mips2
Issue instructions from level 2 of the MIPS ISA (branch likely, square
-root instructions). @samp{r6000} is the default @var{cpu type} at this
-ISA level.
+root instructions). At this ISA level, @samp{r6000} is the default
+@var{cpu type} and @samp{32} is the default @var{abi type}.
@item -mips3
Issue instructions from level 3 of the MIPS ISA (64 bit instructions).
-@samp{r4000} is the default @var{cpu type} at this ISA level.
-This option does not change the sizes of any of the C data types.
+At this ISA level, @samp{r4000} is the default @var{cpu type} and @samp{n32}
+is the default @var{abi type}.
+
+@item -mips4
+Issue instructions from level 4 of the MIPS ISA (conditional move,
+prefetch, enhanced FPU instructions). At this ISA level, @samp{r8000} is
+the default @var{cpu type} and @samp{64} is the default @var{abi type}.
@item -mfp32
Assume that 32 32-bit floating point registers are available. This is
--
Jerry James
Email: jerry@cs.ucsb.edu
WWW: http://www.cs.ucsb.edu/~jerry/
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
* Suggested IRIX6 patch
@ 1998-03-25 17:22 Jeremiah W. James
1998-03-27 15:18 ` Jeremiah W. James
0 siblings, 1 reply; 4+ messages in thread
From: Jeremiah W. James @ 1998-03-25 17:22 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: egcs
One philosophy of gcc/egcs seems to be "don't assume more processor than
absolutely necessary, unless the user tells you so." That rule seems to
be followed fairly well. One place where it is not followed is causing
me problems.
Irix 6 has three ABIs, 32 (= Irix 5 ABI, not currently supported for
Irix 6), n32, and 64. When generating MIPS III or MIPS IV code, one of
the latter two ABIs must be used. Everything is fine, in general,
except that egcs currently does this: if -mabi=64 is specified, then it
defaults to generating MIPS IV code! This is a problem, since MIPS III
machines can also use the 64-bit ABI. When multilib is invoked, it gets
the following arguments:
-mabi=n32, which generates MIPS III code; and
-mabi=64, which generates MIPS IV code!
Frankly, that isn't right for anybody. Those, like me, with MIPS III
machines cannot use the 64-bit ABI, since programs get linked with MIPS
IV libraries, resulting in an unusable MIPS IV binary. Those with MIPS
IV machines miss out on the advanced MIPS IV floating point instructions
in the n32 libraries.
Here's a patch to fix my end of things. It makes -mabi=64 default to
-mips3, instead of -mips4, and fixes up some documentation. The result
is that multilib will generate two MIPS III libraries, one for each
ABI. Someone with a MIPS IV machine will probably want to do something
to let them get two MIPS IV libaries out of the deal. Note that these
patches are against the egcs 1.0.2 sources, not the mainline sources. I
apologize for that, but I don't really have the resources to use the CVS
repository, and it is unlikely that I will get them in the near future.
Wed Mar 25 10:49:13 PST 1998 Jerry James (jerry@cs.ucsb.edu)
* gcc/config/mips/iris6.h: Pass appropriate ABI and instruction set
options to the linker when the user doesn't set both.
* gcc/config/mips/mips.c (override_options): default to MIPS III
instead of MIPS IV when -mabi=64
* gcc/config/mips/mips.h: Pass appropriate ABI and instruction set
options to the assembler and cc1 when the user doesn't set both.
* gcc/invoke.texi: Add documentation for new MIPS ABI and instruction
set options. Add ABI defaults to description of -mips options.
