* [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering (bug 30869)
@ 2023-09-19 8:48 Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests Florian Weimer
` (3 more replies)
0 siblings, 4 replies; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-09-19 8:48 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: libc-alpha
It turns out that we cannot simply reverse the constructor ordering.
Some applications expect that the main program is destructed first.
It also seems reasonable to assume that some applications depend
on the destructor ordering resulting from explicit dlclose calls
upon exit time (destructors calling dlclose).
The change in main program destructor ordering went unnoticed because
the DSO ordering test framework did not record main program
constructor/destructor calls, so the first commit fixes that omission.
Thanks,
Florian
Florian Weimer (3):
elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
elf: Add dummy declaration of _dl_audit_objclose for !SHARED
elf: Process initially loaded objects first in _dl_fini (bug 30869)
elf/Makefile | 21 +++++++++++++
elf/dl-fini.c | 49 ++++++++++++++++++++---------
elf/dl-init.c | 38 ++++++++++++++++------
elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def | 24 +++++++-------
elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def | 4 +--
elf/tst-finiorder1.c | 52 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder1mod1.c | 43 +++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder1mod2.c | 36 +++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2.c | 61 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2mod1.c | 49 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2mod2.c | 35 +++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2mod3.c | 36 +++++++++++++++++++++
scripts/dso-ordering-test.py | 32 ++++++++++++-------
sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h | 12 ++++++-
14 files changed, 441 insertions(+), 51 deletions(-)
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder1.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder1mod1.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder1mod2.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2mod1.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2mod2.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2mod3.c
base-commit: 5bc9b3a1f6a003f6456f717b590615ea98e2d6fb
--
2.41.0
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
2023-09-19 8:48 [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
@ 2023-09-19 8:48 ` Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:56 ` Andreas Schwab
2023-09-19 12:41 ` Carlos O'Donell
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 2/3] elf: Add dummy declaration of _dl_audit_objclose for !SHARED Florian Weimer
` (2 subsequent siblings)
3 siblings, 2 replies; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-09-19 8:48 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: libc-alpha
Previously, the ordering was not capture in the test output. Adjust
expected test output accordingly. Note that after commit 6985865bc3a
("elf: Always call destructors in reverse constructor order
(bug 30785)"), the main program destructors in tst-bz28937 run last
(which is bug XXX).
---
elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def | 24 ++++++++++++------------
elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def | 4 ++--
scripts/dso-ordering-test.py | 32 +++++++++++++++++++++-----------
3 files changed, 35 insertions(+), 25 deletions(-)
diff --git a/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def b/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
index 61dc54f8ae..cefc474e4f 100644
--- a/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
+++ b/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
@@ -8,59 +8,59 @@ tunable_option: glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=2
# Sequence of single dependencies with no cycles.
tst-dso-ordering1: a->b->c
-output: c>b>a>{}<a<b<c
+output: c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c
# Sequence including 2 dependent DSOs not at the end of the graph.
tst-dso-ordering2: a->b->[cd]->e
-output: e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e
+output: e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e
# Complex order with 3 "layers" of full dependencies
tst-dso-ordering3: a->[bc]->[def]->[gh]->i
-output: i>h>g>f>e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e<f<g<h<i
+output: i>h>g>f>e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e<f<g<h<i
# Sequence including 2 dependent DSOs at the end of the graph.
# Additionally the same dependencies appear in two paths.
tst-dso-ordering4: a->b->[de];a->c->d->e
-output: e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e
+output: e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e
# Test that b->c cross link is respected correctly
tst-dso-ordering5: a!->[bc]->d;b->c
-output: d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d
+output: d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d
# First DSO fully dependent on 4 DSOs, with another DSO at the end of chain.
tst-dso-ordering6: a->[bcde]->f
-output: f>e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e<f
+output: f>e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e<f
# Sequence including 2 dependent and 3 dependent DSOs, and one of the
# dependent DSOs is dependent on an earlier DSO.
tst-dso-ordering7: a->[bc];b->[cde];e->f
-output: f>e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e<f
+output: f>e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e<f
# Sequence where the DSO c is unerlinked and calls a function in DSO a which
# is technically a cycle. The main executable depends on the first two DSOs.
# Note: This test has unspecified behavior.
tst-dso-ordering8: a->b->c=>a;{}->[ba]
-output: c>b>a>{}<a<b<c
+output: c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c
# Generate the permutation of DT_NEEDED order between the main binary and
# all 5 DSOs; all link orders should produce exact same init/fini ordering
tst-dso-ordering9: a->b->c->d->e;{}!->[abcde]
-output: e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e
+output: e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e
# Test if init/fini ordering behavior is proper, despite main program with
# an soname that may cause confusion
tst-dso-ordering10: {}->a->b->c;soname({})=c
-output: b>a>{}<a<b
+output: b>a>.>{}<.<a<b
# Complex example from Bugzilla #15311, under-linked and with circular
# relocation(dynamic) dependencies. For both sorting algorithms, the
# destruction order is the reverse of the construction order, and
# relocation dependencies are not taken into account.
tst-bz15311: {+a;+e;+f;+g;+d;%d;-d;-g;-f;-e;-a};a->b->c->d;d=>[ba];c=>a;b=>e=>a;c=>f=>b;d=>g=>c
-output: {+a[d>c>b>a>];+e[e>];+f[f>];+g[g>];+d[];%d(b(e(a()))a()g(c(a()f(b(e(a()))))));-d[];-g[];-f[];-e[];-a[<g<f<e<a<b<c<d];}
+output: .>{+a[d>c>b>a>];+e[e>];+f[f>];+g[g>];+d[];%d(b(e(a()))a()g(c(a()f(b(e(a()))))));-d[];-g[];-f[];-e[];-a[<g<f<e<a<b<c<d];}<.
# Test that even in the presence of dependency loops involving dlopen'ed
# object, that object is initialized last (and not unloaded prematurely).
# Final destructor order is the opposite of constructor order.
tst-bz28937: {+a;+b;-b;+c;%c};a->a1;a->a2;a2->a;b->b1;c->a1;c=>a1
-output: {+a[a2>a1>a>];+b[b1>b>];-b[<b<b1];+c[c>];%c(a1());}<c<a<a1<a2
+output: .>{+a[a2>a1>a>];+b[b1>b>];-b[<b<b1];+c[c>];%c(a1());}<c<a<a1<a2<.
diff --git a/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def b/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def
index b79e79ecb7..73792de53b 100644
--- a/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def
+++ b/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def
@@ -610,5 +610,5 @@ M30X22
M30X23
M30X24
M30X25
-xfail_output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=1): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M27X14>M28X18>M27X15>M28X13>M27X11>M28X23>M27X25>M28X14>M28X25>M27X23>M27X22>M28X24>M27X21>M27X13>M27X19>M27X17>M26X11>M26X23>M26X21>M26X22>M26X20>M26X16>M25X21>M17X22>M15X15>M20X14>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>M27X24>M25X17>M27X20>M26X18>M26X17>M27X16>M26X19>M25X18>M26X24>M25X20>M24X17>M23X18>M25X13>M26X13>M17X23>M16X16>M26X12>M25X12>M26X15>M24X19>M25X23>M25X24>M25X25>M24X20>M25X19>M24X21>M23X17>M22X21>M24X14>M23X22>M24X24>M22X20>M24X13>M25X11>M24X12>M25X15>M23X15>M25X16>M24X22>M23X13>M24X18>M23X14>M22X22>M21X20>M24X25>M23X16>M22X25>M21X19>M22X14>M23X11>M22X15>M21X18>M22X19>M21X17>M20X17>M19X17>M21X24>M21X12>M20X22>M19X16>M18X25>M19X21>M19X20>M18X24>M20X12>M19X11>M23X20>M22X24>M22X16>M21X21>M25X14>M23X19>M23X24>M20X24>M19X12>M18X15>M17X14>M16X18>M14X25>M16X22>M16X20>M17X17>M22X12>M21X11>M20X15>M18X22>M19X24>M19X18>M18X21>M17X16>M17X18>M16X21>M15X20>M19X22>M18X20>M18X11>M17X19>M16X17>M15X21>M16X14>M16X13>M15X22>M14X20>M17X25>M16X19>M14X21>M13X24>M12X12>M16X24>M15X23>M14X16>M16X15>M15X25>M15X11>M15X12>M14X15>M13X14>M14X22>M13X20>M12X13>M11X11>M22X23>M21X15>M21X16>M20X21>M20X20>M18X17>M19X25>M18X23>M21X13>M15X17>M15X18>M18X19>M17X24>M16X12>M17X13>M20X25>M19X23>M15X19>M14X13>M13X18>M15X13>M17X12>M16X11>M18X13>M18X12>M14X11>M14X24>M13X19>M15X14>M17X20>M20X11>M20X13>M21X14>M15X24>M14X12>M13X22>M14X23>M13X23>M14X19>M17X15>M16X25>M17X11>M18X14>M19X19>M21X25>M13X12>M13X11>M14X18>M13X13>M12X11>M15X16>M14X14>M27X12>M17X21>M20X23>M22X13>M21X22>M24X16>M24X15>M26X25>M23X25>M26X14>M23X12>M22X18>M24X11>M16X23>M19X14>M19X13>M21X23>M22X17>M23X23>M23X21>M25X22>M18X16>M19X15>M20X18>M20X19>M22X11>M24X23>C156>C118>C143>C137>C147>C106>C168>C113>C163>C155>C105>C146>C187>A150>C139>C180>C164>C193>C157>A191>C158>B188>A159>C184>C121>C154>B171>A105>C131>C104>B104>C161>C111>B145>C160>B155>A163>C112>C142>B148>C133>B198>A198>A115>C114>B157>A156>C175>B144>A120>C173>B184>A174>C126>B107>A139>C194>B194>A194>C116>B116>C166>B160>B110>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B162>A154>C186>B187>A179>C124>B181>A101>C153>B158>A136>C135>C176>A192>B133>A133>C177>B177>A177>C185>C103>B141>A141>C183>A162>C192>C129>B179>C144>B124>B183>C127>B127>A127>B108>A112>B153>A153>C167>B167>A186>A122>C162>A144>B149>C174>B131>A185>C141>B106>A126>A167>C140>B122>A170>C198>B143>C117>C123>B123>A147>A106>C200>B169>C191>B175>A123>B118>A182>C132>B151>A145>A104>A109>C159>C150>B119>A119>A178>B164>B114>A164>C181>A102>C122>B134>A157>A116>C195>B191>B111>C172>B172>A118>B129>A129>C149>A107>C170>B197>A197>A173>B168>A132>C107>B165>A160>A131>C188>A168>B109>C178>A189>A148>C119>C190>C120>B166>B176>C108>B135>B139>A103>B178>A169>B132>C125>C138>B163>A111>B170>C110>A165>C151>C169>C199>A138>C182>A135>B101>B142>C101>C148>B193>B152>A158>A199>C136>B137>A161>B120>A108>A149>A125>B113>A184>C171>A134>A175>A124>B150>B161>B102>A146>A187>C130>B192>B200>A200>A142>A183>C102>B105>B156>A176>C165>B147>A137>A196>B190>A190>B125>C134>C189>B126>B186>A166>B136>B195>A195>B154>B138>B112>B173>A117>B159>B182>A181>A140>C145>B117>A152>A193>C197>B130>A172>A113>A151>B115>A143>B140>B185>B103>A121>A180>A130>A171>B199>C196>B146>B180>C115>B174>B121>A188>B196>B189>C152>C109>A155>A114>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>{}<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<A114<A155<C109<C152<B189<B196<A188<B121<B174<C115<B180<B146<C196<B199<A171<A130<A180<A121<B103<B185<B140<A143<B115<A151<A113<A172<B130<C197<A193<A152<B117<C145<A140<A181<B182<B159<A117<B173<B112<B138<B154<A195<B195<B136<A166<B186<B126<C189<C134<B125<A190<B190<A196<A137<B147<C165<A176<B156<B105<C102<A183<A142<A200<B200<B192<C130<A187<A146<B102<B161<B150<A124<A175<A134<C171<A184<B113<A125<A149<A108<B120<A161<B137<C136<A199<A158<B152<B193<C148<C101<B142<B101<A135<C182<A138<C199<C169<C151<A165<C110<B170<A111<B163<C138<C125<B132<A169<B178<A103<B139<B135<C108<B176<B166<C120<C190<C119<A148<A189<C178<B109<A168<C188<A131<A160<B165<C107<A132<B168<A173<A197<B197<C170<A107<C149<A129<B129<A118<B172<C172<B111<B191<C195<A116<A157<B134<C122<A102<C181<A164<B114<B164<A178<A119<B119<C150<C159<A109<A104<A145<B151<C132<A182<B118<A123<B175<C191<B169<C200<A106<A147<B123<C123<C117<B143<C198<A170<B122<C140<A167<A126<B106<C141<A185<B131<C174<B149<A144<C162<A122<A186<B167<C167<A153<B153<A112<B108<A127<B127<C127<B183<B124<C144<B179<C129<C192<A162<C183<A141<B141<C103<C185<A177<B177<C177<A133<B133<A192<C176<C135<A136<B158<C153<A101<B181<C124<A179<B187