public inbox for gdb@sourceware.org
 help / color / mirror / Atom feed
From: Bob Rossi <bob@brasko.net>
To: gdb@sources.redhat.com
Cc: cagney@redhat.com, ezannoni@redhat.com, fnasser@redhat.com
Subject: Re: GDB/XMI (XML Machine Interface)
Date: Fri, 20 Aug 2004 19:59:00 -0000	[thread overview]
Message-ID: <20040820195928.GA6372@white> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <20040820194224.GA24407@nevyn.them.org>

On Fri, Aug 20, 2004 at 03:42:24PM -0400, Daniel Jacobowitz wrote:
> On Fri, Aug 20, 2004 at 03:24:58PM -0400, Bob Rossi wrote:
> > > > > Heck, parse it into XML if you'd like.
> > > > 
> > > > I don't want the data to be in XML. I just want the data without writing
> > > > a parser. and a protocol that is backwards compatible. This seems like a
> > > > simple think to ask for.
> > > > 
> > > > If GDB expects to have one common MI library, than it should distribute
> > > > a library that is responsible for reading it's own output, and giving
> > > > the user some data structures that will be backwards compatible. Thus, a
> > > > library to link against.
> > > 
> > > So, it would be a waste of your time to write a parser that all future
> > > front ends could use, but not a waste of GDB developers' time to carry
> > > out major incompatible surgery on GDB's output format for people that
> > > already parse MI?
> > 
> > What? I am saying that if GDB wants to stick with this self invented
> > grammer and decides that it is obviously silly to have all of the
> > consumers reinventing the wheel, it should write a library that parses
> > the MI output and give it to the user in some sort of ADT. Making the
> > protocol transparent. If this existed, I would be satisfied.
> > 
> > I wouldn't expect anyone but myself and people that believed in the idea
> > to carry out the surgery. I am not asking for a present.
> 
> That's what I was suggesting you do - write that library.

I am not interested in writing this library. I am interested in the XML
approach. Do you know why yet? It's because I won't have to write a
library. No one will. Ever.

> > I feel that an XML approach will save developers time over the long run
> > and that inventing a grammer to parse on output was a mistake in the
> > first place. 
> > 
> > Is the *main* argument to stick with MI because there is already a
> > customer base?
> 
> There's no "main" argument, but there seem to be lots of existing
> arguments.  Myself, I don't have much reason to care, but I agree with
> Chris that typiing XML by hand is a real pain, but MI is manageable
> (and I do it periodically).
> 
> I don't think that using XML would change anything.  Several people
> have already presented my opinion better than I could.

You are missing the point. It would change the amount of work a front
end writer had to do to implement to GDB.  XML is clearly a better
approach to communicating data between 2 entities. It is a proven
technique that has parsers written in many languages.

Changing the MI output to XML would greatly reduce the amount of time
and code written to interface with GDB. Period. I strongly believe there
is no argument against this point.

Other reasons for not wanting to switch to XML seem relavant, such as,
typeing XML commands to talk to GDB. However, I have two arguments to
that. 
   If you were to send XML commands to GDB, most of the time they would
   be short.
   <next/>

   Second, the commands sent to GDB don't have to be XML, although I
   think that they should be.

BTW, how does one go about getting a yes/no answer to such an RFC? Do I
need the approval of the majority of GDB contributors? maintainers?

Also, why haven't some of the maintainers of MI responded at all on this
subject? Andrew or Elena? Fernando are you the main contact as far as
decisions on the MI code goes?

Thanks,
Bob Rossi

  reply	other threads:[~2004-08-20 19:59 UTC|newest]