diff -u gcc/config/mips/iris6.h.ORIG gcc/config/mips/iris6.h
--- gcc/config/mips/iris6.h.ORIG Fri Jan 2 15:38:15 1998
+++ gcc/config/mips/iris6.h Wed Mar 25 10:11:33 1998
@@ -531,11 +531,11 @@
%{!mabi*:%{mips4:/usr/lib32/mips4/crtn.o%s}\
%{!mips4:/usr/lib32/mips3/crtn.o%s}}}"
-/* ??? If no mabi=X option give, but a mipsX option is, then should depend
- on the mipsX option. */
#undef LINK_SPEC
#define LINK_SPEC "\
-%{G*} %{EB} %{EL} %{mips1} %{mips2} %{mips3} %{mips4} \
+%{G*} %{EB} %{EL} \
+%{mips1:%{!mabi*:-32} -mips1} %{mips2:{!mabi*:-32} -mips2} \
+%{mips3:%{!mabi*:-n32} -mips3} %{mips4:{!mabi*:-64} -mips4} \
%{bestGnum} %{shared} %{non_shared} \
%{call_shared} %{no_archive} %{exact_version} %{w} \
%{static: -non_shared} \
@@ -543,4 +543,4 @@
%{!shared: %{!non_shared: %{!call_shared: -call_shared -no_unresolved}}}} \
%{rpath} -init __do_global_ctors -fini __do_global_dtors \
%{shared:-hidden_symbol __do_global_ctors,__do_global_dtors,__EH_FRAME_BEGIN__,__frame_dummy} \
--_SYSTYPE_SVR4 %{mabi=32: -32}%{mabi=n32: -n32}%{mabi=64: -64} %{!mabi*: -n32}"
+-_SYSTYPE_SVR4 %{mabi=32: -32}%{mabi=n32: -n32 %{!mips*:-mips3}}%{mabi=64: -64 %{!mips*:-mips3}} %{!mabi*: -n32 %{!mips*:-mips3}}"
diff -pu gcc/config/mips/mips.c.ORIG gcc/config/mips/mips.c
--- gcc/config/mips/mips.c.ORIG Wed Dec 24 14:06:51 1997
+++ gcc/config/mips/mips.c Wed Mar 25 10:16:24 1998
@@ -3462,10 +3462,8 @@ override_options ()
{
if (mips_abi == ABI_32)
mips_isa = 1;
- else if (mips_abi == ABI_N32)
- mips_isa = 3;
else
- mips_isa = 4;
+ mips_isa = 3;
}
/* If both ABI and ISA were specified, check for conflicts. */
else if (mips_isa_string && mips_abi_string)
diff -u gcc/config/mips/mips.h.ORIG gcc/config/mips/mips.h
--- gcc/config/mips/mips.h.ORIG Wed Dec 24 14:06:54 1997
+++ gcc/config/mips/mips.h Wed Mar 25 10:22:55 1998
@@ -717,7 +717,8 @@
%(subtarget_asm_optimizing_spec) \
%(subtarget_asm_debugging_spec) \
%{membedded-pic} \
-%{mabi=32:-32}%{mabi=o32:-32}%{mabi=n32:-n32}%{mabi=64:-64}%{mabi=n64:-64} \
+%{mabi=32:-32}%{mabi=o32:-32}%{mabi=n32:-n32 %{!mips*:-mips3}} \
+%{mabi=64:-64 %{!mips*:-mips3}}%{mabi=n64:-64 %{!mips*:-mips3}} \
%(target_asm_spec) \
%(subtarget_asm_spec)"
@@ -784,9 +785,12 @@
#ifndef CC1_SPEC
#define CC1_SPEC "\
%{gline:%{!g:%{!g0:%{!g1:%{!g2: -g1}}}}} \
-%{mips1:-mfp32 -mgp32} %{mips2:-mfp32 -mgp32}\
-%{mips3:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64} \
-%{mips4:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64} \
+%{mabi=n32:%{!mips*:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 -mips3}} \
+%{mabi=64:%{!mips*:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 -mips3}} \
+%{mips1:-mfp32 -mgp32 %{!mabi*:-mabi=32}} \
+%{mips2:-mfp32 -mgp32 %{!mabi*:-mabi=32}} \
+%{mips3:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 %{!mabi*:-mabi=n32}} \
+%{mips4:%{!msingle-float:%{!m4650:-mfp64}} -mgp64 %{!mabi*:-mabi=64}} \
%{mfp64:%{msingle-float:%emay not use both -mfp64 and -msingle-float}} \
%{mfp64:%{m4650:%emay not use both -mfp64 and -m4650}} \
%{m4650:-mcpu=r4650} \
diff -u gcc/invoke.texi.ORIG gcc/invoke.texi
--- gcc/invoke.texi.ORIG Tue Dec 2 22:02:05 1997
+++ gcc/invoke.texi Wed Mar 25 11:06:31 1998
@@ -4254,28 +4254,45 @@
These @samp{-m} options are defined for the MIPS family of computers:
@table @code
+@item -mabi=@var{abi type}
+For Irix 6, choose the ABI to target. The choices for @var{abi type} are
+@samp{32}, @samp{n32}, and @samp{64}. With @samp{32}, the default
+instruction level is @samp{-mips1}. With @samp{n32} and @samp{64}, the
+default instruction level is @samp{-mips3}.