<C186<A154<B162<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B110<B160<C166<B116<C116<A194<B194<C194<A139<B107<C126<A174<B184<C173<A120<B144<C175<A156<B157<C114<A115<A198<B198<C133<B148<C142<C112<A163<B155<C160<B145<C111<C161<B104<C104<C131<A105<B171<C154<C121<C184<A159<B188<C158<A191<C157<C193<C164<C180<C139<A150<C187<C146<C105<C155<C163<C113<C168<C106<C147<C137<C143<C118<C156<M24X23<M22X11<M20X19<M20X18<M19X15<M18X16<M25X22<M23X21<M23X23<M22X17<M21X23<M19X13<M19X14<M16X23<M24X11<M22X18<M23X12<M26X14<M23X25<M26X25<M24X15<M24X16<M21X22<M22X13<M20X23<M17X21<M27X12<M14X14<M15X16<M12X11<M13X13<M14X18<M13X11<M13X12<M21X25<M19X19<M18X14<M17X11<M16X25<M17X15<M14X19<M13X23<M14X23<M13X22<M14X12<M15X24<M21X14<M20X13<M20X11<M17X20<M15X14<M13X19<M14X24<M14X11<M18X12<M18X13<M16X11<M17X12<M15X13<M13X18<M14X13<M15X19<M19X23<M20X25<M17X13<M16X12<M17X24<M18X19<M15X18<M15X17<M21X13<M18X23<M19X25<M18X17<M20X20<M20X21<M21X16<M21X15<M22X23<M11X11<M12X13<M13X20<M14X22<M13X14<M14X15<M15X12<M15X11<M15X25<M16X15<M14X16<M15X23<M16X24<M12X12<M13X24<M14X21<M16X19<M17X25<M14X20<M15X22<M16X13<M16X14<M15X21<M16X17<M17X19<M18X11<M18X20<M19X22<M15X20<M16X21<M17X18<M17X16<M18X21<M19X18<M19X24<M18X22<M20X15<M21X11<M22X12<M17X17<M16X20<M16X22<M14X25<M16X18<M17X14<M18X15<M19X12<M20X24<M23X24<M23X19<M25X14<M21X21<M22X16<M22X24<M23X20<M19X11<M20X12<M18X24<M19X20<M19X21<M18X25<M19X16<M20X22<M21X12<M21X24<M19X17<M20X17<M21X17<M22X19<M21X18<M22X15<M23X11<M22X14<M21X19<M22X25<M23X16<M24X25<M21X20<M22X22<M23X14<M24X18<M23X13<M24X22<M25X16<M23X15<M25X15<M24X12<M25X11<M24X13<M22X20<M24X24<M23X22<M24X14<M22X21<M23X17<M24X21<M25X19<M24X20<M25X25<M25X24<M25X23<M24X19<M26X15<M25X12<M26X12<M16X16<M17X23<M26X13<M25X13<M23X18<M24X17<M25X20<M26X24<M25X18<M26X19<M27X16<M26X17<M26X18<M27X20<M25X17<M27X24<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M20X14<M15X15<M17X22<M25X21<M26X16<M26X20<M26X22<M26X21<M26X23<M26X11<M27X17<M27X19<M27X13<M27X21<M28X24<M27X22<M27X23<M28X25<M28X14<M27X25<M28X23<M27X11<M28X13<M27X15<M28X18<M27X14<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
-output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=2): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M28X24>M28X23>M27X21>M28X13>M27X20>M27X19>M26X14>M27X25>M28X18>M27X11>M28X25>M27X24>M26X24>M27X15>M27X14>M27X13>M26X23>M27X17>M26X22>M25X13>M28X14>M27X16>M26X19>M26X18>M27X23>M27X22>M26X17>M25X18>M26X21>M25X17>M26X20>M26X15>M26X13>M25X19>M24X14>M25X23>M26X11>M26X25>M25X16>M25X15>M24X22>M25X21>M25X20>M24X21>M25X25>M25X24>M24X20>M23X13>M22X15>M25X14>M24X19>M23X17>M24X25>M23X24>M24X13>M23X15>M24X18>M23X14>M22X11>M24X15>M23X22>M24X11>M23X19>M22X21>M24X24>M23X21>M22X20>M23X25>M22X19>M21X24>M20X23>M22X22>M25X11>M23X16>M22X18>M23X20>M22X17>M21X21>M21X20>M20X24>M22X14>M22X13>M21X11>M21X17>M22X23>M21X16>M20X25>M19X23>M18X16>M21X22>M20X20>M20X19>M21X13>M20X18>M19X13>M21X18>M20X21>M19X24>M18X12>M20X14>M20X13>M22X25>M20X12>M20X15>M19X14>M18X22>M19X18>M20X17>M19X17>M19X16>M18X21>M17X20>M19X19>M18X13>M17X11>M18X17>M19X25>M18X15>M17X25>M18X19>M17X24>M16X19>M15X17>M17X21>M16X24>M18X23>M17X16>M16X25>M19X15>M18X25>M17X23>M16X23>M15X23>M18X14>M17X14>M16X14>M17X18>M16X13>M17X22>M16X12>M15X22>M14X16>M17X12>M16X22>M15X12>M16X11>M15X11>M16X15>M15X25>M14X15>M13X14>M15X18>M16X21>M15X16>M14X21>M15X14>M16X20>M15X13>M14X22>M15X20>M14X20>M13X20>M14X11>M15X19>M14X24>M13X19>M14X13>M13X18>M12X13>M15X24>M14X23>M13X12>M14X12>M13X11>M12X11>M11X11>M21X12>M20X11>M19X11>M18X11>M17X15>M16X18>M14X25>M14X19>M13X24>M13X23>M13X22>M12X12>M22X12>M21X15>M19X22>M18X20>M16X17>M14X14>M24X12>M23X23>M22X16>M21X14>M20X22>M18X24>M16X16>M26X12>M24X16>M23X11>M21X23>M19X20>M17X17>M27X12>M26X16>M25X22>M24X17>M23X18>M21X25>M19X12>M17X19>M15X21>M14X18>M13X13>M23X12>M21X19>M19X21>M17X13>M15X15>M25X12>M24X23>M22X24>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>A150>C158>B112>A112>C167>B146>A146>C180>B180>A180>C143>B143>A115>C126>B126>A126>C190>B190>A190>C138>B138>A138>C174>B174>A102>C122>B122>A122>C162>B162>A162>C142>B142>A142>C102>B102>A174>C176>B176>A176>C115>B115>A143>C172>B172>A172>C187>B187>A187>C130>B130>A130>C118>B118>A118>C184>B184>A184>C171>B171>A171>C168>B182>A182>C182>B168>A168>C109>B109>A109>C159>B159>A159>C134>B134>A134>C146>B167>A167>C140>B140>A140>C163>B163>A163>C112>B158>A158>C164>B164>A164>C131>B131>A131>C188>B188>A188>C199>B199>A199>C114>B114>A114>C106>B106>A106>C200>B200>A200>C183>B183>A183>C152>B152>A152>C147>B147>A147>C150>B150>A198>C144>B144>A144>C191>B191>A191>C108>B108>A108>C139>B139>A139>C194>B194>A194>C166>B166>A166>C120>B120>A120>C123>B123>A123>C132>B132>A132>C107>B107>A107>C170>B170>A170>C198>B198>A156>C125>B125>A125>C121>B121>A121>C193>B193>A193>C197>B197>A197>C175>B175>A175>C196>B196>A196>C105>B105>A105>C181>B181>A181>C113>B113>A113>C137>B137>A137>C155>B155>A155>C156>B156>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B179>A179>C124>B124>A124>C151>B151>A151>C178>B178>A178>C104>B104>A104>C111>B111>A111>C148>B148>A148>C169>B169>A169>C129>B129>A129>C149>B149>A149>C189>B189>A189>C119>B119>A119>C154>B154>A154>C136>B136>A136>C135>B135>A135>C116>B116>A116>C145>B145>A145>C161>B161>A161>C173>B173>A173>C157>B157>A157>C195>B195>A195>C186>B186>A186>C160>B160>A160>C153>B153>A153>C117>B117>A117>C165>B165>A165>C101>B101>A101>C103>B103>A103>C192>B192>A192>C177>B177>A177>C185>B185>A185>C141>B141>A141>C133>B133>A133>C127>B127>A127>C110>B110>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>{}<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<B110<C110<A127<B127<C127<A133<B133<C133<A141<B141<C141<A185<B185<C185<A177<B177<C177<A192<B192<C192<A103<B103<C103<A101<B101<C101<A165<B165<C165<A117<B117<C117<A153<B153<C153<A160<B160<C160<A186<B186<C186<A195<B195<C195<A157<B157<C157<A173<B173<C173<A161<B161<C161<A145<B145<C145<A116<B116<C116<A135<B135<C135<A136<B136<C136<A154<B154<C154<A119<B119<C119<A189<B189<C189<A149<B149<C149<A129<B129<C129<A169<B169<C169<A148<B148<C148<A111<B111<C111<A104<B104<C104<A178<B178<C178<A151<B151<C151<A124<B124<C124<A179<B179<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B156<C156<A155<B155<C155<A137<B137<C137<A113<B113<C113<A181<B181<C181<A105<B105<C105<A196<B196<C196<A175<B175<C175<A197<B197<C197<A193<B193<C193<A121<B121<C121<A125<B125<C125<A156<B198<C198<A170<B170<C170<A107<B107<C107<A132<B132<C132<A123<B123<C123<A120<B120<C120<A166<B166<C166<A194<B194<C194<A139<B139<C139<A108<B108<C108<A191<B191<C191<A144<B144<C144<A198<B150<C150<A147<B147<C147<A152<B152<C152<A183<B183<C183<A200<B200<C200<A106<B106<C106<A114<B114<C114<A199<B199<C199<A188<B188<C188<A131<B131<C131<A164<B164<C164<A158<B158<C112<A163<B163<C163<A140<B140<C140<A167<B167<C146<A134<B134<C134<A159<B159<C159<A109<B109<C109<A168<B168<C182<A182<B182<C168<A171<B171<C171<A184<B184<C184<A118<B118<C118<A130<B130<C130<A187<B187<C187<A172<B172<C172<A143<B115<C115<A176<B176<C176<A174<B102<C102<A142<B142<C142<A162<B162<C162<A122<B122<C122<A102<B174<C174<A138<B138<C138<A190<B190<C190<A126<B126<C126<A115<B143<C143<A180<B180<C180<A146<B146<C167<A112<B112<C158<A150<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M22X24<M24X23<M25X12<M15X15<M17X13<M19X21<M21X19<M23X12<M13X13<M14X18<M15X21<M17X19<M19X12<M21X25<M23X18<M24X17<M25X22<M26X16<M27X12<M17X17<M19X20<M21X23<M23X11<M24X16<M26X12<M16X16<M18X24<M20X22<M21X14<M22X16<M23X23<M24X12<M14X14<M16X17<M18X20<M19X22<M21X15<M22X12<M12X12<M13X22<M13X23<M13X24<M14X19<M14X25<M16X18<M17X15<M18X11<M19X11<M20X11<M21X12<M11X11<M12X11<M13X11<M14X12<M13X12<M14X23<M15X24<M12X13<M13X18<M14X13<M13X19<M14X24<M15X19<M14X11<M13X20<M14X20<M15X20<M14X22<M15X13<M16X20<M15X14<M14X21<M15X16<M16X21<M15X18<M13X14<M14X15<M15X25<M16X15<M15X11<M16X11<M15X12<M16X22<M17X12<M14X16<M15X22<M16X12<M17X22<M16X13<M17X18<M16X14<M17X14<M18X14<M15X23<M16X23<M17X23<M18X25<M19X15<M16X25<M17X16<M18X23<M16X24<M17X21<M15X17<M16X19<M17X24<M18X19<M17X25<M18X15<M19X25<M18X17<M17X11<M18X13<M19X19<M17X20<M18X21<M19X16<M19X17<M20X17<M19X18<M18X22<M19X14<M20X15<M20X12<M22X25<M20X13<M20X14<M18X12<M19X24<M20X21<M21X18<M19X13<M20X18<M21X13<M20X19<M20X20<M21X22<M18X16<M19X23<M20X25<M21X16<M22X23<M21X17<M21X11<M22X13<M22X14<M20X24<M21X20<M21X21<M22X17<M23X20<M22X18<M23X16<M25X11<M22X22<M20X23<M21X24<M22X19<M23X25<M22X20<M23X21<M24X24<M22X21<M23X19<M24X11<M23X22<M24X15<M22X11<M23X14<M24X18<M23X15<M24X13<M23X24<M24X25<M23X17<M24X19<M25X14<M22X15<M23X13<M24X20<M25X24<M25X25<M24X21<M25X20<M25X21<M24X22<M25X15<M25X16<M26X25<M26X11<M25X23<M24X14<M25X19<M26X13<M26X15<M26X20<M25X17<M26X21<M25X18<M26X17<M27X22<M27X23<M26X18<M26X19<M27X16<M28X14<M25X13<M26X22<M27X17<M26X23<M27X13<M27X14<M27X15<M26X24<M27X24<M28X25<M27X11<M28X18<M27X25<M26X14<M27X19<M27X20<M28X13<M27X21<M28X23<M28X24<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
+xfail_output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=1): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M27X14>M28X18>M27X15>M28X13>M27X11>M28X23>M27X25>M28X14>M28X25>M27X23>M27X22>M28X24>M27X21>M27X13>M27X19>M27X17>M26X11>M26X23>M26X21>M26X22>M26X20>M26X16>M25X21>M17X22>M15X15>M20X14>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>M27X24>M25X17>M27X20>M26X18>M26X17>M27X16>M26X19>M25X18>M26X24>M25X20>M24X17>M23X18>M25X13>M26X13>M17X23>M16X16>M26X12>M25X12>M26X15>M24X19>M25X23>M25X24>M25X25>M24X20>M25X19>M24X21>M23X17>M22X21>M24X14>M23X22>M24X24>M22X20>M24X13>M25X11>M24X12>M25X15>M23X15>M25X16>M24X22>M23X13>M24X18>M23X14>M22X22>M21X20>M24X25>M23X16>M22X25>M21X19>M22X14>M23X11>M22X15>M21X18>M22X19>M21X17>M20X17>M19X17>M21X24>M21X12>M20X22>M19X16>M18X25>M19X21>M19X20>M18X24>M20X12>M19X11>M23X20>M22X24>M22X16>M21X21>M25X14>M23X19>M23X24>M20X24>M19X12>M18X15>M17X14>M16X18>M14X25>M16X22>M16X20>M17X17>M22X12>M21X11>M20X15>M18X22>M19X24>M19X18>M18X21>M17X16>M17X18>M16X21>M15X20>M19X22>M18X20>M18X11>M17X19>M16X17>M15X21>M16X14>M16X13>M15X22>M14X20>M17X25>M16X19>M14X21>M13X24>M12X12>M16X24>M15X23>M14X16>M16X15>M15X25>M15X11>M15X12>M14X15>M13X14>M14X22>M13X20>M12X13>M11X11>M22X23>M21X15>M21X16>M20X21>M20X20>M18X17>M19X25>M18X23>M21X13>M15X17>M15X18>M18X19>M17X24>M16X12>M17X13>M20X25>M19X23>M15X19>M14X13>M13X18>M15X13>M17X12>M16X11>M18X13>M18X12>M14X11>M14X24>M13X19>M15X14>M17X20>M20X11>M20X13>M21X14>M15X24>M14X12>M13X22>M14X23>M13X23>M14X19>M17X15>M16X25>M17X11>M18X14>M19X19>M21X25>M13X12>M13X11>M14X18>M13X13>M12X11>M15X16>M14X14>M27X12>M17X21>M20X23>M22X13>M21X22>M24X16>M24X15>M26X25>M23X25>M26X14>M23X12>M22X18>M24X11>M16X23>M19X14>M19X13>M21X23>M22X17>M23X23>M23X21>M25X22>M18X16>M19X15>M20X18>M20X19>M22X11>M24X23>C156>C118>C143>C137>C147>C106>C168>C113>C163>C155>C105>C146>C187>A150>C139>C180>C164>C193>C157>A191>C158>B188>A159>C184>C121>C154>B171>A105>C131>C104>B104>C161>C111>B145>C160>B155>A163>C112>C142>B148>C133>B198>A198>A115>C114>B157>A156>C175>B144>A120>C173>B184>A174>C126>B107>A139>C194>B194>A194>C116>B116>C166>B160>B110>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B162>A154>C186>B187>A179>C124>B181>A101>C153>B158>A136>C135>C176>A192>B133>A133>C177>B177>A177>C185>C103>B141>A141>C183>A162>C192>C129>B179>C144>B124>B183>C127>B127>A127>B108>A112>B153>A153>C167>B167>A186>A122>C162>A144>B149>C174>B131>A185>C141>B106>A126>A167>C140>B122>A170>C198>B143>C117>C123>B123>A147>A106>C200>B169>C191>B175>A123>B118>A182>C132>B151>A145>A104>A109>C159>C150>B119>A119>A178>B164>B114>A164>C181>A102>C122>B134>A157>A116>C195>B191>B111>C172>B172>A118>B129>A129>C149>A107>C170>B197>A197>A173>B168>A132>C107>B165>A160>A131>C188>A168>B109>C178>A189>A148>C119>C190>C120>B166>B176>C108>B135>B139>A103>B178>A169>B132>C125>C138>B163>A111>B170>C110>A165>C151>C169>C199>A138>C182>A135>B101>B142>C101>C148>B193>B152>A158>A199>C136>B137>A161>B120>A108>A149>A125>B113>A184>C171>A134>A175>A124>B150>B161>B102>A146>A187>C130>B192>B200>A200>A142>A183>C102>B105>B156>A176>C165>B147>A137>A196>B190>A190>B125>C134>C189>B126>B186>A166>B136>B195>A195>B154>B138>B112>B173>A117>B159>B182>A181>A140>C145>B117>A152>A193>C197>B130>A172>A113>A151>B115>A143>B140>B185>B103>A121>A180>A130>A171>B199>C196>B146>B180>C115>B174>B121>A188>B196>B189>C152>C109>A155>A114>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>.>{}<.