Thread overview: 215+ messages / expand[flat|nested]  mbox.gz  Atom feed  top
     [not found] <5956F1E2-EB0D-11D8-9949-000A9569836A@apple.com>
2004-08-11  0:51 ` Chris Friesen
     [not found]   ` <gdb001@speakeasy.net>
2004-08-11  6:28     ` Felix Lee
2004-08-11  8:25       ` Chris Friesen
2004-08-11 22:43     ` Felix Lee
2004-08-12  4:54       ` OT: " Chris Friesen
2004-08-20 10:34     ` Felix Lee
2004-08-20 12:54       ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-20 18:34         ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-08-20 18:49           ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-20 18:52             ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-08-20 19:25               ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-20 19:42                 ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-08-20 19:59                   ` Bob Rossi [this message]
2004-08-21 10:25                     ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-08-21 12:34                       ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-21 13:34                         ` Eli Zaretskii
     [not found]         ` <bob@brasko.net>
2004-08-20 18:20           ` Felix Lee
2004-08-20 21:34           ` Felix Lee
2004-08-21 19:21           ` Felix Lee
2004-08-21 20:21             ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-21 19:28           ` Felix Lee
2004-08-21 20:16             ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-21 21:28           ` Felix Lee
2004-08-21 22:37           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-03 18:36           ` GDB/MI snapshots between major release's Felix Lee
2004-10-03 18:40             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-03 18:42               ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-03 19:35                 ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-03 19:39           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-03 20:19             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04  5:00           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-04 15:34           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-04 15:58             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04 16:48           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-04 17:37             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04 18:31           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-04 19:00             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04 21:07           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-03 17:01             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04  5:04               ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-04 14:59                 ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04 15:49                   ` Mark Kettenis
2004-10-04 16:04                     ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-05 10:57                       ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-05 14:18                         ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-06  1:40                           ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 11:14                           ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-06 11:39                             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 13:19                               ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-06 16:55                                 ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 17:00                                   ` Paul Koning
2004-10-06 17:02                                     ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04 21:27             ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-04 22:14             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-05  9:03               ` Fabian Cenedese
2004-10-05  9:18                 ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-05 13:37                   ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-05 18:53           ` probing GDB for MI versions Felix Lee
2004-10-06 17:14           ` GDB/MI snapshots between major release's Felix Lee
2004-10-06 17:21             ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-06 18:41           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-06 18:50             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 18:55           ` Bumping MI protocol Felix Lee
2004-10-06 19:43             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 21:04           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-07 18:01           ` probing GDB for MI versions Felix Lee
2004-10-07 19:44             ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-08  8:54               ` Fabian Cenedese
2004-10-19 20:13           ` Felix Lee
2004-10-19 20:23             ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-19 21:27             ` Bob Rossi
2004-11-09  2:27             ` Bob Rossi
2005-10-10 20:46 Laziness David Lecomber
2005-10-10 20:50 ` Laziness Daniel Jacobowitz
2005-10-10 21:05   ` Laziness David Lecomber
2005-10-10 21:09     ` Laziness Daniel Jacobowitz
2005-10-10 21:24       ` Laziness David Lecomber
2005-10-10 21:27         ` Laziness Daniel Jacobowitz
2005-10-10 23:53           ` Laziness Paul Hilfinger
     [not found] <200508292030.NAA29909@hpsje.cup.hp.com>
     [not found] ` <1125360166.9350.69.camel@aretha.corp.specifix.com>
2005-08-30  1:13   ` HP gdb/wdb sources available Daniel Jacobowitz
2005-08-30  2:13     ` Paul Hilfinger
  -- strict thread matches above, loose matches on Subject: below --
2004-10-26 14:49 backtrace changes current source location Felix Lee
2004-10-28 13:49 ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-06  1:03 Bumping MI protocol Bob Rossi
2004-10-06  5:08 ` Nathan J. Williams
2004-10-06 11:27   ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 12:30     ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-06 16:38       ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 16:45         ` Nathan J. Williams
2004-10-06 19:53           ` Bob Rossi
     [not found]       ` <eliz@gnu.org>
2004-10-06 16:57         ` Felix Lee
2004-10-06 17:03           ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04 17:51 gdbserver, sysroot, prelink Felix Lee
2004-10-04 18:12 ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-03 17:15 probing GDB for MI versions Bob Rossi
2004-10-04  9:00 ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-04 13:19   ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-05  9:10     ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-05 12:34       ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 10:19         ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-06 11:47           ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 12:13             ` Dave Korn
2004-10-06 16:31               ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 16:46                 ` Nathan J. Williams
2004-10-06 16:55                   ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 17:04                     ` Nathan J. Williams
2004-10-06 17:15                       ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 16:57                 ` Dave Korn
2004-10-06 17:12                   ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 17:21                     ` Dave Korn
2004-10-06 17:24                       ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 17:31                         ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-06 17:38                           ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 17:41                             ` Dave Korn
2004-10-06 17:55                               ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 18:19                                 ` Paul Koning
2004-10-07 10:56                                 ` Dave Korn
2004-10-07 14:15                                   ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-07 14:28                                     ` Dave Korn