+
@item -mcpu=@var{cpu type}
Assume the defaults for the machine type @var{cpu type} when scheduling
instructions. The choices for @var{cpu type} are @samp{r2000}, @samp{r3000},
-@samp{r4000}, @samp{r4400}, @samp{r4600}, and @samp{r6000}. While picking a
-specific @var{cpu type} will schedule things appropriately for that
-particular chip, the compiler will not generate any code that does not
-meet level 1 of the MIPS ISA (instruction set architecture) without
-the @samp{-mips2} or @samp{-mips3} switches being used.
+@samp{r4000}, @samp{r4100}, @samp{r4300}, @samp{r4400}, @samp{r4600},
+@samp{r4650}, @samp{r5000}, @samp{r6000}, and @samp{r8000}. Additionally,
+the @samp{r2000}, @samp{r3000}, @samp{r4000}, @samp{r5000}, and
+@samp{r6000} can be abbreviated as @samp{r2k} (or @samp{r2K}),
+@samp{r3k}, etc. Finally, @samp{orion} is equivalent to @samp{r4600}.
+While picking a specific @var{cpu type} will schedule things appropriately
+for that articular chip, the compiler will not generate any code that does
+not meet level 1 of the MIPS ISA (instruction set architecture) without the
+@samp{-mips2}, @samp{-mips3}, @samp{-mips4}, @samp{-mabi=n32}, or
+@samp{-mabi=64} switches being used.
@item -mips1
Issue instructions from level 1 of the MIPS ISA. This is the default.
-@samp{r3000} is the default @var{cpu type} at this ISA level.
+At this ISA level, @samp{r3000} is the default @var{cpu type} and @samp{32}
+is the default @var{abi type}.
@item -mips2
Issue instructions from level 2 of the MIPS ISA (branch likely, square
-root instructions). @samp{r6000} is the default @var{cpu type} at this
-ISA level.
+root instructions). At this ISA level, @samp{r6000} is the default
+@var{cpu type} and @samp{32} is the default @var{abi type}.
@item -mips3
Issue instructions from level 3 of the MIPS ISA (64 bit instructions).
-@samp{r4000} is the default @var{cpu type} at this ISA level.
-This option does not change the sizes of any of the C data types.
+At this ISA level, @samp{r4000} is the default @var{cpu type} and @samp{n32}
+is the default @var{abi type}.
+
+@item -mips4
+Issue instructions from level 4 of the MIPS ISA (conditional move,
+prefetch, enhanced FPU instructions). At this ISA level, @samp{r8000} is
+the default @var{cpu type} and @samp{64} is the default @var{abi type}.
@item -mfp32
Assume that 32 32-bit floating point registers are available. This is
--
Jerry James
Email: jerry@cs.ucsb.edu
WWW: http://www.cs.ucsb.edu/~jerry/
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~1998-03-30 16:18 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 4+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
1998-03-26 21:54 Suggested IRIX6 patch Doug Semler
1998-03-30 16:18 ` Jeremiah W. James
-- strict thread matches above, loose matches on Subject: below --
1998-03-25 17:22 Jeremiah W. James
1998-03-27 15:18 ` Jeremiah W. James
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for read-only IMAP folder(s) and NNTP newsgroup(s).