<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<A114<A155<C109<C152<B189<B196<A188<B121<B174<C115<B180<B146<C196<B199<A171<A130<A180<A121<B103<B185<B140<A143<B115<A151<A113<A172<B130<C197<A193<A152<B117<C145<A140<A181<B182<B159<A117<B173<B112<B138<B154<A195<B195<B136<A166<B186<B126<C189<C134<B125<A190<B190<A196<A137<B147<C165<A176<B156<B105<C102<A183<A142<A200<B200<B192<C130<A187<A146<B102<B161<B150<A124<A175<A134<C171<A184<B113<A125<A149<A108<B120<A161<B137<C136<A199<A158<B152<B193<C148<C101<B142<B101<A135<C182<A138<C199<C169<C151<A165<C110<B170<A111<B163<C138<C125<B132<A169<B178<A103<B139<B135<C108<B176<B166<C120<C190<C119<A148<A189<C178<B109<A168<C188<A131<A160<B165<C107<A132<B168<A173<A197<B197<C170<A107<C149<A129<B129<A118<B172<C172<B111<B191<C195<A116<A157<B134<C122<A102<C181<A164<B114<B164<A178<A119<B119<C150<C159<A109<A104<A145<B151<C132<A182<B118<A123<B175<C191<B169<C200<A106<A147<B123<C123<C117<B143<C198<A170<B122<C140<A167<A126<B106<C141<A185<B131<C174<B149<A144<C162<A122<A186<B167<C167<A153<B153<A112<B108<A127<B127<C127<B183<B124<C144<B179<C129<C192<A162<C183<A141<B141<C103<C185<A177<B177<C177<A133<B133<A192<C176<C135<A136<B158<C153<A101<B181<C124<A179<B187<C186<A154<B162<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B110<B160<C166<B116<C116<A194<B194<C194<A139<B107<C126<A174<B184<C173<A120<B144<C175<A156<B157<C114<A115<A198<B198<C133<B148<C142<C112<A163<B155<C160<B145<C111<C161<B104<C104<C131<A105<B171<C154<C121<C184<A159<B188<C158<A191<C157<C193<C164<C180<C139<A150<C187<C146<C105<C155<C163<C113<C168<C106<C147<C137<C143<C118<C156<M24X23<M22X11<M20X19<M20X18<M19X15<M18X16<M25X22<M23X21<M23X23<M22X17<M21X23<M19X13<M19X14<M16X23<M24X11<M22X18<M23X12<M26X14<M23X25<M26X25<M24X15<M24X16<M21X22<M22X13<M20X23<M17X21<M27X12<M14X14<M15X16<M12X11<M13X13<M14X18<M13X11<M13X12<M21X25<M19X19<M18X14<M17X11<M16X25<M17X15<M14X19<M13X23<M14X23<M13X22<M14X12<M15X24<M21X14<M20X13<M20X11<M17X20<M15X14<M13X19<M14X24<M14X11<M18X12<M18X13<M16X11<M17X12<M15X13<M13X18<M14X13<M15X19<M19X23<M20X25<M17X13<M16X12<M17X24<M18X19<M15X18<M15X17<M21X13<M18X23<M19X25<M18X17<M20X20<M20X21<M21X16<M21X15<M22X23<M11X11<M12X13<M13X20<M14X22<M13X14<M14X15<M15X12<M15X11<M15X25<M16X15<M14X16<M15X23<M16X24<M12X12<M13X24<M14X21<M16X19<M17X25<M14X20<M15X22<M16X13<M16X14<M15X21<M16X17<M17X19<M18X11<M18X20<M19X22<M15X20<M16X21<M17X18<M17X16<M18X21<M19X18<M19X24<M18X22<M20X15<M21X11<M22X12<M17X17<M16X20<M16X22<M14X25<M16X18<M17X14<M18X15<M19X12<M20X24<M23X24<M23X19<M25X14<M21X21<M22X16<M22X24<M23X20<M19X11<M20X12<M18X24<M19X20<M19X21<M18X25<M19X16<M20X22<M21X12<M21X24<M19X17<M20X17<M21X17<M22X19<M21X18<M22X15<M23X11<M22X14<M21X19<M22X25<M23X16<M24X25<M21X20<M22X22<M23X14<M24X18<M23X13<M24X22<M25X16<M23X15<M25X15<M24X12<M25X11<M24X13<M22X20<M24X24<M23X22<M24X14<M22X21<M23X17<M24X21<M25X19<M24X20<M25X25<M25X24<M25X23<M24X19<M26X15<M25X12<M26X12<M16X16<M17X23<M26X13<M25X13<M23X18<M24X17<M25X20<M26X24<M25X18<M26X19<M27X16<M26X17<M26X18<M27X20<M25X17<M27X24<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M20X14<M15X15<M17X22<M25X21<M26X16<M26X20<M26X22<M26X21<M26X23<M26X11<M27X17<M27X19<M27X13<M27X21<M28X24<M27X22<M27X23<M28X25<M28X14<M27X25<M28X23<M27X11<M28X13<M27X15<M28X18<M27X14<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
+output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=2): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M28X24>M28X23>M27X21>M28X13>M27X20>M27X19>M26X14>M27X25>M28X18>M27X11>M28X25>M27X24>M26X24>M27X15>M27X14>M27X13>M26X23>M27X17>M26X22>M25X13>M28X14>M27X16>M26X19>M26X18>M27X23>M27X22>M26X17>M25X18>M26X21>M25X17>M26X20>M26X15>M26X13>M25X19>M24X14>M25X23>M26X11>M26X25>M25X16>M25X15>M24X22>M25X21>M25X20>M24X21>M25X25>M25X24>M24X20>M23X13>M22X15>M25X14>M24X19>M23X17>M24X25>M23X24>M24X13>M23X15>M24X18>M23X14>M22X11>M24X15>M23X22>M24X11>M23X19>M22X21>M24X24>M23X21>M22X20>M23X25>M22X19>M21X24>M20X23>M22X22>M25X11>M23X16>M22X18>M23X20>M22X17>M21X21>M21X20>M20X24>M22X14>M22X13>M21X11>M21X17>M22X23>M21X16>M20X25>M19X23>M18X16>M21X22>M20X20>M20X19>M21X13>M20X18>M19X13>M21X18>M20X21>M19X24>M18X12>M20X14>M20X13>M22X25>M20X12>M20X15>M19X14>M18X22>M19X18>M20X17>M19X17>M19X16>M18X21>M17X20>M19X19>M18X13>M17X11>M18X17>M19X25>M18X15>M17X25>M18X19>M17X24>M16X19>M15X17>M17X21>M16X24>M18X23>M17X16>M16X25>M19X15>M18X25>M17X23>M16X23>M15X23>M18X14>M17X14>M16X14>M17X18>M16X13>M17X22>M16X12>M15X22>M14X16>M17X12>M16X22>M15X12>M16X11>M15X11>M16X15>M15X25>M14X15>M13X14>M15X18>M16X21>M15X16>M14X21>M15X14>M16X20>M15X13>M14X22>M15X20>M14X20>M13X20>M14X11>M15X19>M14X24>M13X19>M14X13>M13X18>M12X13>M15X24>M14X23>M13X12>M14X12>M13X11>M12X11>M11X11>M21X12>M20X11>M19X11>M18X11>M17X15>M16X18>M14X25>M14X19>M13X24>M13X23>M13X22>M12X12>M22X12>M21X15>M19X22>M18X20>M16X17>M14X14>M24X12>M23X23>M22X16>M21X14>M20X22>M18X24>M16X16>M26X12>M24X16>M23X11>M21X23>M19X20>M17X17>M27X12>M26X16>M25X22>M24X17>M23X18>M21X25>M19X12>M17X19>M15X21>M14X18>M13X13>M23X12>M21X19>M19X21>M17X13>M15X15>M25X12>M24X23>M22X24>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>A150>C158>B112>A112>C167>B146>A146>C180>B180>A180>C143>B143>A115>C126>B126>A126>C190>B190>A190>C138>B138>A138>C174>B174>A102>C122>B122>A122>C162>B162>A162>C142>B142>A142>C102>B102>A174>C176>B176>A176>C115>B115>A143>C172>B172>A172>C187>B187>A187>C130>B130>A130>C118>B118>A118>C184>B184>A184>C171>B171>A171>C168>B182>A182>C182>B168>A168>C109>B109>A109>C159>B159>A159>C134>B134>A134>C146>B167>A167>C140>B140>A140>C163>B163>A163>C112>B158>A158>C164>B164>A164>C131>B131>A131>C188>B188>A188>C199>B199>A199>C114>B114>A114>C106>B106>A106>C200>B200>A200>C183>B183>A183>C152>B152>A152>C147>B147>A147>C150>B150>A198>C144>B144>A144>C191>B191>A191>C108>B108>A108>C139>B139>A139>C194>B194>A194>C166>B166>A166>C120>B120>A120>C123>B123>A123>C132>B132>A132>C107>B107>A107>C170>B170>A170>C198>B198>A156>C125>B125>A125>C121>B121>A121>C193>B193>A193>C197>B197>A197>C175>B175>A175>C196>B196>A196>C105>B105>A105>C181>B181>A181>C113>B113>A113>C137>B137>A137>C155>B155>A155>C156>B156>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B179>A179>C124>B124>A124>C151>B151>A151>C178>B178>A178>C104>B104>A104>C111>B111>A111>C148>B148>A148>C169>B169>A169>C129>B129>A129>C149>B149>A149>C189>B189>A189>C119>B119>A119>C154>B154>A154>C136>B136>A136>C135>B135>A135>C116>B116>A116>C145>B145>A145>C161>B161>A161>C173>B173>A173>C157>B157>A157>C195>B195>A195>C186>B186>A186>C160>B160>A160>C153>B153>A153>C117>B117>A117>C165>B165>A165>C101>B101>A101>C103>B103>A103>C192>B192>A192>C177>B177>A177>C185>B185>A185>C141>B141>A141>C133>B133>A133>C127>B127>A127>C110>B110>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>.>{}<.<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<B110<C110<A127<B127<C127<A133<B133<C133<A141<B141<C141<A185<B185<C185<A177<B177<C177<A192<B192<C192<A103<B103<C103<A101<B101<C101<A165<B165<C165<A117<B117<C117<A153<B153<C153<A160<B160<C160<A186<B186<C186<A195<B195<C195<A157<B157<C157<A173<B173<C173<A161<B161<C161<A145<B145<C145<A116<B116<C116<A135<B135<C135<A136<B136<C136<A154<B154<C154<A119<B119<C119<A189<B189<C189<A149<B149<C149<A129<B129<C129<A169<B169<C169<A148<B148<C148<A111<B111<C111<A104<B104<C104<A178<B178<C178<A151<B151<C151<A124<B124<C124<A179<B179<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B156<C156<A155<B155<C155<A137<B137<C137<A113<B113<C113<A181<B181<C181<A105<B105<C105<A196<B196<C196<A175<B175<C175<A197<B197<C197<A193<B193<C193<A121<B121<C121<A125<B125<C125<A156<B198<C198<A170<B170<C170<A107<B107<C107<A132<B132<C132<A123<B123<C123<A120<B120<C120<A166<B166<C166<A194<B194<C194<A139<B139<C139<A108<B108<C108<A191<B191<C191<A144<B144<C144<A198<B150<C150<A147<B147<C147<A152<B152<C152<A183<B183<C183<A200<B200<C200<A106<B106<C106<A114<B114<C114<A199<B199<C199<A188<B188<C188<A131<B131<C131<A164<B164<C164<A158<B158<C112<A163<B163<C163<A140<B140<C140<A167<B167<C146<A134<B134<C134<A159<B159<C159<A109<B109<C109<A168<B168<C182<A182<B182<C168<A171<B171<C171<A184<B184<C184<A118<B118<C118<A130<B130<C130<A187<B187<C187<A172<B172<C172<A143<B115<C115<A176<B176<C176<A174<B102<C102<A142<B142<C142<A162<B162<C162<A122<B122<C122<A102<B174<C174<A138<B138<C138<A190<B190<C190<A126<B126<C126<A115<B143<C143<A180<B180<C180<A146<B146<C167<A112<B112<C158<A150<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M22X24<M24X23<M25X12<M15X15<M17X13<M19X21<M21X19<M23X12<M13X13<M14X18<M15X21<M17X19<M19X12<M21X25<M23X18<M24X17<M25X22<M26X16<M27X12<M17X17<M19X20<M21X23<M23X11<M24X16<M26X12<M16X16<M18X24<M20X22<M21X14<M22X16<M23X23<M24X12<M14X14<M16X17<M18X20<M19X22<M21X15<M22X12<M12X12<M13X22<M13X23<M13X24<M14X19<M14X25<M16X18<M17X15<M18X11<M19X11<M20X11<M21X12<M11X11<M12X11<M13X11<M14X12<M13X12<M14X23<M15X24<M12X13<M13X18<M14X13<M13X19<M14X24<M15X19<M14X11<M13X20<M14X20<M15X20<M14X22<M15X13<M16X20<M15X14<M14X21<M15X16<M16X21<M15X18<M13X14<M14X15<M15X25<M16X15<M15X11<M16X11<M15X12<M16X22<M17X12<M14X16<M15X22<M16X12<M17X22<M16X13<M17X18<M16X14<M17X14<M18X14<M15X23<M16X23<M17X23<M18X25<M19X15<M16X25<M17X16<M18X23<M16X24<M17X21<M15X17<M16X19<M17X24<M18X19<M17X25<M18X15<M19X25<M18X17<M17X11<M18X13<M19X19<M17X20<M18X21<M19X16<M19X17<M20X17<M19X18<M18X22<M19X14<M20X15<M20X12<M22X25<M20X13<M20X14<M18X12<M19X24<M20X21<M21X18<M19X13<M20X18<M21X13<M20X19<M20X20<M21X22<M18X16<M19X23<M20X25<M21X16<M22X23<M21X17<M21X11<M22X13<M22X14<M20X24<M21X20<M21X21<M22X17<M23X20<M22X18<M23X16<M25X11<M22X22<M20X23<M21X24<M22X19<M23X25<M22X20<M23X21<M24X24<M22X21<M23X19<M24X11<M23X22<M24X15<M22X11<M23X14<M24X18<M23X15<M24X13<M23X24<M24X25<M23X17<M24X19<M25X14<M22X15<M23X13<M24X20<M25X24<M25X25<M24X21<M25X20<M25X21<M24X22<M25X15<M25X16<M26X25<M26X11<M25X23<M24X14<M25X19<M26X13<M26X15<M26X20<M25X17<M26X21<M25X18<M26X17<M27X22<M27X23<M26X18<M26X19<M27X16<M28X14<M25X13<M26X22<M27X17<M26X23<M27X13<M27X14<M27X15<M26X24<M27X24<M28X25<M27X11<M28X18<M27X25<M26X14<M27X19<M27X20<M28X13<M27X21<M28X23<M28X24<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
diff --git a/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py b/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py
index e4da3d64fd..f11ef68f21 100644
--- a/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py
+++ b/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py
@@ -181,7 +181,7 @@ parts:
3. Destructors' output
To see by example, a simple test description "a->b->c" generates a testcase
-that when run, outputs: "c>b>a>{}<a<b<c"
+that when run, outputs: "c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c"
Each generated DSO constructor prints its name followed by a '>' character,
and the "c>b>a" part above is the full constructor output by all DSOs, the
@@ -192,6 +192,9 @@ Destructor output for each DSO is a '<' character followed by its name,
reflecting its reverse nature of constructors. In the above example, the
destructor output part is "<a<b<c".
+The main program prints '.>' and '<.' when its constructors and
+destructors are invoked.
+
The middle "{}" part is the main program. In this simple example, nothing
was specified for the main program, so by default it is implicitly linked
to the DSO 'a' (with no other DSOs depending on it) and only prints the
@@ -201,7 +204,7 @@ To see an example with actions inside the main program, lets see an example
description: c->g=>h;{+c;%c;-c}->a->h
This produces a testcase, that when executed outputs:
- h>a>{+c[g>c>];%c();-c[<c<g];}<a<h
+ h>a>.>{+c[g>c>];%c();-c[<c<g];}<.<a<h
The constructor and destructor parts display the a->h dependency as expected.
Inside the main program, the "+c" action triggers a dlopen() of DSO 'c',
@@ -218,6 +221,7 @@ by the main test program constructs documented earlier.
The output strings described here is the exact same form placed in
test description files' "output: <expected output>" line.
+
"""
import sys
@@ -774,15 +778,9 @@ def process_testcase(t):
test_srcdir, base_test_name, exp_tunable_sfx,
("X" if xfail else ""), test_name, tunable_descr))
- # Generate C files according to dependency and calling relations from
- # description string.
- for obj in test_descr.objs:
- src_name = test_name + "-" + obj + ".c"
- f = open(testpfx_src + src_name, "w")
- if obj in test_descr.callrefs:
- called_objs = test_descr.callrefs[obj]
- for callee in called_objs:
- f.write("extern void fn_%s (void);\n" % (callee))
+ def write_initfini(f, obj):
+ """Write init/fini ELF constructor/destructor functions to F."""
+
if len(obj) == 1:
f.write("extern int putchar(int);\n")
f.write("static void __attribute__((constructor)) " +
@@ -795,6 +793,17 @@ def process_testcase(t):
'init(void){printf("%s>");}\n' % (obj))
f.write('static void __attribute__((destructor)) ' +
'fini(void){printf("<%s");}\n' % (obj))
+
+ # Generate C files according to dependency and calling relations from
+ # description string.