2004-10-07 14:37                                       ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-07 14:39                                         ` Dave Korn
2004-10-07 14:50                                           ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-07 15:38                                             ` Dave Korn
2004-10-07 15:49                                               ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-07 16:31                                                 ` Nathan J. Williams
2004-10-07 16:45                                                 ` Alain Magloire
2004-10-07 17:12                                                 ` Dave Korn
     [not found]                                                 ` <200410071614.MAA19648@smtp.ott.qnx.com>
2004-10-08  6:56                                                   ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-08  9:10                                                     ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-10 18:13                                                       ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-11 17:46                                                         ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-13 12:14                                                         ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-13 12:48                                                           ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-13 14:05                                                             ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-14  7:10                                                               ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-14 19:34                                                                 ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-14 21:23                                                                   ` Andrew Cagney
2004-10-15 15:40                                                                     ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-15 13:02                                                                   ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-15 13:28                                                                     ` Michael Chastain
2004-10-15 13:42                                                                       ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-15 18:04                                                                     ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-16 15:46                                                                       ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-16 21:56                                                                         ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-17 18:59                                                                           ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-19 13:51                                                                             ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-19 14:18                                                                               ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-19 19:28                                                                                 ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-19 20:17                                                                                 ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-06 18:43                               ` Andrew Cagney
2004-10-06 18:54                                 ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 19:19                                   ` Andrew Cagney
2004-10-06 19:25                                     ` 'Bob Rossi'
2004-10-06 17:36                         ` Dave Korn
2004-10-06 17:51                         ` Paul Koning
2004-10-06 18:09                           ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 17:05                 ` Alain Magloire
2004-10-06 19:16 ` Andrew Cagney
2004-10-06 19:20   ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 20:10     ` Alain Magloire
2004-10-06 20:15       ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-06 20:13     ` Andrew Cagney
2004-10-08 10:28       ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-10-08 18:48         ` Daniel Jacobowitz
     [not found] <message on Sat, 21 Aug 2004 14:28:52 PDT from Felix Lee <felix.1@canids.net>
2004-08-22  2:55 ` GDB/XMI (XML Machine Interface) Felix Lee
2004-08-23  0:33   ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-23  9:27   ` Fabian Cenedese
     [not found] <1092177534.30930.ezmlm@sources.redhat.com>
2004-08-10 23:02 ` Jim Ingham
2004-08-10 20:14 Bob Rossi
2004-08-10 22:38 ` Kip Macy
2004-08-11  0:17 ` Michael Chastain
2004-08-11  7:36 ` Fabian Cenedese
2004-08-11  8:51 ` Nick NoSpam
2004-08-11 18:05 ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-11 19:26   ` Alain Magloire
2004-08-11 22:35     ` Jason Molenda
2004-08-12 13:03       ` Nick NoSpam
2004-08-19 23:49 ` Bob Rossi
2004-08-20  7:09   ` Chris Friesen
2004-08-20 12:47     ` Bob Rossi
2004-07-29  5:10 breaking at for-loop test line Allen Hopkins
2004-07-29 16:29 ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-07-29 18:58   ` Andre Ancelin
2004-07-30 11:32   ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-08-03 19:21     ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-08-03 20:09       ` Andrew Cagney
2004-08-03 20:21         ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-07-25  1:18 [proposal/testsuite] require build == host Michael Chastain
2004-07-25  1:52 ` Felix Lee
2004-07-25  2:43   ` Daniel Jacobowitz
     [not found]     ` <drow@false.org>
2004-07-25 22:36       ` Felix Lee
2004-07-26 18:07         ` Michael Chastain
2004-07-27  4:41           ` Felix Lee
2004-07-29 22:21       ` breaking at for-loop test line Felix Lee
2004-07-30  8:23         ` Baurjan Ismagulov
     [not found]           ` <ibr@ata.cs.hun.edu.tr>
2004-07-30 10:46             ` Felix Lee
2004-08-03 18:53               ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-08-20 19:06       ` GDB/XMI (XML Machine Interface) Felix Lee
2004-08-20 19:09         ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-08-20 19:20       ` Felix Lee
2004-08-21 12:37         ` Bob Rossi
2004-10-04 19:05       ` gdbserver, sysroot, prelink Felix Lee
2004-10-04 19:24         ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-05 13:03           ` Andrew Cagney
2004-10-05 13:52             ` Daniel Jacobowitz
2004-10-05 13:53       ` Felix Lee
2004-10-06 17:58       ` GDB/MI snapshots between major release's Felix Lee
2004-10-29  8:32       ` backtrace changes current source location Felix Lee
2004-07-25  7:59 ` [proposal/testsuite] require build == host Eli Zaretskii
2004-07-27  0:45 ` Andrew Cagney
2004-07-27  2:31   ` Michael Chastain
2004-07-27  4:16     ` Eli Zaretskii
2004-07-27 15:32     ` Andrew Cagney
2004-07-27 15:50       ` Christopher Faylor
2004-07-27 21:17       ` Michael Chastain

Reply instructions:

You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:

* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
  and reply-to-all from there: mbox

  Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style

* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
  switches of git-send-email(1):

  git send-email \
    --in-reply-to=20040820195928.GA6372@white \
    --to=bob@brasko.net \
    --cc=cagney@redhat.com \
    --cc=ezannoni@redhat.com \
    --cc=fnasser@redhat.com \
    --cc=gdb@sources.redhat.com \
    /path/to/YOUR_REPLY

  https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html

* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
  via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line before the message body.
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for read-only IMAP folder(s) and NNTP newsgroup(s).