+ for obj in test_descr.objs:
+ src_name = test_name + "-" + obj + ".c"
+ f = open(testpfx_src + src_name, "w")
+ if obj in test_descr.callrefs:
+ called_objs = test_descr.callrefs[obj]
+ for callee in called_objs:
+ f.write("extern void fn_%s (void);\n" % (callee))
+ write_initfini(f, obj)
if obj in test_descr.callrefs:
called_objs = test_descr.callrefs[obj]
if len(obj) != 1:
@@ -828,6 +837,7 @@ def process_testcase(t):
f.write("#include <stdio.h>\n")
f.write("#include <stdlib.h>\n")
f.write("#include <dlfcn.h>\n")
+ write_initfini(f, '.')
for s in test_descr.main_program:
if s[0] == '@':
f.write("extern void fn_%s (void);\n" % (s[1:]));
--
2.41.0
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* [PATCH 2/3] elf: Add dummy declaration of _dl_audit_objclose for !SHARED
2023-09-19 8:48 [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests Florian Weimer
@ 2023-09-19 8:48 ` Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 12:43 ` Carlos O'Donell
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 3/3] elf: Process initially loaded objects first in _dl_fini (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
2023-10-06 12:35 ` [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering " Florian Weimer
3 siblings, 1 reply; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-09-19 8:48 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: libc-alpha
This allows us to avoid some #ifdef SHARED conditionals.
---
sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h | 9 ++++++++-
1 file changed, 8 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-)
diff --git a/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h b/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
index edebca9a23..82c5383c7e 100644
--- a/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
+++ b/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
@@ -1383,7 +1383,14 @@ void DL_ARCH_FIXUP_ATTRIBUTE _dl_audit_pltexit (struct link_map *l,
const void *inregs,
void *outregs)
attribute_hidden;
-#endif /* SHARED */
+
+#else /* !SHARED */
+static inline void
+_dl_audit_objclose (struct link_map *l)
+{
+ /* No audit implementation for !SHARED. */
+}
+#endif /* !SHARED */
#if PTHREAD_IN_LIBC && defined SHARED
/* Recursive locking implementation for use within the dynamic loader.
--
2.41.0
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* [PATCH 3/3] elf: Process initially loaded objects first in _dl_fini (bug 30869)
2023-09-19 8:48 [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 2/3] elf: Add dummy declaration of _dl_audit_objclose for !SHARED Florian Weimer
@ 2023-09-19 8:48 ` Florian Weimer
2023-10-06 12:35 ` [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering " Florian Weimer
3 siblings, 0 replies; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-09-19 8:48 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: libc-alpha
This matches historical practice when _dl_fini was using
_dl_sort_maps for ordering destructors.
The old approach gave more control to applications: The initially
loaded objects cannot themselves be unloaded with dlclose, but they
can dlclose other objects. At that point, their destructors run,
in a more predictable ordering. Only after all the initially loaded
objects have been destructed, destruct the dlopen'ed objects that
are still around (because they have not been subject to explicit
dlclose calls).
As an additional fix, change the order in which the ELF destructors
are scheduled. Registration in elf/dl-init.c now happens after
completion of the ELF constructor, so that the match destructor
runs first if the object is executed from _dl_fini. This helps
with destructor ordering when the destructor for an object is called
from _dl_fini, and that destructor in turn calls dlclose to unload
objects that have been opened.
The ordering tests are written manually because at this time,
scripts/dso-ordering-test.py does not support customizing ELF
constructors.
Fixes commit 6985865bc3ad5b23147ee73466583dd7fdf65892 ("elf: Always
call destructors in reverse constructor order (bug 30785)").
---
elf/Makefile | 21 +++++++++++++
elf/dl-fini.c | 49 ++++++++++++++++++++----------
elf/dl-init.c | 38 +++++++++++++++++-------
elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def | 2 +-
elf/tst-finiorder1.c | 52 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder1mod1.c | 43 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder1mod2.c | 36 ++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2.c | 61 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2mod1.c | 49 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2mod2.c | 35 ++++++++++++++++++++++
elf/tst-finiorder2mod3.c | 36 ++++++++++++++++++++++
sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h | 3 ++
12 files changed, 399 insertions(+), 26 deletions(-)
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder1.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder1mod1.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder1mod2.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2mod1.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2mod2.c
create mode 100644 elf/tst-finiorder2mod3.c
diff --git a/elf/Makefile b/elf/Makefile
index 9176cbf1e3..9c4cfddbb3 100644
--- a/elf/Makefile
+++ b/elf/Makefile
@@ -412,6 +412,8 @@ tests += \
tst-dlsym-error \
tst-filterobj \
tst-filterobj-dlopen \
+ tst-finiorder1 \
+ tst-finiorder2 \
tst-glibc-hwcaps \
tst-glibc-hwcaps-mask \
tst-glibc-hwcaps-prepend \
@@ -834,6 +836,11 @@ modules-names += \
tst-filterobj-filtee \
tst-filterobj-flt \
tst-finilazyfailmod \
+ tst-finiorder1mod1 \
+ tst-finiorder1mod2 \
+ tst-finiorder2mod1 \
+ tst-finiorder2mod2 \
+ tst-finiorder2mod3 \
tst-globalmod2 \
tst-initlazyfailmod \
tst-initorder2a \
@@ -3018,3 +3025,17 @@ LDFLAGS-tst-dlclose-lazy-mod1.so = -Wl,-z,lazy,--no-as-needed
$(objpfx)tst-dlclose-lazy-mod1.so: $(objpfx)tst-dlclose-lazy-mod2.so
$(objpfx)tst-dlclose-lazy.out: \
$(objpfx)tst-dlclose-lazy-mod1.so $(objpfx)tst-dlclose-lazy-mod2.so
+
+LDFLAGS-tst-finiorder1 = -Wl,-export-dynamic
+tst-finiorder1mod1.so-no-z-defs = yes
+tst-finiorder1mod2.so-no-z-defs = yes
+$(objpfx)tst-finiorder1.out: \
+ $(objpfx)tst-finiorder1mod1.so $(objpfx)tst-finiorder1mod2.so
+
+LDFLAGS-tst-finiorder2 = -Wl,-export-dynamic
+tst-finiorder2mod1.so-no-z-defs = yes
+tst-finiorder2mod2.so-no-z-defs = yes
+tst-finiorder2mod3.so-no-z-defs = yes
+$(objpfx)tst-finiorder2: $(objpfx)tst-finiorder2mod1.so
+$(objpfx)tst-finiorder2.out: \
+ $(objpfx)tst-finiorder2mod2.so $(objpfx)tst-finiorder2mod3.so
diff --git a/elf/dl-fini.c b/elf/dl-fini.c
index e201d36651..97cd5cea5c 100644
--- a/elf/dl-fini.c
+++ b/elf/dl-fini.c
@@ -24,15 +24,42 @@
void
_dl_fini (void)
{
- /* Call destructors strictly in the reverse order of constructors.
- This causes fewer surprises than some arbitrary reordering based
- on new (relocation) dependencies. None of the objects are
- unmapped, so applications can deal with this if their DSOs remain
- in a consistent state after destructors have run. */
-
/* Protect against concurrent loads and unloads. */
__rtld_lock_lock_recursive (GL(dl_load_lock));
+ /* Always call the destructor of the main program first. This may
+ trigger dlclose calls, which runs other destructors early. (The
+ main program is never added to _dl_init_called_list.) Together
+ with the first loop below, the effect is similar to calling
+ dlclose on the main program (except that nothing is unloaded). */
+#ifdef SHARED
+ Lmid_t last_ns = LM_ID_BASE;
+ _dl_audit_activity_nsid (LM_ID_BASE, LA_ACT_DELETE);
+#endif
+ /* There is no need to re-enable exceptions because _dl_fini
+ is not called from a context where exceptions are caught. */
+ _dl_call_fini (GL(dl_ns)[LM_ID_BASE]._ns_loaded);
+ /* Auditing checkpoint: another object closed. */
+ _dl_audit_objclose (GL(dl_ns)[LM_ID_BASE]._ns_loaded);
+
+ /* Give the initially loaded objects a chance to unload dlopen'ed
+ objects using dlclose. */
+ for (struct link_map *l = _dl_init_called_library_list; l != NULL;
+ l = l->l_init_called_next)
+ {
+ _dl_call_fini (l);
+ _dl_audit_objclose (l);
+ }
+
+ /* At this point _dl_init_called_list contains objects that have
+ been dlopen'ed but not dlclose'd, and destructors for other
+ objects have been invoked. Call destructors in the reverse order
+ of constructors (with an exception for audit modules). This
+ causes fewer surprises than some arbitrary reordering based on
+ new (relocation) dependencies. None of the objects are unmapped,
+ so applications can rely on DSOs remaining in a consistent state
+ after destructors have run. */
+
/* Ignore objects which are opened during shutdown. */
struct link_map *local_init_called_list = _dl_init_called_list;
@@ -52,7 +79,6 @@ _dl_fini (void)
still run. */
#ifdef SHARED
int last_pass = GLRO(dl_naudit) > 0;
- Lmid_t last_ns = -1;
for (int do_audit = 0; do_audit <= last_pass; ++do_audit)
#endif
for (struct link_map *l = local_init_called_list; l != NULL;
@@ -73,19 +99,12 @@ _dl_fini (void)
}
#endif
- /* There is no need to re-enable exceptions because _dl_fini
- is not called from a context where exceptions are caught. */
_dl_call_fini (l);
-
-#ifdef SHARED
- /* Auditing checkpoint: another object closed. */
_dl_audit_objclose (l);
-#endif
}
#ifdef SHARED
- if (last_ns >= 0)
- _dl_audit_activity_nsid (last_ns, LA_ACT_CONSISTENT);
+ _dl_audit_activity_nsid (last_ns, LA_ACT_CONSISTENT);
if (__glibc_unlikely (GLRO(dl_debug_mask) & DL_DEBUG_STATISTICS))
_dl_debug_printf ("\nruntime linker statistics:\n"
diff --git a/elf/dl-init.c b/elf/dl-init.c
index ffd05b7806..700c49fbc3 100644
--- a/elf/dl-init.c
+++ b/elf/dl-init.c
@@ -22,6 +22,7 @@
#include <elf-initfini.h>
struct link_map *_dl_init_called_list;
+struct link_map *_dl_init_called_library_list;
static void
call_init (struct link_map *l, int argc, char **argv, char **env)
@@ -48,16 +49,6 @@ call_init (struct link_map *l, int argc, char **argv, char **env)
progress.) */
l->l_map_used = 1;
- /* Record execution before starting any initializers. This way, if
- the initializers themselves call dlopen, their ELF destructors
- will eventually be run before this object is destructed, matching
- that their ELF constructors have run before this object was
- constructed. _dl_fini uses this list for audit callbacks, so
- register objects on the list even if they do not have a
- constructor. */
- l->l_init_called_next = _dl_init_called_list;
- _dl_init_called_list = l;
-
/* Check for object which constructors we do not run here. */
if (__builtin_expect (l->l_name[0], 'a') == '\0'
&& l->l_type == lt_executable)
@@ -89,6 +80,33 @@ call_init (struct link_map *l, int argc, char **argv, char **env)
for (j = 0; j < jm; ++j)
((dl_init_t) addrs[j]) (argc, argv, env);
}
+
+ /* Schedule invocation of the ELF destructors for this object. Use
+ separate lists for initially loaded objects (lt_library) and
+ dlopened objects (lt_loaded), so that _dl_fini can give a chance
+ to lt_library objects to unload objects using dlclose.
+
+ Do this after completion of the constructors, so that the
+ initializers themselves call dlopen, this object has a chance to
+ influence destructor order with explicit dlclose calls if this
+ object is destructed via _dl_fini. (If an object is destructed
+ earlier, using dlclose, objects it has dlopened are not eligible
+ for destruction, and the destructor of the explicitly dlclose'd
+ object runs first, but _dl_fini is different.)
+
+ Objects without constructors may still have destructors, and
+ _dl_fini uses this list for audit callbacks, so register objects
+ on the list even if they do not have a constructor. */
+ if (l->l_type == lt_loaded)
+ {
+ l->l_init_called_next = _dl_init_called_list;
+ _dl_init_called_list = l;
+ }
+ else
+ {
+ l->l_init_called_next = _dl_init_called_library_list;
+ _dl_init_called_library_list = l;
+ }
}
diff --git a/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def b/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
index cefc474e4f..9d8610051c 100644
--- a/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
+++ b/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
@@ -63,4 +63,4 @@ output: .>{+a[d>c>b>a>];+e[e>];+f[f>];+g[g>];+d[];%d(b(e(a()))a()g(c(a()f(b(e(a(
# object, that object is initialized last (and not unloaded prematurely).
# Final destructor order is the opposite of constructor order.
tst-bz28937: {+a;+b;-b;+c;%c};a->a1;a->a2;a2->a;b->b1;c->a1;c=>a1
-output: .>{+a[a2>a1>a>];+b[b1>b>];-b[<b<b1];+c[c>];%c(a1());}<c<a<a1<a2<.
+output: .>{+a[a2>a1>a>];+b[b1>b>];-b[<b<b1];+c[c>];%c(a1());}<.<c<a<a1<a2
diff --git a/elf/tst-finiorder1.c b/elf/tst-finiorder1.c
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..852f010fab
--- /dev/null
+++ b/elf/tst-finiorder1.c
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
+/* _dl_fini ordering test.
+ Copyright (C) 2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
+ This file is part of the GNU C Library.
+
+ The GNU C Library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
+ modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
+ version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
+
+ The GNU C Library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU
+ Lesser General Public License for more details.
+
+ You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License along with the GNU C Library; if not, see
+ <https://www.gnu.org/licenses/>. */
+
+/* This test opens mod2 from the ELF constructor of mod1, and expects
+ the main program to be destructed first, followed by mod1, followed
+ by mod2: .>{mod1>mod2>}<.<mod1<mod2 in scripts/dso-ordering-test.py
+ terms. */
+
+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <support/check.h>
+#include <support/xdlfcn.h>
+#include <unistd.h>
+
+/* Used to check destructor ordering. */
+int fini_counter;
+
+static void __attribute__ ((destructor))
+fini (void)
+{
+ printf ("info: main program destructor invoked (PID %d)\n", (int) getpid ());
+
+ /* Destructor for the main program runs first. */
+ TEST_COMPARE (fini_counter, 0);
+ fini_counter = 1;
+}
+
+static int
+do_test (void)
+{
+ /* Leak the handle, so that the destructor is invoked by _dl_fini. */
+ (void) xdlopen ("tst-finiorder1mod1.so", RTLD_NOW);
+ return 0;
+}
+
+/* Marker value from the tst-finiorder1mod2.so destructor. */
+#define EXPECTED_STATUS 17
+#include <support/test-driver.c>
diff --git a/elf/tst-finiorder1mod1.c b/elf/tst-finiorder1mod1.c
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..5735196271
--- /dev/null
+++ b/elf/tst-finiorder1mod1.c
@@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
+/* _dl_fini ordering test. Helper module.
+ Copyright (C) 2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
+ This file is part of the GNU C Library.
+
+ The GNU C Library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
+ modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
+ version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
+
+ The GNU C Library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU
+ Lesser General Public License for more details.
+
+ You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License along with the GNU C Library; if not, see
+ <https://www.gnu.org/licenses/>. */
+
+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <support/xdlfcn.h>
+#include <unistd.h>
+
+extern int fini_counter;
+
+static void __attribute__ ((constructor))
+init (void)
+{
+ /* Leak the handle, rely on _dl_fini constructor invocation. */
+ (void) xdlopen ("tst-finiorder1mod2.so", RTLD_NOW);
+}
+
+static void __attribute__ ((destructor))
+fini (void)
+{
+ printf ("info: tst-finiorder1mod1.so destructor invoked (%d)\n",
+ fini_counter);
+ if (fini_counter != 1)
+ {
+ puts ("error: unexpected fini_counter");
+ _exit (1);
+ }
+ fini_counter = 2;
+}
diff --git a/elf/tst-finiorder1mod2.c b/elf/tst-finiorder1mod2.c
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..121faf559a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/elf/tst-finiorder1mod2.c
@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
+/* _dl_fini ordering test. Helper module producing exit status 17.
+ Copyright (C) 2021-2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
+ This file is part of the GNU C Library.
+
+ The GNU C Library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
+ modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
+ version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
+
+ The GNU C Library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU
+ Lesser General Public License for more details.
+
+ You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License along with the GNU C Library; if not, see
+ <https://www.gnu.org/licenses/>. */
+
+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <unistd.h>
+
+extern int fini_counter;
+
+static void __attribute__ ((destructor))
+fini (void)
+{
+ printf ("info: tst-finiorder1mod2.so destructor invoked (%d)\n",
+ fini_counter);
+ if (fini_counter != 2)
+ {
+ puts ("error: unexpected fini_counter");
+ _exit (1);
+ }
+ /* Marker value expected by the test driver. */
+ _exit (17);
+}
diff --git a/elf/tst-finiorder2.c b/elf/tst-finiorder2.c
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..3a5cfba9b1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/elf/tst-finiorder2.c
@@ -0,0 +1,61 @@
+/* _dl_fini ordering test.
+ Copyright (C) 2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
+ This file is part of the GNU C Library.
+
+ The GNU C Library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
+ modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
+ version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
+
+ The GNU C Library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU
+ Lesser General Public License for more details.
+
+ You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License along with the GNU C Library; if not, see
+ <https://www.gnu.org/licenses/>. */
+
+/* This test dlopens mod3, followed by mod2 (indirectly via the
+ directly linked mod1). The main program to be destructed first,
+ followed by mod1, mod2, mod3: mod1>.>{mod2>mod3>}<.<mod1<mod2<mod3
+ in scripts/dso-ordering-test.py terms. */
+
+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <support/check.h>
+#include <support/xdlfcn.h>
+#include <unistd.h>
+
+/* Used to check destructor ordering. */
+int fini_counter;
+
+extern void init_mod1 (void);
+
+static void __attribute__ ((destructor))
+fini (void)
+{
+ printf ("info: main program destructor invoked (PID %d)\n", (int) getpid ());
+
+ /* Destructor for the main program runs first. */
+ TEST_COMPARE (fini_counter, 0);
+ fini_counter = 1;
+}
+
+static int
+do_test (void)
+{
+ /* Leak the handle, so that the destructor is invoked by _dl_fini.
+ The other dlopen'ed object (tst-finiorder1mod2.so) is dlclose'd
+ explicitly. */
+ (void) xdlopen ("tst-finiorder2mod3.so", RTLD_NOW);
+
+ /* Trigger a dlopen call from tst-finiorder2mod1.so, to load
+ tst-finiorder2mod2.so. */
+ init_mod1 ();
+
+ return 0;
+}
+
+/* Marker value from the tst-finiorder2mod3.so destructor. */
+#define EXPECTED_STATUS 17
+#include <support/test-driver.c>
diff --git a/elf/tst-finiorder2mod1.c b/elf/tst-finiorder2mod1.c
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..fc6609554f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/elf/tst-finiorder2mod1.c
@@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
+/* _dl_fini ordering test. Helper module.
+ Copyright (C) 2021-2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
+ This file is part of the GNU C Library.
+
+ The GNU C Library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
+ modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
+ version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
+
+ The GNU C Library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU
+ Lesser General Public License for more details.
+
+ You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License along with the GNU C Library; if not, see
+ <https://www.gnu.org/licenses/>. */
+
+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <support/xdlfcn.h>
+#include <unistd.h>
+
+extern int fini_counter;
+
+static void *mod2_handle;
+
+void
+init_mod1 (void)
+{
+ mod2_handle = xdlopen ("tst-finiorder2mod2.so", RTLD_NOW);
+}
+
+static void __attribute__ ((destructor))
+fini (void)
+{
+ if (mod2_handle == NULL)
+ /* Do nothing in the test wrapper. */
+ return;
+
+ printf ("info: tst-finiorder1mod1.so destructor invoked (%d)\n",
+ fini_counter);
+ if (fini_counter != 1)
+ {
+ puts ("error: unexpected fini_counter");
+ _exit (1);
+ }
+ fini_counter = 2;
+ xdlclose (mod2_handle);
+}
diff --git a/elf/tst-finiorder2mod2.c b/elf/tst-finiorder2mod2.c
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..58a1c2b1c6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/elf/tst-finiorder2mod2.c
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+/* _dl_fini ordering test. Helper module.
+ Copyright (C) 2021-2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
+ This file is part of the GNU C Library.
+
+ The GNU C Library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
+ modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
+ version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
+
+ The GNU C Library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU
+ Lesser General Public License for more details.
+
+ You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License along with the GNU C Library; if not, see
+ <https://www.gnu.org/licenses/>. */
+
+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <unistd.h>
+
+extern int fini_counter;
+
+static void __attribute__ ((destructor))
+fini (void)
+{
+ printf ("info: tst-finiorder2mod2.so destructor invoked (%d)\n",
+ fini_counter);
+ if (fini_counter != 2)
+ {
+ puts ("error: unexpected fini_counter");
+ _exit (1);
+ }
+ fini_counter = 3;
+}
diff --git a/elf/tst-finiorder2mod3.c b/elf/tst-finiorder2mod3.c
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..bcd7aadd1a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/elf/tst-finiorder2mod3.c
@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
+/* _dl_fini ordering test. Helper module producing exit status 17.
+ Copyright (C) 2021-2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
+ This file is part of the GNU C Library.
+
+ The GNU C Library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
+ modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
+ version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
+
+ The GNU C Library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU
+ Lesser General Public License for more details.
+
+ You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
+ License along with the GNU C Library; if not, see
+ <https://www.gnu.org/licenses/>. */
+
+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <unistd.h>
+
+extern int fini_counter;
+
+static void __attribute__ ((destructor))
+fini (void)
+{
+ printf ("info: tst-finiorder2mod3.so destructor invoked (%d)\n",
+ fini_counter);
+ if (fini_counter != 3)
+ {
+ puts ("error: unexpected fini_counter");
+ _exit (1);
+ }
+ /* Marker value expected by the test driver. */
+ _exit (17);
+}
diff --git a/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h b/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
index 82c5383c7e..050d9d8bc7 100644
--- a/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
+++ b/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
@@ -1041,6 +1041,9 @@ extern void _dl_init (struct link_map *main_map, int argc, char **argv,
invocation. */
extern struct link_map *_dl_init_called_list attribute_hidden;
+/* The same, but for initially loaded libraries. */
+extern struct link_map *_dl_init_called_library_list attribute_hidden;
+
/* Call the finalizer functions of all shared objects whose
initializer functions have completed. */
extern void _dl_fini (void) attribute_hidden;
--
2.41.0
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests Florian Weimer
@ 2023-09-19 8:56 ` Andreas Schwab
2023-09-19 9:30 ` Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 12:41 ` Carlos O'Donell
1 sibling, 1 reply; 12+ messages in thread
From: Andreas Schwab @ 2023-09-19 8:56 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Florian Weimer; +Cc: libc-alpha
On Sep 19 2023, Florian Weimer wrote:
> Previously, the ordering was not capture in the test output. Adjust
captured
--
Andreas Schwab, SUSE Labs, schwab@suse.de
GPG Key fingerprint = 0196 BAD8 1CE9 1970 F4BE 1748 E4D4 88E3 0EEA B9D7
"And now for something completely different."
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
2023-09-19 8:56 ` Andreas Schwab
@ 2023-09-19 9:30 ` Florian Weimer
0 siblings, 0 replies; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-09-19 9:30 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Andreas Schwab; +Cc: libc-alpha
* Andreas Schwab:
> On Sep 19 2023, Florian Weimer wrote:
>
>> Previously, the ordering was not capture in the test output. Adjust
> captured
Thanks, fixed locally.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:56 ` Andreas Schwab
@ 2023-09-19 12:41 ` Carlos O'Donell
2023-09-19 12:47 ` Florian Weimer
1 sibling, 1 reply; 12+ messages in thread
From: Carlos O'Donell @ 2023-09-19 12:41 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Florian Weimer, libc-alpha
On 9/19/23 04:48, Florian Weimer wrote:
> Previously, the ordering was not capture in the test output. Adjust
s/capture/captured/g (as noted by Andreas)
> expected test output accordingly. Note that after commit 6985865bc3a
> ("elf: Always call destructors in reverse constructor order
> (bug 30785)"), the main program destructors in tst-bz28937 run last
> (which is bug XXX).
Do we need to fill in bug XXX?
> ---
> elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def | 24 ++++++++++++------------
> elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def | 4 ++--
> scripts/dso-ordering-test.py | 32 +++++++++++++++++++++-----------
> 3 files changed, 35 insertions(+), 25 deletions(-)
>
> diff --git a/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def b/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
> index 61dc54f8ae..cefc474e4f 100644
> --- a/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
> +++ b/elf/dso-sort-tests-1.def
> @@ -8,59 +8,59 @@ tunable_option: glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=2
>
> # Sequence of single dependencies with no cycles.
> tst-dso-ordering1: a->b->c
> -output: c>b>a>{}<a<b<c
> +output: c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c
>
> # Sequence including 2 dependent DSOs not at the end of the graph.
> tst-dso-ordering2: a->b->[cd]->e
> -output: e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e
> +output: e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e
>
> # Complex order with 3 "layers" of full dependencies
> tst-dso-ordering3: a->[bc]->[def]->[gh]->i
> -output: i>h>g>f>e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e<f<g<h<i
> +output: i>h>g>f>e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e<f<g<h<i
>
> # Sequence including 2 dependent DSOs at the end of the graph.
> # Additionally the same dependencies appear in two paths.
> tst-dso-ordering4: a->b->[de];a->c->d->e
> -output: e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e
> +output: e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e
>
> # Test that b->c cross link is respected correctly
> tst-dso-ordering5: a!->[bc]->d;b->c
> -output: d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d
> +output: d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d
>
> # First DSO fully dependent on 4 DSOs, with another DSO at the end of chain.
> tst-dso-ordering6: a->[bcde]->f
> -output: f>e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e<f
> +output: f>e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e<f
>
> # Sequence including 2 dependent and 3 dependent DSOs, and one of the
> # dependent DSOs is dependent on an earlier DSO.
> tst-dso-ordering7: a->[bc];b->[cde];e->f
> -output: f>e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e<f
> +output: f>e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e<f
>
> # Sequence where the DSO c is unerlinked and calls a function in DSO a which
> # is technically a cycle. The main executable depends on the first two DSOs.
> # Note: This test has unspecified behavior.
> tst-dso-ordering8: a->b->c=>a;{}->[ba]
> -output: c>b>a>{}<a<b<c
> +output: c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c
>
> # Generate the permutation of DT_NEEDED order between the main binary and
> # all 5 DSOs; all link orders should produce exact same init/fini ordering
> tst-dso-ordering9: a->b->c->d->e;{}!->[abcde]
> -output: e>d>c>b>a>{}<a<b<c<d<e
> +output: e>d>c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c<d<e
>
> # Test if init/fini ordering behavior is proper, despite main program with
> # an soname that may cause confusion
> tst-dso-ordering10: {}->a->b->c;soname({})=c
> -output: b>a>{}<a<b
> +output: b>a>.>{}<.<a<b
>
> # Complex example from Bugzilla #15311, under-linked and with circular
> # relocation(dynamic) dependencies. For both sorting algorithms, the
> # destruction order is the reverse of the construction order, and
> # relocation dependencies are not taken into account.
> tst-bz15311: {+a;+e;+f;+g;+d;%d;-d;-g;-f;-e;-a};a->b->c->d;d=>[ba];c=>a;b=>e=>a;c=>f=>b;d=>g=>c
> -output: {+a[d>c>b>a>];+e[e>];+f[f>];+g[g>];+d[];%d(b(e(a()))a()g(c(a()f(b(e(a()))))));-d[];-g[];-f[];-e[];-a[<g<f<e<a<b<c<d];}
> +output: .>{+a[d>c>b>a>];+e[e>];+f[f>];+g[g>];+d[];%d(b(e(a()))a()g(c(a()f(b(e(a()))))));-d[];-g[];-f[];-e[];-a[<g<f<e<a<b<c<d];}<.
>
> # Test that even in the presence of dependency loops involving dlopen'ed
> # object, that object is initialized last (and not unloaded prematurely).
> # Final destructor order is the opposite of constructor order.
> tst-bz28937: {+a;+b;-b;+c;%c};a->a1;a->a2;a2->a;b->b1;c->a1;c=>a1
> -output: {+a[a2>a1>a>];+b[b1>b>];-b[<b<b1];+c[c>];%c(a1());}<c<a<a1<a2
> +output: .>{+a[a2>a1>a>];+b[b1>b>];-b[<b<b1];+c[c>];%c(a1());}<c<a<a1<a2<.
OK. Adjust testing with "." for main executable.
> diff --git a/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def b/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def
> index b79e79ecb7..73792de53b 100644
> --- a/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def
> +++ b/elf/dso-sort-tests-2.def
> @@ -610,5 +610,5 @@ M30X22
> M30X23
> M30X24
> M30X25
> -xfail_output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=1): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M27X14>M28X18>M27X15>M28X13>M27X11>M28X23>M27X25>M28X14>M28X25>M27X23>M27X22>M28X24>M27X21>M27X13>M27X19>M27X17>M26X11>M26X23>M26X21>M26X22>M26X20>M26X16>M25X21>M17X22>M15X15>M20X14>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>M27X24>M25X17>M27X20>M26X18>M26X17>M27X16>M26X19>M25X18>M26X24>M25X20>M24X17>M23X18>M25X13>M26X13>M17X23>M16X16>M26X12>M25X12>M26X15>M24X19>M25X23>M25X24>M25X25>M24X20>M25X19>M24X21>M23X17>M22X21>M24X14>M23X22>M24X24>M22X20>M24X13>M25X11>M24X12>M25X15>M23X15>M25X16>M24X22>M23X13>M24X18>M23X14>M22X22>M21X20>M24X25>M23X16>M22X25>M21X19>M22X14>M23X11>M22X15>M21X18>M22X19>M21X17>M20X17>M19X17>M21X24>M21X12>M20X22>M19X16>M18X25>M19X21>M19X20>M18X24>M20X12>M19X11>M23X20>M22X24>M22X16>M21X21>M25X14>M23X19>M23X24>M20X24>M19X12>M18X15>M17X14>M16X18>M14X25>M16X22>M16X20>M17X17>M22X12>M21X11>M20X15>M18X22>M19X24>M19X18>M18X21>M17X16>M17X18>M16X21>M15X20>M19X22>M18X20>M18X11>M17X19>M16X17>M15X21>M16X14>M16X13>M15X22>M14X20>M17X25>M16X19>M14X21>M13X24>M12X12>M16X24>M15X23>M14X16>M16X15>M15X25>M15X11>M15X12>M14X15>M13X14>M14X22>M13X20>M12X13>M11X11>M22X23>M21X15>M21X16>M20X21>M20X20>M18X17>M19X25>M18X23>M21X13>M15X17>M15X18>M18X19>M17X24>M16X12>M17X13>M20X25>M19X23>M15X19>M14X13>M13X18>M15X13>M17X12>M16X11>M18X13>M18X12>M14X11>M14X24>M13X19>M15X14>M17X20>M20X11>M20X13>M21X14>M15X24>M14X12>M13X22>M14X23>M13X23>M14X19>M17X15>M16X25>M17X11>M18X14>M19X19>M21X25>M13X12>M13X11>M14X18>M13X13>M12X11>M15X16>M14X14>M27X12>M17X21>M20X23>M22X13>M21X22>M24X16>M24X15>M26X25>M23X25>M26X14>M23X12>M22X18>M24X11>M16X23>M19X14>M19X13>M21X23>M22X17>M23X23>M23X21>M25X22>M18X16>M19X15>M20X18>M20X19>M22X11>M24X23>C156>C118>C143>C137>C147>C106>C168>C113>C163>C155>C105>C146>C187>A150>C139>C180>C164>C193>C157>A191>C158>B188>A159>C184>C121>C154>B171>A105>C131>C104>B104>C161>C111>B145>C160>B155>A163>C112>C142>B148>C133>B198>A198>A115>C114>B157>A156>C175>B144>A120>C173>B184>A174>C126>B107>A139>C194>B194>A194>C116>B116>C166>B160>B110>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B162>A154>C186>B187>A179>C124>B181>A101>C153>B158>A136>C135>C176>A192>B133>A133>C177>B177>A177>C185>C103>B141>A141>C183>A162>C192>C129>B179>C144>B124>B183>C127>B127>A127>B108>A112>B153>A153>C167>B167>A186>A122>C162>A144>B149>C174>B131>A185>C141>B106>A126>A167>C140>B122>A170>C198>B143>C117>C123>B123>A147>A106>C200>B169>C191>B175>A123>B118>A182>C132>B151>A145>A104>A109>C159>C150>B119>A119>A178>B164>B114>A164>C181>A102>C122>B134>A157>A116>C195>B191>B111>C172>B172>A118>B129>A129>C149>A107>C170>B197>A197>A173>B168>A132>C107>B165>A160>A131>C188>A168>B109>C178>A189>A148>C119>C190>C120>B166>B176>C108>B135>B139>A103>B178>A169>B132>C125>C138>B163>A111>B170>C110>A165>C151>C169>C199>A138>C182>A135>B101>B142>C101>C148>B193>B152>A158>A199>C136>B137>A161>B120>A108>A149>A125>B113>A184>C171>A134>A175>A124>B150>B161>B102>A146>A187>C130>B192>B200>A200>A142>A183>C102>B105>B156>A176>C165>B147>A137>A196>B190>A190>B125>C134>C189>B126>B186>A166>B136>B195>A195>B154>B138>B112>B173>A117>B159>B182>A181>A140>C145>B117>A152>A193>C197>B130>A172>A113>A151>B115>A143>B140>B185>B103>A121>A180>A130>A171>B199>C196>B146>B180>C115>B174>B121>A188>B196>B189>C152>C109>A155>A114>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>{}<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<A114<A155<C109<C152<B189<B196<A188<B121<B174<C115<B180<B146<C196<B199<A171<A130<A180<A121<B103<B185<B140<A143<B115<A151<A113<A172<B130<C197<A193<A152<B117<C145<A140<A181<B182<B159<A117<B173<B112<B138<B154<A195<B195<B136<A166<B186<B126<C189<C134<B125<A190<B190<A196<A137<B147<C165<A176<B156<B105<C102<A183<A142<A200<B200<B192<C130<A187<A146<B102<B161<B150<A124<A175<A134<C171<A184<B113<A125<A149<A108<B120<A161<B137<C136<A199<A158<B152<B193<C148<C101<B142<B101<A135<C182<A138<C199<C169<C151<A165<C110<B170<A111<B163<C138<C125<B132<A169<B178<A103<B139<B135<C108<B176<B166<C120<C190<C119<A148<A189<C178<B109<A168<C188<A131<A160<B165<C107<A132<B168<A173<A197<B197<C170<A107<C149<A129<B129<A118<B172<C172<B111<B191<C195<A116<A157<B134<C122<A102<C181<A164<B114<B164<A178<A119<B119<C150<C159<A109<A104<A145<B151<C132<A182<B118<A123<B175<C191<B169<C200<A106<A147<B123<C123<C117<B143<C198<A170<B122<C140<A167<A126<B106<C141<A185<B131<C174<B149<A144<C162<A122<A186<B167<C167<A153<B153<A112<B108<A127<B127<C127<B183<B124<C144<B179<C129<C192<A162<C183<A141<B141<C103<C185<A177<B177<C177<A133<B133<A192<C176<C135<A136<B158<C153<A101<B181<C124<A179<B187<C186<A154<B162<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B110<B160<C166<B116<C116<A194<B194<C194<A139<B107<C126<A174<B184<C173<A120<B144<C175<A156<B157<C114<A115<A198<B198<C133<B148<C142<C112<A163<B155<C160<B145<C111<C161<B104<C104<C131<A105<B171<C154<C121<C184<A159<B188<C158<A191<C157<C193<C164<C180<C139<A150<C187<C146<C105<C155<C163<C113<C168<C106<C147<C137<C143<C118<C156<M24X23<M22X11<M20X19<M20X18<M19X15<M18X16<M25X22<M23X21<M23X23<M22X17<M21X23<M19X13<M19X14<M16X23<M24X11<M22X18<M23X12<M26X14<M23X25<M26X25<M24X15<M24X16<M21X22<M22X13<M20X23<M17X21<M27X12<M14X14<M15X16<M12X11<M13X13<M14X18<M13X11<M13X12<M21X25<M19X19<M18X14<M17X11<M16X25<M17X15<M14X19<M13X23<M14X23<M13X22<M14X12<M15X24<M21X14<M20X13<M20X11<M17X20<M15X14<M13X19<M14X24<M14X11<M18X12<M18X13<M16X11<M17X12<M15X13<M13X18<M14X13<M15X19<M19X23<M20X25<M17X13<M16X12<M17X24<M18X19<M15X18<M15X17<M21X13<M18X23<M19X25<M18X17<M20X20<M20X21<M21X16<M21X15<M22X23<M11X11<M12X13<M13X20<M14X22<M13X14<M14X15<M15X12<M15X11<M15X25<M16X15<M14X16<M15X23<M16X24<M12X12<M13X24<M14X21<M16X19<M17X25<M14X20<M15X22<M16X13<M16X14<M15X21<M16X17<M17X19<M18X11<M18X20<M19X22<M15X20<M16X21<M17X18<M17X16<M18X21<M19X18<M19X24<M18X22<M20X15<M21X11<M22X12<M17X17<M16X20<M16X22<M14X25<M16X18<M17X14<M18X15<M19X12<M20X24<M23X24<M23X19<M25X14<M21X21<M22X16<M22X24<M23X20<M19X11<M20X12<M18X24<M19X20<M19X21<M18X25<M19X16<M20X22<M21X12<M21X24<M19X17<M20X17<M21X17<M22X19<M21X18<M22X15<M23X11<M22X14<M21X19<M22X25<M23X16<M24X25<M21X20<M22X22<M23X14<M24X18<M23X13<M24X22<M25X16<M23X15<M25X15<M24X12<M25X11<M24X13<M22X20<M24X24<M23X22<M24X14<M22X21<M23X17<M24X21<M25X19<M24X20<M25X25<M25X24<M25X23<M24X19<M26X15<M25X12<M26X12<M16X16<M17X23<M26X13<M25X13<M23X18<M24X17<M25X20<M26X24<M25X18<M26X19<M27X16<M26X17<M26X18<M27X20<M25X17<M27X24<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M20X14<M15X15<M17X22<M25X21<M26X16<M26X20<M26X22<M26X21<M26X23<M26X11<M27X17<M27X19<M27X13<M27X21<M28X24<M27X22<M27X23<M28X25<M28X14<M27X25<M28X23<M27X11<M28X13<M27X15<M28X18<M27X14<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
> -output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=2): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M28X24>M28X23>M27X21>M28X13>M27X20>M27X19>M26X14>M27X25>M28X18>M27X11>M28X25>M27X24>M26X24>M27X15>M27X14>M27X13>M26X23>M27X17>M26X22>M25X13>M28X14>M27X16>M26X19>M26X18>M27X23>M27X22>M26X17>M25X18>M26X21>M25X17>M26X20>M26X15>M26X13>M25X19>M24X14>M25X23>M26X11>M26X25>M25X16>M25X15>M24X22>M25X21>M25X20>M24X21>M25X25>M25X24>M24X20>M23X13>M22X15>M25X14>M24X19>M23X17>M24X25>M23X24>M24X13>M23X15>M24X18>M23X14>M22X11>M24X15>M23X22>M24X11>M23X19>M22X21>M24X24>M23X21>M22X20>M23X25>M22X19>M21X24>M20X23>M22X22>M25X11>M23X16>M22X18>M23X20>M22X17>M21X21>M21X20>M20X24>M22X14>M22X13>M21X11>M21X17>M22X23>M21X16>M20X25>M19X23>M18X16>M21X22>M20X20>M20X19>M21X13>M20X18>M19X13>M21X18>M20X21>M19X24>M18X12>M20X14>M20X13>M22X25>M20X12>M20X15>M19X14>M18X22>M19X18>M20X17>M19X17>M19X16>M18X21>M17X20>M19X19>M18X13>M17X11>M18X17>M19X25>M18X15>M17X25>M18X19>M17X24>M16X19>M15X17>M17X21>M16X24>M18X23>M17X16>M16X25>M19X15>M18X25>M17X23>M16X23>M15X23>M18X14>M17X14>M16X14>M17X18>M16X13>M17X22>M16X12>M15X22>M14X16>M17X12>M16X22>M15X12>M16X11>M15X11>M16X15>M15X25>M14X15>M13X14>M15X18>M16X21>M15X16>M14X21>M15X14>M16X20>M15X13>M14X22>M15X20>M14X20>M13X20>M14X11>M15X19>M14X24>M13X19>M14X13>M13X18>M12X13>M15X24>M14X23>M13X12>M14X12>M13X11>M12X11>M11X11>M21X12>M20X11>M19X11>M18X11>M17X15>M16X18>M14X25>M14X19>M13X24>M13X23>M13X22>M12X12>M22X12>M21X15>M19X22>M18X20>M16X17>M14X14>M24X12>M23X23>M22X16>M21X14>M20X22>M18X24>M16X16>M26X12>M24X16>M23X11>M21X23>M19X20>M17X17>M27X12>M26X16>M25X22>M24X17>M23X18>M21X25>M19X12>M17X19>M15X21>M14X18>M13X13>M23X12>M21X19>M19X21>M17X13>M15X15>M25X12>M24X23>M22X24>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>A150>C158>B112>A112>C167>B146>A146>C180>B180>A180>C143>B143>A115>C126>B126>A126>C190>B190>A190>C138>B138>A138>C174>B174>A102>C122>B122>A122>C162>B162>A162>C142>B142>A142>C102>B102>A174>C176>B176>A176>C115>B115>A143>C172>B172>A172>C187>B187>A187>C130>B130>A130>C118>B118>A118>C184>B184>A184>C171>B171>A171>C168>B182>A182>C182>B168>A168>C109>B109>A109>C159>B159>A159>C134>B134>A134>C146>B167>A167>C140>B140>A140>C163>B163>A163>C112>B158>A158>C164>B164>A164>C131>B131>A131>C188>B188>A188>C199>B199>A199>C114>B114>A114>C106>B106>A106>C200>B200>A200>C183>B183>A183>C152>B152>A152>C147>B147>A147>C150>B150>A198>C144>B144>A144>C191>B191>A191>C108>B108>A108>C139>B139>A139>C194>B194>A194>C166>B166>A166>C120>B120>A120>C123>B123>A123>C132>B132>A132>C107>B107>A107>C170>B170>A170>C198>B198>A156>C125>B125>A125>C121>B121>A121>C193>B193>A193>C197>B197>A197>C175>B175>A175>C196>B196>A196>C105>B105>A105>C181>B181>A181>C113>B113>A113>C137>B137>A137>C155>B155>A155>C156>B156>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B179>A179>C124>B124>A124>C151>B151>A151>C178>B178>A178>C104>B104>A104>C111>B111>A111>C148>B148>A148>C169>B169>A169>C129>B129>A129>C149>B149>A149>C189>B189>A189>C119>B119>A119>C154>B154>A154>C136>B136>A136>C135>B135>A135>C116>B116>A116>C145>B145>A145>C161>B161>A161>C173>B173>A173>C157>B157>A157>C195>B195>A195>C186>B186>A186>C160>B160>A160>C153>B153>A153>C117>B117>A117>C165>B165>A165>C101>B101>A101>C103>B103>A103>C192>B192>A192>C177>B177>A177>C185>B185>A185>C141>B141>A141>C133>B133>A133>C127>B127>A127>C110>B110>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>{}<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<B110<C110<A127<B127<C127<A133<B133<C133<A141<B141<C141<A185<B185<C185<A177<B177<C177<A192<B192<C192<A103<B103<C103<A101<B101<C101<A165<B165<C165<A117<B117<C117<A153<B153<C153<A160<B160<C160<A186<B186<C186<A195<B195<C195<A157<B157<C157<A173<B173<C173<A161<B161<C161<A145<B145<C145<A116<B116<C116<A135<B135<C135<A136<B136<C136<A154<B154<C154<A119<B119<C119<A189<B189<C189<A149<B149<C149<A129<B129<C129<A169<B169<C169<A148<B148<C148<A111<B111<C111<A104<B104<C104<A178<B178<C178<A151<B151<C151<A124<B124<C124<A179<B179<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B156<C156<A155<B155<C155<A137<B137<C137<A113<B113<C113<A181<B181<C181<A105<B105<C105<A196<B196<C196<A175<B175<C175<A197<B197<C197<A193<B193<C193<A121<B121<C121<A125<B125<C125<A156<B198<C198<A170<B170<C170<A107<B107<C107<A132<B132<C132<A123<B123<C123<A120<B120<C120<A166<B166<C166<A194<B194<C194<A139<B139<C139<A108<B108<C108<A191<B191<C191<A144<B144<C144<A198<B150<C150<A147<B147<C147<A152<B152<C152<A183<B183<C183<A200<B200<C200<A106<B106<C106<A114<B114<C114<A199<B199<C199<A188<B188<C188<A131<B131<C131<A164<B164<C164<A158<B158<C112<A163<B163<C163<A140<B140<C140<A167<B167<C146<A134<B134<C134<A159<B159<C159<A109<B109<C109<A168<B168<C182<A182<B182<C168<A171<B171<C171<A184<B184<C184<A118<B118<C118<A130<B130<C130<A187<B187<C187<A172<B172<C172<A143<B115<C115<A176<B176<C176<A174<B102<C102<A142<B142<C142<A162<B162<C162<A122<B122<C122<A102<B174<C174<A138<B138<C138<A190<B190<C190<A126<B126<C126<A115<B143<C143<A180<B180<C180<A146<B146<C167<A112<B112<C158<A150<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M22X24<M24X23<M25X12<M15X15<M17X13<M19X21<M21X19<M23X12<M13X13<M14X18<M15X21<M17X19<M19X12<M21X25<M23X18<M24X17<M25X22<M26X16<M27X12<M17X17<M19X20<M21X23<M23X11<M24X16<M26X12<M16X16<M18X24<M20X22<M21X14<M22X16<M23X23<M24X12<M14X14<M16X17<M18X20<M19X22<M21X15<M22X12<M12X12<M13X22<M13X23<M13X24<M14X19<M14X25<M16X18<M17X15<M18X11<M19X11<M20X11<M21X12<M11X11<M12X11<M13X11<M14X12<M13X12<M14X23<M15X24<M12X13<M13X18<M14X13<M13X19<M14X24<M15X19<M14X11<M13X20<M14X20<M15X20<M14X22<M15X13<M16X20<M15X14<M14X21<M15X16<M16X21<M15X18<M13X14<M14X15<M15X25<M16X15<M15X11<M16X11<M15X12<M16X22<M17X12<M14X16<M15X22<M16X12<M17X22<M16X13<M17X18<M16X14<M17X14<M18X14<M15X23<M16X23<M17X23<M18X25<M19X15<M16X25<M17X16<M18X23<M16X24<M17X21<M15X17<M16X19<M17X24<M18X19<M17X25<M18X15<M19X25<M18X17<M17X11<M18X13<M19X19<M17X20<M18X21<M19X16<M19X17<M20X17<M19X18<M18X22<M19X14<M20X15<M20X12<M22X25<M20X13<M20X14<M18X12<M19X24<M20X21<M21X18<M19X13<M20X18<M21X13<M20X19<M20X20<M21X22<M18X16<M19X23<M20X25<M21X16<M22X23<M21X17<M21X11<M22X13<M22X14<M20X24<M21X20<M21X21<M22X17<M23X20<M22X18<M23X16<M25X11<M22X22<M20X23<M21X24<M22X19<M23X25<M22X20<M23X21<M24X24<M22X21<M23X19<M24X11<M23X22<M24X15<M22X11<M23X14<M24X18<M23X15<M24X13<M23X24<M24X25<M23X17<M24X19<M25X14<M22X15<M23X13<M24X20<M25X24<M25X25<M24X21<M25X20<M25X21<M24X22<M25X15<M25X16<M26X25<M26X11<M25X23<M24X14<M25X19<M26X13<M26X15<M26X20<M25X17<M26X21<M25X18<M26X17<M27X22<M27X23<M26X18<M26X19<M27X16<M28X14<M25X13<M26X22<M27X17<M26X23<M27X13<M27X14<M27X15<M26X24<M27X24<M28X25<M27X11<M28X18<M27X25<M26X14<M27X19<M27X20<M28X13<M27X21<M28X23<M28X24<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
> +xfail_output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=1): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M27X14>M28X18>M27X15>M28X13>M27X11>M28X23>M27X25>M28X14>M28X25>M27X23>M27X22>M28X24>M27X21>M27X13>M27X19>M27X17>M26X11>M26X23>M26X21>M26X22>M26X20>M26X16>M25X21>M17X22>M15X15>M20X14>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>M27X24>M25X17>M27X20>M26X18>M26X17>M27X16>M26X19>M25X18>M26X24>M25X20>M24X17>M23X18>M25X13>M26X13>M17X23>M16X16>M26X12>M25X12>M26X15>M24X19>M25X23>M25X24>M25X25>M24X20>M25X19>M24X21>M23X17>M22X21>M24X14>M23X22>M24X24>M22X20>M24X13>M25X11>M24X12>M25X15>M23X15>M25X16>M24X22>M23X13>M24X18>M23X14>M22X22>M21X20>M24X25>M23X16>M22X25>M21X19>M22X14>M23X11>M22X15>M21X18>M22X19>M21X17>M20X17>M19X17>M21X24>M21X12>M20X22>M19X16>M18X25>M19X21>M19X20>M18X24>M20X12>M19X11>M23X20>M22X24>M22X16>M21X21>M25X14>M23X19>M23X24>M20X24>M19X12>M18X15>M17X14>M16X18>M14X25>M16X22>M16X20>M17X17>M22X12>M21X11>M20X15>M18X22>M19X24>M19X18>M18X21>M17X16>M17X18>M16X21>M15X20>M19X22>M18X20>M18X11>M17X19>M16X17>M15X21>M16X14>M16X13>M15X22>M14X20>M17X25>M16X19>M14X21>M13X24>M12X12>M16X24>M15X23>M14X16>M16X15>M15X25>M15X11>M15X12>M14X15>M13X14>M14X22>M13X20>M12X13>M11X11>M22X23>M21X15>M21X16>M20X21>M20X20>M18X17>M19X25>M18X23>M21X13>M15X17>M15X18>M18X19>M17X24>M16X12>M17X13>M20X25>M19X23>M15X19>M14X13>M13X18>M15X13>M17X12>M16X11>M18X13>M18X12>M14X11>M14X24>M13X19>M15X14>M17X20>M20X11>M20X13>M21X14>M15X24>M14X12>M13X22>M14X23>M13X23>M14X19>M17X15>M16X25>M17X11>M18X14>M19X19>M21X25>M13X12>M13X11>M14X18>M13X13>M12X11>M15X16>M14X14>M27X12>M17X21>M20X23>M22X13>M21X22>M24X16>M24X15>M26X25>M23X25>M26X14>M23X12>M22X18>M24X11>M16X23>M19X14>M19X13>M21X23>M22X17>M23X23>M23X21>M25X22>M18X16>M19X15>M20X18>M20X19>M22X11>M24X23>C156>C118>C143>C137>C147>C106>C168>C113>C163>C155>C105>C146>C187>A150>C139>C180>C164>C193>C157>A191>C158>B188>A159>C184>C121>C154>B171>A105>C131>C104>B104>C161>C111>B145>C160>B155>A163>C112>C142>B148>C133>B198>A198>A115>C114>B157>A156>C175>B144>A120>C173>B184>A174>C126>B107>A139>C194>B194>A194>C116>B116>C166>B160>B110>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B162>A154>C186>B187>A179>C124>B181>A101>C153>B158>A136>C135>C176>A192>B133>A133>C177>B177>A177>C185>C103>B141>A141>C183>A162>C192>C129>B179>C144>B124>B183>C127>B127>A127>B108>A112>B153>A153>C167>B167>A186>A122>C162>A144>B149>C174>B131>A185>C141>B106>A126>A167>C140>B122>A170>C198>B143>C117>C123>B123>A147>A106>C200>B169>C191>B175>A123>B118>A182>C132>B151>A145>A104>A109>C159>C150>B119>A119>A178>B164>B114>A164>C181>A102>C122>B134>A157>A116>C195>B191>B111>C172>B172>A118>B129>A129>C149>A107>C170>B197>A197>A173>B168>A132>C107>B165>A160>A131>C188>A168>B109>C178>A189>A148>C119>C190>C120>B166>B176>C108>B135>B139>A103>B178>A169>B132>C125>C138>B163>A111>B170>C110>A165>C151>C169>C199>A138>C182>A135>B101>B142>C101>C148>B193>B152>A158>A199>C136>B137>A161>B120>A108>A149>A125>B113>A184>C171>A134>A175>A124>B150>B161>B102>A146>A187>C130>B192>B200>A200>A142>A183>C102>B105>B156>A176>C165>B147>A137>A196>B190>A190>B125>C134>C189>B126>B186>A166>B136>B195>A195>B154>B138>B112>B173>A117>B159>B182>A181>A140>C145>B117>A152>A193>C197>B130>A172>A113>A151>B115>A143>B140>B185>B103>A121>A180>A130>A171>B199>C196>B146>B180>C115>B174>B121>A188>B196>B189>C152>C109>A155>A114>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>.>{}<.<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<A114<A155<C109<C152<B189<B196<A188<B121<B174<C115<B180<B146<C196<B199<A171<A130<A180<A121<B103<B185<B140<A143<B115<A151<A113<A172<B130<C197<A193<A152<B117<C145<A140<A181<B182<B159<A117<B173<B112<B138<B154<A195<B195<B136<A166<B186<B126<C189<C134<B125<A190<B190<A196<A137<B147<C165<A176<B156<B105<C102<A183<A142<A200<B200<B192<C130<A187<A146<B102<B161<B150<A124<A175<A134<C171<A184<B113<A125<A149<A108<B120<A161<B137<C136<A199<A158<B152<B193<C148<C101<B142<B101<A135<C182<A138<C199<C169<C151<A165<C110<B170<A111<B163<C138<C125<B132<A169<B178<A103<B139<B135<C108<B176<B166<C120<C190<C119<A148<A189<C178<B109<A168<C188<A131<A160<B165<C107<A132<B168<A173<A197<B197<C170<A107<C149<A129<B129<A118<B172<C172<B111<B191<C195<A116<A157<B134<C122<A102<C181<A164<B114<B164<A178<A119<B119<C150<C159<A109<A104<A145<B151<C132<A182<B118<A123<B175<C191<B169<C200<A106<A147<B123<C123<C117<B143<C198<A170<B122<C140<A167<A126<B106<C141<A185<B131<C174<B149<A144<C162<A122<A186<B167<C167<A153<B153<A112<B108<A127<B127<C127<B183<B124<C144<B179<C129<C192<A162<C183<A141<B141<C103<C185<A177<B177<C177<A133<B133<A192<C176<C135<A136<B158<C153<A101<B181<C124<A179<B187<C186<A154<B162<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B110<B160<C166<B116<C116<A194<B194<C194<A139<B107<C126<A174<B184<C173<A120<B144<C175<A156<B157<C114<A115<A198<B198<C133<B148<C142<C112<A163<B155<C160<B145<C111<C161<B104<C104<C131<A105<B171<C154<C121<C184<A159<B188<C158<A191<C157<C193<C164<C180<C139<A150<C187<C146<C105<C155<C163<C113<C168<C106<C147<C137<C143<C118<C156<M24X23<M22X11<M20X19<M20X18<M19X15<M18X16<M25X22<M23X21<M23X23<M22X17<M21X23<M19X13<M19X14<M16X23<M24X11<M22X18<M23X12<M26X14<M23X25<M26X25<M24X15<M24X16<M21X22<M22X13<M20X23<M17X21<M27X12<M14X14<M15X16<M12X11<M13X13<M14X18<M13X11<M13X12<M21X25<M19X19<M18X14<M17X11<M16X25<M17X15<M14X19<M13X23<M14X23<M13X22<M14X12<M15X24<M21X14<M20X13<M20X11<M17X20<M15X14<M13X19<M14X24<M14X11<M18X12<M18X13<M16X11<M17X12<M15X13<M13X18<M14X13<M15X19<M19X23<M20X25<M17X13<M16X12<M17X24<M18X19<M15X18<M15X17<M21X13<M18X23<M19X25<M18X17<M20X20<M20X21<M21X16<M21X15<M22X23<M11X11<M12X13<M13X20<M14X22<M13X14<M14X15<M15X12<M15X11<M15X25<M16X15<M14X16<M15X23<M16X24<M12X12<M13X24<M14X21<M16X19<M17X25<M14X20<M15X22<M16X13<M16X14<M15X21<M16X17<M17X19<M18X11<M18X20<M19X22<M15X20<M16X21<M17X18<M17X16<M18X21<M19X18<M19X24<M18X22<M20X15<M21X11<M22X12<M17X17<M16X20<M16X22<M14X25<M16X18<M17X14<M18X15<M19X12<M20X24<M23X24<M23X19<M25X14<M21X21<M22X16<M22X24<M23X20<M19X11<M20X12<M18X24<M19X20<M19X21<M18X25<M19X16<M20X22<M21X12<M21X24<M19X17<M20X17<M21X17<M22X19<M21X18<M22X15<M23X11<M22X14<M21X19<M22X25<M23X16<M24X25<M21X20<M22X22<M23X14<M24X18<M23X13<M24X22<M25X16<M23X15<M25X15<M24X12<M25X11<M24X13<M22X20<M24X24<M23X22<M24X14<M22X21<M23X17<M24X21<M25X19<M24X20<M25X25<M25X24<M25X23<M24X19<M26X15<M25X12<M26X12<M16X16<M17X23<M26X13<M25X13<M23X18<M24X17<M25X20<M26X24<M25X18<M26X19<M27X16<M26X17<M26X18<M27X20<M25X17<M27X24<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M20X14<M15X15<M17X22<M25X21<M26X16<M26X20<M26X22<M26X21<M26X23<M26X11<M27X17<M27X19<M27X13<M27X21<M28X24<M27X22<M27X23<M28X25<M28X14<M27X25<M28X23<M27X11<M28X13<M27X15<M28X18<M27X14<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
> +output(glibc.rtld.dynamic_sort=2): M30X19>M30X15>M30X16>M30X11>M30X12>M30X17>M30X13>M30X14>M29X20>M30X23>M30X24>M30X20>M30X18>M29X15>M29X12>M30X22>M30X21>M29X22>M30X25>M29X19>M29X23>M29X16>M29X24>M29X13>M29X17>M29X18>M28X19>M29X21>M29X25>M29X14>M28X20>M28X15>M28X16>M28X21>M27X18>M29X11>M28X17>M28X11>M28X22>M28X24>M28X23>M27X21>M28X13>M27X20>M27X19>M26X14>M27X25>M28X18>M27X11>M28X25>M27X24>M26X24>M27X15>M27X14>M27X13>M26X23>M27X17>M26X22>M25X13>M28X14>M27X16>M26X19>M26X18>M27X23>M27X22>M26X17>M25X18>M26X21>M25X17>M26X20>M26X15>M26X13>M25X19>M24X14>M25X23>M26X11>M26X25>M25X16>M25X15>M24X22>M25X21>M25X20>M24X21>M25X25>M25X24>M24X20>M23X13>M22X15>M25X14>M24X19>M23X17>M24X25>M23X24>M24X13>M23X15>M24X18>M23X14>M22X11>M24X15>M23X22>M24X11>M23X19>M22X21>M24X24>M23X21>M22X20>M23X25>M22X19>M21X24>M20X23>M22X22>M25X11>M23X16>M22X18>M23X20>M22X17>M21X21>M21X20>M20X24>M22X14>M22X13>M21X11>M21X17>M22X23>M21X16>M20X25>M19X23>M18X16>M21X22>M20X20>M20X19>M21X13>M20X18>M19X13>M21X18>M20X21>M19X24>M18X12>M20X14>M20X13>M22X25>M20X12>M20X15>M19X14>M18X22>M19X18>M20X17>M19X17>M19X16>M18X21>M17X20>M19X19>M18X13>M17X11>M18X17>M19X25>M18X15>M17X25>M18X19>M17X24>M16X19>M15X17>M17X21>M16X24>M18X23>M17X16>M16X25>M19X15>M18X25>M17X23>M16X23>M15X23>M18X14>M17X14>M16X14>M17X18>M16X13>M17X22>M16X12>M15X22>M14X16>M17X12>M16X22>M15X12>M16X11>M15X11>M16X15>M15X25>M14X15>M13X14>M15X18>M16X21>M15X16>M14X21>M15X14>M16X20>M15X13>M14X22>M15X20>M14X20>M13X20>M14X11>M15X19>M14X24>M13X19>M14X13>M13X18>M12X13>M15X24>M14X23>M13X12>M14X12>M13X11>M12X11>M11X11>M21X12>M20X11>M19X11>M18X11>M17X15>M16X18>M14X25>M14X19>M13X24>M13X23>M13X22>M12X12>M22X12>M21X15>M19X22>M18X20>M16X17>M14X14>M24X12>M23X23>M22X16>M21X14>M20X22>M18X24>M16X16>M26X12>M24X16>M23X11>M21X23>M19X20>M17X17>M27X12>M26X16>M25X22>M24X17>M23X18>M21X25>M19X12>M17X19>M15X21>M14X18>M13X13>M23X12>M21X19>M19X21>M17X13>M15X15>M25X12>M24X23>M22X24>M20X16>M18X18>M28X12>A150>C158>B112>A112>C167>B146>A146>C180>B180>A180>C143>B143>A115>C126>B126>A126>C190>B190>A190>C138>B138>A138>C174>B174>A102>C122>B122>A122>C162>B162>A162>C142>B142>A142>C102>B102>A174>C176>B176>A176>C115>B115>A143>C172>B172>A172>C187>B187>A187>C130>B130>A130>C118>B118>A118>C184>B184>A184>C171>B171>A171>C168>B182>A182>C182>B168>A168>C109>B109>A109>C159>B159>A159>C134>B134>A134>C146>B167>A167>C140>B140>A140>C163>B163>A163>C112>B158>A158>C164>B164>A164>C131>B131>A131>C188>B188>A188>C199>B199>A199>C114>B114>A114>C106>B106>A106>C200>B200>A200>C183>B183>A183>C152>B152>A152>C147>B147>A147>C150>B150>A198>C144>B144>A144>C191>B191>A191>C108>B108>A108>C139>B139>A139>C194>B194>A194>C166>B166>A166>C120>B120>A120>C123>B123>A123>C132>B132>A132>C107>B107>A107>C170>B170>A170>C198>B198>A156>C125>B125>A125>C121>B121>A121>C193>B193>A193>C197>B197>A197>C175>B175>A175>C196>B196>A196>C105>B105>A105>C181>B181>A181>C113>B113>A113>C137>B137>A137>C155>B155>A155>C156>B156>A110>C128>B128>A128>C179>B179>A179>C124>B124>A124>C151>B151>A151>C178>B178>A178>C104>B104>A104>C111>B111>A111>C148>B148>A148>C169>B169>A169>C129>B129>A129>C149>B149>A149>C189>B189>A189>C119>B119>A119>C154>B154>A154>C136>B136>A136>C135>B135>A135>C116>B116>A116>C145>B145>A145>C161>B161>A161>C173>B173>A173>C157>B157>A157>C195>B195>A195>C186>B186>A186>C160>B160>A160>C153>B153>A153>C117>B117>A117>C165>B165>A165>C101>B101>A101>C103>B103>A103>C192>B192>A192>C177>B177>A177>C185>B185>A185>C141>B141>A141>C133>B133>A133>C127>B127>A127>C110>B110>M14X17>M13X15>M13X16>M13X17>M12X17>M12X21>M12X25>M12X14>M13X25>M12X15>M13X21>M12X16>M12X18>M12X19>M12X20>M12X22>M12X23>M12X24>M11X25>M11X24>M11X23>M11X22>M11X21>M11X20>M11X19>M11X18>M11X17>M11X16>M11X15>M11X14>M11X13>M11X12>.>{}<.<M11X12<M11X13<M11X14<M11X15<M11X16<M11X17<M11X18<M11X19<M11X20<M11X21<M11X22<M11X23<M11X24<M11X25<M12X24<M12X23<M12X22<M12X20<M12X19<M12X18<M12X16<M13X21<M12X15<M13X25<M12X14<M12X25<M12X21<M12X17<M13X17<M13X16<M13X15<M14X17<B110<C110<A127<B127<C127<A133<B133<C133<A141<B141<C141<A185<B185<C185<A177<B177<C177<A192<B192<C192<A103<B103<C103<A101<B101<C101<A165<B165<C165<A117<B117<C117<A153<B153<C153<A160<B160<C160<A186<B186<C186<A195<B195<C195<A157<B157<C157<A173<B173<C173<A161<B161<C161<A145<B145<C145<A116<B116<C116<A135<B135<C135<A136<B136<C136<A154<B154<C154<A119<B119<C119<A189<B189<C189<A149<B149<C149<A129<B129<C129<A169<B169<C169<A148<B148<C148<A111<B111<C111<A104<B104<C104<A178<B178<C178<A151<B151<C151<A124<B124<C124<A179<B179<C179<A128<B128<C128<A110<B156<C156<A155<B155<C155<A137<B137<C137<A113<B113<C113<A181<B181<C181<A105<B105<C105<A196<B196<C196<A175<B175<C175<A197<B197<C197<A193<B193<C193<A121<B121<C121<A125<B125<C125<A156<B198<C198<A170<B170<C170<A107<B107<C107<A132<B132<C132<A123<B123<C123<A120<B120<C120<A166<B166<C166<A194<B194<C194<A139<B139<C139<A108<B108<C108<A191<B191<C191<A144<B144<C144<A198<B150<C150<A147<B147<C147<A152<B152<C152<A183<B183<C183<A200<B200<C200<A106<B106<C106<A114<B114<C114<A199<B199<C199<A188<B188<C188<A131<B131<C131<A164<B164<C164<A158<B158<C112<A163<B163<C163<A140<B140<C140<A167<B167<C146<A134<B134<C134<A159<B159<C159<A109<B109<C109<A168<B168<C182<A182<B182<C168<A171<B171<C171<A184<B184<C184<A118<B118<C118<A130<B130<C130<A187<B187<C187<A172<B172<C172<A143<B115<C115<A176<B176<C176<A174<B102<C102<A142<B142<C142<A162<B162<C162<A122<B122<C122<A102<B174<C174<A138<B138<C138<A190<B190<C190<A126<B126<C126<A115<B143<C143<A180<B180<C180<A146<B146<C167<A112<B112<C158<A150<M28X12<M18X18<M20X16<M22X24<M24X23<M25X12<M15X15<M17X13<M19X21<M21X19<M23X12<M13X13<M14X18<M15X21<M17X19<M19X12<M21X25<M23X18<M24X17<M25X22<M26X16<M27X12<M17X17<M19X20<M21X23<M23X11<M24X16<M26X12<M16X16<M18X24<M20X22<M21X14<M22X16<M23X23<M24X12<M14X14<M16X17<M18X20<M19X22<M21X15<M22X12<M12X12<M13X22<M13X23<M13X24<M14X19<M14X25<M16X18<M17X15<M18X11<M19X11<M20X11<M21X12<M11X11<M12X11<M13X11<M14X12<M13X12<M14X23<M15X24<M12X13<M13X18<M14X13<M13X19<M14X24<M15X19<M14X11<M13X20<M14X20<M15X20<M14X22<M15X13<M16X20<M15X14<M14X21<M15X16<M16X21<M15X18<M13X14<M14X15<M15X25<M16X15<M15X11<M16X11<M15X12<M16X22<M17X12<M14X16<M15X22<M16X12<M17X22<M16X13<M17X18<M16X14<M17X14<M18X14<M15X23<M16X23<M17X23<M18X25<M19X15<M16X25<M17X16<M18X23<M16X24<M17X21<M15X17<M16X19<M17X24<M18X19<M17X25<M18X15<M19X25<M18X17<M17X11<M18X13<M19X19<M17X20<M18X21<M19X16<M19X17<M20X17<M19X18<M18X22<M19X14<M20X15<M20X12<M22X25<M20X13<M20X14<M18X12<M19X24<M20X21<M21X18<M19X13<M20X18<M21X13<M20X19<M20X20<M21X22<M18X16<M19X23<M20X25<M21X16<M22X23<M21X17<M21X11<M22X13<M22X14<M20X24<M21X20<M21X21<M22X17<M23X20<M22X18<M23X16<M25X11<M22X22<M20X23<M21X24<M22X19<M23X25<M22X20<M23X21<M24X24<M22X21<M23X19<M24X11<M23X22<M24X15<M22X11<M23X14<M24X18<M23X15<M24X13<M23X24<M24X25<M23X17<M24X19<M25X14<M22X15<M23X13<M24X20<M25X24<M25X25<M24X21<M25X20<M25X21<M24X22<M25X15<M25X16<M26X25<M26X11<M25X23<M24X14<M25X19<M26X13<M26X15<M26X20<M25X17<M26X21<M25X18<M26X17<M27X22<M27X23<M26X18<M26X19<M27X16<M28X14<M25X13<M26X22<M27X17<M26X23<M27X13<M27X14<M27X15<M26X24<M27X24<M28X25<M27X11<M28X18<M27X25<M26X14<M27X19<M27X20<M28X13<M27X21<M28X23<M28X24<M28X22<M28X11<M28X17<M29X11<M27X18<M28X21<M28X16<M28X15<M28X20<M29X14<M29X25<M29X21<M28X19<M29X18<M29X17<M29X13<M29X24<M29X16<M29X23<M29X19<M30X25<M29X22<M30X21<M30X22<M29X12<M29X15<M30X18<M30X20<M30X24<M30X23<M29X20<M30X14<M30X13<M30X17<M30X12<M30X11<M30X16<M30X15<M30X19
OK. Likewise.
> diff --git a/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py b/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py
> index e4da3d64fd..f11ef68f21 100644
> --- a/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py
> +++ b/scripts/dso-ordering-test.py
> @@ -181,7 +181,7 @@ parts:
> 3. Destructors' output
>
> To see by example, a simple test description "a->b->c" generates a testcase
> -that when run, outputs: "c>b>a>{}<a<b<c"
> +that when run, outputs: "c>b>a>.>{}<.<a<b<c"
OK.
>
> Each generated DSO constructor prints its name followed by a '>' character,
> and the "c>b>a" part above is the full constructor output by all DSOs, the
> @@ -192,6 +192,9 @@ Destructor output for each DSO is a '<' character followed by its name,
> reflecting its reverse nature of constructors. In the above example, the
> destructor output part is "<a<b<c".
>
> +The main program prints '.>' and '<.' when its constructors and
> +destructors are invoked.
OK.
> +
> The middle "{}" part is the main program. In this simple example, nothing
> was specified for the main program, so by default it is implicitly linked
> to the DSO 'a' (with no other DSOs depending on it) and only prints the
> @@ -201,7 +204,7 @@ To see an example with actions inside the main program, lets see an example
> description: c->g=>h;{+c;%c;-c}->a->h
>
> This produces a testcase, that when executed outputs:
> - h>a>{+c[g>c>];%c();-c[<c<g];}<a<h
> + h>a>.>{+c[g>c>];%c();-c[<c<g];}<.<a<h
OK.
>
> The constructor and destructor parts display the a->h dependency as expected.
> Inside the main program, the "+c" action triggers a dlopen() of DSO 'c',
> @@ -218,6 +221,7 @@ by the main test program constructs documented earlier.
>
> The output strings described here is the exact same form placed in
> test description files' "output: <expected output>" line.
> +
> """
>
> import sys
> @@ -774,15 +778,9 @@ def process_testcase(t):
> test_srcdir, base_test_name, exp_tunable_sfx,
> ("X" if xfail else ""), test_name, tunable_descr))
>
> - # Generate C files according to dependency and calling relations from
> - # description string.
> - for obj in test_descr.objs:
> - src_name = test_name + "-" + obj + ".c"
> - f = open(testpfx_src + src_name, "w")
> - if obj in test_descr.callrefs:
> - called_objs = test_descr.callrefs[obj]
> - for callee in called_objs:
> - f.write("extern void fn_%s (void);\n" % (callee))
> + def write_initfini(f, obj):
> + """Write init/fini ELF constructor/destructor functions to F."""
> +
OK. Create a subroutine. Later we will call it by moving the loop up a level.
> if len(obj) == 1:
> f.write("extern int putchar(int);\n")
> f.write("static void __attribute__((constructor)) " +
> @@ -795,6 +793,17 @@ def process_testcase(t):
> 'init(void){printf("%s>");}\n' % (obj))
> f.write('static void __attribute__((destructor)) ' +
> 'fini(void){printf("<%s");}\n' % (obj))
> +
> + # Generate C files according to dependency and calling relations from
> + # description string.
> + for obj in test_descr.objs:
> + src_name = test_name + "-" + obj + ".c"
> + f = open(testpfx_src + src_name, "w")
> + if obj in test_descr.callrefs:
> + called_objs = test_descr.callrefs[obj]
> + for callee in called_objs:
> + f.write("extern void fn_%s (void);\n" % (callee))
> + write_initfini(f, obj)
OK. Call write_initfini.
> if obj in test_descr.callrefs:
> called_objs = test_descr.callrefs[obj]
> if len(obj) != 1:
> @@ -828,6 +837,7 @@ def process_testcase(t):
> f.write("#include <stdio.h>\n")
> f.write("#include <stdlib.h>\n")
> f.write("#include <dlfcn.h>\n")
> + write_initfini(f, '.')
Lastly, for the main program.
> for s in test_descr.main_program:
> if s[0] == '@':
> f.write("extern void fn_%s (void);\n" % (s[1:]));
--
Cheers,
Carlos.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 2/3] elf: Add dummy declaration of _dl_audit_objclose for !SHARED
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 2/3] elf: Add dummy declaration of _dl_audit_objclose for !SHARED Florian Weimer
@ 2023-09-19 12:43 ` Carlos O'Donell
0 siblings, 0 replies; 12+ messages in thread
From: Carlos O'Donell @ 2023-09-19 12:43 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Florian Weimer, libc-alpha
On 9/19/23 04:48, Florian Weimer wrote:
> This allows us to avoid some #ifdef SHARED conditionals.
LGTM.
Reviewed-by: Carlos O'Donell <carlos@redhat.com>
> ---
> sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h | 9 ++++++++-
> 1 file changed, 8 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-)
>
> diff --git a/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h b/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
> index edebca9a23..82c5383c7e 100644
> --- a/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
> +++ b/sysdeps/generic/ldsodefs.h
> @@ -1383,7 +1383,14 @@ void DL_ARCH_FIXUP_ATTRIBUTE _dl_audit_pltexit (struct link_map *l,
> const void *inregs,
> void *outregs)
> attribute_hidden;
> -#endif /* SHARED */
> +
> +#else /* !SHARED */
> +static inline void
> +_dl_audit_objclose (struct link_map *l)
> +{
> + /* No audit implementation for !SHARED. */
> +}
> +#endif /* !SHARED */
OK.
>
> #if PTHREAD_IN_LIBC && defined SHARED
> /* Recursive locking implementation for use within the dynamic loader.
--
Cheers,
Carlos.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
2023-09-19 12:41 ` Carlos O'Donell
@ 2023-09-19 12:47 ` Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 14:24 ` Carlos O'Donell
0 siblings, 1 reply; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-09-19 12:47 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Carlos O'Donell; +Cc: libc-alpha
* Carlos O'Donell:
> On 9/19/23 04:48, Florian Weimer wrote:
>> Previously, the ordering was not capture in the test output. Adjust
>
> s/capture/captured/g (as noted by Andreas)
>
>> expected test output accordingly. Note that after commit 6985865bc3a
>> ("elf: Always call destructors in reverse constructor order
>> (bug 30785)"), the main program destructors in tst-bz28937 run last
>> (which is bug XXX).
>
> Do we need to fill in bug XXX?
It's bug 30869, I just forgot to update the commit message.
Thanks,
Florian
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
2023-09-19 12:47 ` Florian Weimer
@ 2023-09-19 14:24 ` Carlos O'Donell
2023-09-19 14:41 ` Florian Weimer
0 siblings, 1 reply; 12+ messages in thread
From: Carlos O'Donell @ 2023-09-19 14:24 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Florian Weimer; +Cc: libc-alpha
On 9/19/23 08:47, Florian Weimer wrote:
> * Carlos O'Donell:
>
>> On 9/19/23 04:48, Florian Weimer wrote:
>>> Previously, the ordering was not capture in the test output. Adjust
>>
>> s/capture/captured/g (as noted by Andreas)
>>
>>> expected test output accordingly. Note that after commit 6985865bc3a
>>> ("elf: Always call destructors in reverse constructor order
>>> (bug 30785)"), the main program destructors in tst-bz28937 run last
>>> (which is bug XXX).
>>
>> Do we need to fill in bug XXX?
>
> It's bug 30869, I just forgot to update the commit message.
Perfect.
Let me finish reviewing 3/3 and then we can proceed with a light review
of v2 with the cleanups?
--
Cheers,
Carlos.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests
2023-09-19 14:24 ` Carlos O'Donell
@ 2023-09-19 14:41 ` Florian Weimer
0 siblings, 0 replies; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-09-19 14:41 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Carlos O'Donell; +Cc: libc-alpha
* Carlos O'Donell:
> On 9/19/23 08:47, Florian Weimer wrote:
>> * Carlos O'Donell:
>>
>>> On 9/19/23 04:48, Florian Weimer wrote:
>>>> Previously, the ordering was not capture in the test output. Adjust
>>>
>>> s/capture/captured/g (as noted by Andreas)
>>>
>>>> expected test output accordingly. Note that after commit 6985865bc3a
>>>> ("elf: Always call destructors in reverse constructor order
>>>> (bug 30785)"), the main program destructors in tst-bz28937 run last
>>>> (which is bug XXX).
>>>
>>> Do we need to fill in bug XXX?
>>
>> It's bug 30869, I just forgot to update the commit message.
>
> Perfect.
>
> Let me finish reviewing 3/3 and then we can proceed with a light review
> of v2 with the cleanups?
Works for me, thanks.
Florian
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
* Re: [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering (bug 30869)
2023-09-19 8:48 [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
` (2 preceding siblings ...)
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 3/3] elf: Process initially loaded objects first in _dl_fini (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
@ 2023-10-06 12:35 ` Florian Weimer
3 siblings, 0 replies; 12+ messages in thread
From: Florian Weimer @ 2023-10-06 12:35 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: libc-alpha
* Florian Weimer:
> It turns out that we cannot simply reverse the constructor ordering.
> Some applications expect that the main program is destructed first.
> It also seems reasonable to assume that some applications depend
> on the destructor ordering resulting from explicit dlclose calls
> upon exit time (destructors calling dlclose).
>
> The change in main program destructor ordering went unnoticed because
> the DSO ordering test framework did not record main program
> constructor/destructor calls, so the first commit fixes that omission.
Further testing shows that doesn't work. We need to revert the ordering
changes (patches already posted). I'm testing a completely different
approach with downstream patches.
Thanks,
Florian
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 12+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~2023-10-06 12:35 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 12+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
2023-09-19 8:48 [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 1/3] elf: Record main program constructor/destructor in ordering tests Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:56 ` Andreas Schwab
2023-09-19 9:30 ` Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 12:41 ` Carlos O'Donell
2023-09-19 12:47 ` Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 14:24 ` Carlos O'Donell
2023-09-19 14:41 ` Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 2/3] elf: Add dummy declaration of _dl_audit_objclose for !SHARED Florian Weimer
2023-09-19 12:43 ` Carlos O'Donell
2023-09-19 8:48 ` [PATCH 3/3] elf: Process initially loaded objects first in _dl_fini (bug 30869) Florian Weimer
2023-10-06 12:35 ` [PATCH 0/3] Fine-tune ELF destructor ordering " Florian Weimer
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for read-only IMAP folder(s) and NNTP newsgroup(s).